Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Goods and Services Tax

Supplier’s Later Disappearance Alone Cannot Deny GST ITC: Madras HC

Summary: The Madras High Court’s  decision in Tvl. Sri Sakthi Enterprises Vs State Tax Officer, WP (MD) Nos. 31489 to 31492 of 2026 Dated 10/11/2026, highlights the need for evidence-based adjudication of input tax credit claims where a supplier is subsequently found missing from its registered premises. According to the available report, the Court set aside four GST assessment orders and directed reconsideration because an inspection conducted in April 2025 could not, by itself, establish that supplies relating to earlier tax periods were fictitious. The purchaser had furnished invoices, e-way bills, banking records, chartered accountant certificates, weighbridge receipts and transport documents that required meaningful examination. The article, authored by S. Prasad, GST Practitioner, Mysore, examines the distinction between subsequent supplier non-existence and the genuineness of earlier transactions, the statutory power of retrospective cancellation under Section 29(2), and the purchaser’s burden under Sections 16 and 155 of the CGST Act. It also discusses the related Madras High Court decisions in Engineering Tools Corporation and Clear Secured Service Private Limited, emphasising that neither retrospective cancellation nor an adverse supplier investigation automatically determines a purchaser’s credit entitlement. Particular attention is given to fraud-based demands under Section 74, the applicability of Section 74A from FY 2024–25, and practical steps for preparing replies and writ petitions. The central principle is that taxpayers must substantiate their transactions, while assessing authorities must examine the evidence, provide a fair hearing and issue reasoned orders. The relief reported was reconsideration, not unconditional allowance of ITC.

Supplier’s Later Disappearance Cannot Decide a Buyer’s ITC Claim – Madras High Court reinforces the need to examine transaction records, give a fair hearing and avoid mechanical GST demands

A supplier is found missing from its registered premises during a departmental inspection. By then, the purchaser may have received the goods, paid the invoice through the banking system, recorded the purchases and sold or consumed the goods in business. Can the subsequent inspection, by itself, justify rejection of the purchaser’s input tax credit?

The  Madras High Court’s  decision in Tvl. Sri Sakthi Enterprises Vs State Tax Officer, WP (MD) Nos. 31489 to 31492 of 2026 Dated 10/11/2026, addresses this important distinction. According to the available report, the Court set aside four orders and directed fresh consideration because the supplier’s non-existence during an investigation in April 2025 could not, by itself, decide the genuineness of transactions relating to earlier tax periods. The purchaser’s documents required proper examination.

The decision offers meaningful support to businesses facing demands based principally on a supplier’s subsequent disappearance. Its value, however, must be stated accurately: the Court ordered reconsideration; it did not grant unconditional credit or dispense with the statutory requirements for claiming ITC.

Advertisement

The dispute: documents produced, but the later inspection prevailed

In Sri Sakthi Enterprises, the petitioner challenged four orders described in the report as having been passed under Section 74 of the applicable GST enactments. The reported tax periods included 2022–23, March 2024 and 2024–25. The petitioner’s case was that its replies and supporting records had not received proper consideration. Those records included invoices, e-way bills, bank statements, chartered accountant certificates, weighbridge receipts and lorry receipts.

The department’s objection centred on an investigation conducted in April 2025, when the supplier was found not to be carrying on business at its declared premises. The orders treated the purchaser’s documents as insufficient to establish receipt of goods because of that later finding.

This was the weakness in the assessment approach. An inspection establishes facts found at the time of inspection. Without supporting material connecting that finding to the earlier transactions, it cannot automatically establish that the supplier never operated there or that goods were never supplied during the relevant period. The Court therefore required the assessing authority to reconsider the documents instead of treating the subsequent inspection as decisive.

According to the report, all four orders were set aside. The authority was directed to provide a reasonable opportunity, consider the documents and issue a speaking order within five months of receiving the judgment.

Later non-existence and earlier non-existence are not the same

The distinction may appear simple, but it has considerable practical importance.

A finding that a supplier was not functioning at an address in April 2025 does not, without more, answer whether that supplier supplied goods in 2022–23 or March 2024. The relevant enquiry concerns the circumstances of the transactions when they occurred—not merely the supplier’s position when the department eventually visited the premises. That is the central evidentiary point emerging from the reported decision.

Equally, a purchaser cannot establish eligibility merely by saying that the supplier once held a GST registration. The enquiry must address the actual supply and the supporting records. The Madras High Court’s approach preserves both sides of that enquiry: the taxpayer must substantiate the claim, and the officer must examine that substantiation rather than reject it through a general conclusion about the supplier.

The question is not whether the department may investigate a doubtful supplier. It plainly may. The question is whether the result of that investigation has been properly connected to the particular credit claimed by the purchaser.

Section 29(2): retrospective cancellation is a statutory power, not an automatic consequence

Retrospective cancellation frequently becomes the starting point for disputes of this nature. The legal position needs careful expression.

Section 29(2) expressly permits the proper officer, where the statutory grounds exist, to cancel registration from a date that may include a retrospective date. It would therefore be incorrect to suggest that retrospective cancellation is prohibited in every case. The same provision, however, expressly requires an opportunity of being heard before cancellation.

The existence of the power does not make every exercise of it justified. In examining a cancellation order, the registered person should distinguish three questions:

  • What statutory ground is alleged?
  • Was a meaningful opportunity given to answer that allegation?
  • What material supports the effective date selected, particularly where cancellation is made retrospective?

These questions arise from the structure of Section 29(2), which deals both with the grounds for cancellation and the date from which cancellation may operate, while expressly preserving the hearing requirement.

There is also a separate question concerning the purchaser. Cancellation of the supplier’s registration and determination of the purchaser’s ITC are not interchangeable exercises. In Engineering Tools Corporation, the Madras High Court expressly directed that ITC should not be rejected solely because the supplier’s registration had been cancelled retrospectively. The genuineness of the transactions had to be examined through the relevant documents.

The distinction is essential. A registration order concerning one person cannot become a substitute for a reasoned adjudication of another person’s credit claim.

The taxpayer’s burden does not remove the officer’s duty

Sections 16 and 155 form an important part of this discussion. The claimant must establish entitlement to ITC; the burden cannot be avoided merely by pointing to procedural defects in the department’s case. At the same time, that burden does not permit the authority to disregard relevant evidence once it is furnished.

This balance was clearly expressed in Clear Secured Service Private Limited v. Assistant Commissioner (ST), reported as W.P. No. 23402 of 2026, decided on 1 July 2026. The taxpayer had produced bank statements, tax invoices, e-way bills, ledger extracts and GSTR-2A/GSTR-2B records. The Court recognised the taxpayer’s burden but held that these documents required due consideration. If the material was deficient, the taxpayer should have received an opportunity to furnish further evidence.

The practical meaning is straightforward. An officer may find a document unreliable, incomplete or inconsistent with other evidence. But the order should explain the defect. Merely listing the documents and then repeating that the supplier was “non-existent” does not answer what those documents were produced to establish. That is the adjudicatory failure against which these decisions provide protection.

The earlier decision involving Shikhar Technologies

The related authority should be identified correctly. Shikhar Technologies was the supplier involved in Engineering Tools Corporation v. Assistant Commissioner (ST); it was not the name of the petitioner in that decision.

In Engineering Tools Corporation, W.P. No. 3505 of 2024, decided on 15 February 2024, the purchaser challenged reversal of ITC following retrospective cancellation of its supplier’s registration. The purchases related to 2017–18, and the purchaser relied on transaction records and payment through regular banking channels.

The Court observed that the purchaser could be required to establish the supplier’s existence at the relevant time and prove the genuineness of the transactions through documents such as invoices, transport records, delivery challans and payment evidence. However, the assessment could not rest on inadequate reasoning. The matter was remanded with an express direction not to reject the claim solely on the ground of retrospective cancellation.

Read together, Engineering Tools Corporation, Clear Secured Service and the reported Sri Sakthi Enterprises decision support a consistent approach: supplier-related findings warrant scrutiny, but the purchaser’s transaction records must still be examined. These are related decisions discussed together here; the available report of Sri Sakthi Enterprises does not state that the Court cited the other two judgments.

Why Section 74 demands require particular care

A demand under Section 74 involves more than an ordinary disagreement over eligibility. The provision addresses tax or credit issues arising by reason of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax. An allegation carrying those consequences requires attention to the statutory ingredients, not merely the use of the provision’s number in a notice or order.

Where the case against a purchaser rest principally on a supplier’s subsequent non-existence, two distinct matters require examination:

  • Whether the credit is inadmissible on the evidence.
  • Whether the alleged wrongful credit arose by reason of the fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression required by Section 74.

The second question should not be treated as automatically answered by the first. A later adverse finding against a supplier does not, without the necessary factual connection, explain the purchaser’s alleged conduct. This is an important pleading distinction arising from the terms of Section 74 and the evidentiary approach adopted in these decisions.

Clear Secured Service presents an additional procedural concern. The Court noted that the show-cause notice referred to Section 73 in more than one place, whereas the assessment order was passed under Section 74. That discrepancy formed part of the Court’s reasons for setting aside the order and directing reconsideration.

A current-law qualification is also necessary. Sections 73 and 74 govern determination for periods up to FY 2023–24, while Section 74A applies to FY 2024–25 onwards. Since the available report of Sri Sakthi Enterprises mentions both Section 74 and a period in FY 2024–25, the original judgment and underlying orders should be examined before drawing conclusions about that particular aspect. The report should not be treated as authority permitting Section 74 to be used indiscriminately for later periods.

Five practical lessons for replies and writ pleadings

1. Put the chronology before the allegation

Prepare a clear statement showing the invoice dates, movement and receipt of goods, payment dates, date of departmental inspection and effective date of cancellation. This brings the central issue into focus: whether a later finding has been used, without an adequate connecting enquiry, to reject earlier transactions.

2. Establish receipt, not merely invoicing

Do not leave the defence at the invoice stage. Where available and applicable, correlate invoices with e-way bills, lorry receipts, weighbridge slips, delivery acknowledgements, stock records and payment entries. The records considered in the Madras cases demonstrate the importance of presenting the transaction as a connected sequence rather than a bundle of unrelated papers.

3. Identify what the order failed to answer

A strong reply or challenge should specify which documents were submitted, what each document established and how the authority dealt with it. The precise grievance is often not that documents were absent from the file, but that their evidentiary value was never meaningfully considered.

4. Separate the cancellation issue from the credit issue

If the taxpayer’s own registration is cancelled, examine the statutory ground, hearing and retrospective date under Section 29(2). If the taxpayer is a purchaser facing ITC reversal, address the supplier-related allegation while independently establishing the purchases. These are distinct disputes and should not be pleaded as though success on one automatically decides the other.

5. Meet the fraud allegation separately

Where Section 74 applies, answer the alleged fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression specifically. Also compare the provision and allegations in the notice with those in the final order. Clear Secured Service shows why a change from a Section 73 notice to a Section 74 order cannot be passed over as an insignificant detail.

What businesses should—and should not—take from these judgments

These decisions are useful because they insist upon an evidence-based decision. They do not declare that every invoice creates an indefeasible right to credit, that every retrospective cancellation is unlawful, or that every purchaser must succeed irrespective of the statutory conditions. The relief granted was reconsideration after proper examination and opportunity.

Their practical strength lies elsewhere. They enable a taxpayer to insist that an officer answer the actual case: Were the goods supplied? What do the movement and payment records show? Why are particular documents unacceptable? How does the later investigation establish anything adverse about the earlier transaction?

For departmental officers, the decisions offer an equally useful guide. Effective enforcement requires more than an adverse description of the supplier. A sustainable order must connect the investigation to the disputed transactions and explain the treatment of the purchaser’s evidence.

Conclusion

The Madras High Court’s approach protects an important distinction in GST administration: a supplier’s later disappearance is a circumstance requiring investigation, not a complete answer to the purchaser’s claim.

Retrospective cancellation under Section 29(2) must operate within the statute, including its express hearing requirement. A purchaser’s ITC claim must, in turn, be decided on the relevant conditions and evidence—not rejected mechanically because the supplier’s registration was cancelled or the supplier could not be located later.

For genuine businesses, these judgments provide a sound basis to contest orders that substitute suspicion for examination. For the department, they underline the need for reasoned adjudication. The taxpayer must prove the transaction; the authority must fairly decide what that proof establishes. Neither responsibility can be ignored.

Advertisement

Author Info

S PRASAD
Name: S PRASAD
Qualification: Graduate
Company: S.PRASAD AND CO
Location: Mysuru, Karnataka
Articles Published: 196

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *