Deciphering GST: Understanding Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria in Taxable Service Valuation with Real-life Scenarios
Inclusions in the Value of Supply (Section 15(2))
Taxes and Fees (Section 15(2)(a))
All taxes, duties, cesses, fees, and charges levied under any law other than the GST laws (Central Goods and Services Tax Act, State Goods and Services Tax Act, Union Territory Goods and Services Tax Act, and the Goods and Services Tax (Compensation to States) Act) are to be included in the value of supply if they are charged separately by the supplier. This ensures that the base for GST calculation is comprehensive.
Supplier’s Liabilities Incurred by the Recipient (Section 15(2)(b))
Any amount that the supplier is liable to pay in relation to the supply, but which is incurred by the recipient and not included in the price actually paid or payable for the goods or services, must be added to the value of supply. This inclusion accounts for costs that should have been borne by the supplier but are instead paid by the recipient.
Incidental Expenses (Section 15(2)(c))
Incidental expenses such as commission, packing, and any other amount charged for anything done by the supplier in respect of the supply of goods or services at the time of, or before, delivery of goods or supply of services are included. This ensures that all costs directly related to the supply are part of the taxable value.
Interest or Late Fee or Penalty (Section 15(2)(d))
Any interest, late fee, or penalty for delayed payment of any consideration for the supply is included in the value of supply. This ensures that the entire amount paid for the supply, including penalties for late payment, is taxed.
Subsidies (Section 15(2)(e))
Subsidies directly linked to the price, excluding subsidies provided by the Central and State Governments, are included in the value of supply. This provision ensures that any financial assistance related to the supply is considered in the taxable value.
Exclusions from the Value of Supply (Section 15(3))
Pre-Supply Discounts (Section 15(3)(a))
Discounts given before or at the time of the supply are excluded from the value of supply if such discounts are duly recorded in the invoice issued for the supply. This allows businesses to reduce the taxable value by any agreed-upon discounts.
Post-Supply Discounts (Section 15(3)(b))
Discounts provided after the supply can be excluded if:
- The discount is established in terms of an agreement entered into at or before the time of such supply and specifically linked to relevant invoices.
- The recipient of the supply reverses the input tax credit attributable to the discount.
Special Cases and Exceptions
Supplies Not Wholly in Money (Rule 27)
When consideration is not wholly in money, the value is determined by:
i. The open market value of the supply.
ii. The sum total of money and the monetary equivalent of non-monetary consideration if open market value is not available.
iii. The value of similar goods or services if neither of the above is determinable.
iv. The residual method under Rule 30 or Rule 31 if the above methods are inapplicable.
Pure Agent Concept (Rule 33)
Expenses incurred by a supplier acting as a pure agent of the recipient are excluded from the value of supply if:
i. The supplier acts on authorization from the recipient.
ii. Payments made are separately indicated in the invoice.
iii. The supplier provides these supplies in addition to their own services.
Practical Examples:
Inclusion Criteria:
1. Consulting Services with Additional Charges:
– Scenario: Consultant A provides advisory services to Client B for ₹50,000. Additionally, A charges ₹5,000 for preparing a detailed report.
– Inclusion: Both the advisory fee and the report preparation charges are included in the taxable value of the service.
2. Construction Services with Material Costs:
– Scenario: Construction Company C constructs a commercial building for Client D. The total cost of construction, including materials, is ₹1 crore.
– Inclusion: The entire cost of construction, including materials, is considered in the taxable value of the service.
3. Transportation Services with Fuel Charges:
– Scenario: Transporter T delivers goods to Customer C for ₹10,000. Additionally, T incurs ₹2,000 on fuel expenses during transportation.
– Inclusion: The transportation charges and the fuel expenses are included in the taxable value of the service.
4. Training Services with Material Costs:
– Scenario: Training Company T conducts a workshop for Corporation C at ₹1,00,000. T provides training materials worth ₹10,000 to each participant.
– Inclusion: The training fee and the cost of training materials provided to participants are included in the taxable value of the service.
5. Interior Design Services with Procurement Costs:
– Scenario: Interior Designer D renovates an office space for Business B at ₹5,00,000. D procures furniture and decor items for ₹1,00,000.
– Inclusion: The renovation fee and the cost of procured furniture and decor items are included in the taxable value of the service.
6. Marketing Services with Advertising Expenses:
– Scenario: Marketing Agency M creates a marketing campaign for Client C at ₹2,00,000. M spends ₹50,000 on advertising placements.
– Inclusion: The marketing fee and the expenses incurred on advertising placements are included in the taxable value of the service.
7. Training Services with Certification Fees:
– Scenario: Training Institute T conducts a certification course for Professionals P at ₹50,000 per participant. T charges an additional ₹5,000 for certification.
– Inclusion: The course fee and the certification fee are both included in the taxable value of the training service.
8. Consulting Services with Travel Expenses:
– Scenario: Consultant C provides advisory services to Business B at ₹1,00,000. C incurs ₹20,000 in travel expenses while visiting B’s office.
– Inclusion: The consulting fee and the travel expenses incurred by the consultant are both included in the taxable value of the service.
9. Event Management Services with Venue Rental:
– Scenario: Event Planner E organizes a corporate event for Company C at ₹5,00,000. E also arranges for venue rental at a cost of ₹1,00,000.
– Inclusion: The event planning fee and the cost of venue rental are both included in the taxable value of the event management service.
Exclusion Criteria:
1. Accounting Services with Government Fees:
– Scenario: Accounting Firm A provides financial auditing services to Company C at ₹1,50,000. A pays ₹20,000 in government auditing fees on behalf of C.
– Exclusion: The government auditing fees paid on behalf of the client are excluded from the taxable value of the accounting service.
2. Translation Services with Translation Software Costs:
– Scenario: Translator T translates documents for Business B at ₹50 per page. T uses translation software with an annual subscription fee of ₹10,000.
– Exclusion: The annual subscription fee for translation software is excluded from the taxable value of the translation service.
3. IT Support Services with Hardware Purchase:
– Scenario: IT Support Provider I offers technical support to Client C at ₹20,000 per month. I purchases hardware components worth ₹30,000 for C’s systems.
– Exclusion: The cost of hardware components purchased for the client’s systems is excluded from the taxable value of the IT support service.
4. Legal Services with Court Filing Charges:
– Scenario: Law Firm L provides legal advice to Individual I at ₹50,000. L incurs ₹5,000 in court filing charges on behalf of I.
– Exclusion: The court filing charges incurred by the law firm on behalf of the client are excluded from the taxable value of the legal service.
5. Software Development Services with License Fees:
– Scenario: Software Company S develops a custom software solution for Client C at ₹2,00,000. S also charges a license fee of ₹50,000 for using proprietary software.
– Exclusion: The license fee for proprietary software is excluded from the taxable value of the software development service.
6. Marketing Services with Printing Costs:
– Scenario: Marketing Agency M designs a marketing campaign for Business B at ₹3,00,000. M incurs ₹50,000 in printing costs for promotional materials.
– Exclusion: The printing costs incurred by the marketing agency for promotional materials are excluded from the taxable value of the marketing service.
7. Legal Services with Reimbursable Expenses:
– Scenario: Law Firm L provides legal representation to Client C for ₹50,000. L also incurs ₹10,000 in court filing fees, which is reimbursed by C.
– Exclusion: The reimbursable court filing fees are excluded from the taxable value of the legal service.
8. Event Management Services with Third-party Costs:
– Scenario: Event Planner E organizes a conference for Company A at ₹1 lakh. E hires a catering service for ₹20,000, which is paid directly by A.
– Exclusion: The cost of the catering service paid directly by A is excluded from the taxable value of the event management service.
9. Software Development Services with License Fees:
– Scenario: Software Company S develops a custom software solution for Client C at ₹2 lakh. Additionally, S charges a license fee of ₹50,000 for proprietary software.
– Exclusion: The license fee for proprietary software is excluded from the taxable value of the software development service.
****
Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and illustrative purposes only. While efforts have been made to ensure accuracy, the examples and scenarios presented are hypothetical and simplified for clarity. Readers are advised to consult relevant authorities or professionals for specific guidance on tax matters, as tax laws and regulations may vary by jurisdiction and change over time. The author disclaims any liability for any loss or damage arising directly or indirectly from the use of or reliance on the information provided in this article.
Author Bio
