CA Bhanu Prudhviraj
Issue of Credit notes is an age old practice in business environment. They are issued by supplier to buyer for the sales return transactions. In GST there will be a tax component in each & every taxable supply transaction. When there is a supply of goods or services, supplier is liable to pay GST on such transactions. However, in credit note transactions, complexity is involved in adjustment of Output Tax liability for supplier & reversal of Input Tax Credit claimed by the recipient on such returned goods.
In this article let us briefly identify the challenges involved in Credit notes transactions in light of GST Annual Returns & Department Circular 72/46/2018-GST dated 26.10.2018.
In terms of Section 34 of CGST Act 2017, the supplier of goods or services is permitted to issue credit notes in very specific situations:
From the above it is clear that GST credit notes can be issued only by supplier of goods and services in the situations stipulated above. In GST while dealing with Credit note transactions both output liability and outward taxable supply turnover of supplier stand reduced in supplier’s GST returns. Similarly, the recipient returning the goods is liable to reverse input tax credit availed on returned goods or services in his GSTR 3B.
In this regard, the attention to proviso to Section 34(2) is required, where reduction in output liability of supplier is not permitted, if the incidence of tax and interest on such supply has been passed on to any other person. Therefore, the supplier is not permitted to issue GST Credit notes when recipient availed Input tax credit on returned goods.
Due to non operation of GSTR 2 and GSTR 3, it is a challenge for supplier to verify whether input tax credit was availed by the receiver on returned goods or not. When there were multiple invoices with different dealers it would be much more difficult for suppliers to monitor input tax credit status for each and every dealer on returned goods.
For these reasons, the supplier may issue credit note reducing the value of original supply without disturbing the tax component on original supply. Such credit notes are referred as ‘Financial Credit notes’. In financial credit notes, the recipient is entitled for full input tax credit on original supply without reversing any Input tax Credit on returned goods. In supplier books of accounts they would have been duly recorded by adjusting in taxable sales without declaring the same in his GST Returns, as it does not affect output tax payable.
However, the value of financial credit notes should be declared against Part II Sl.No. 5J of GSTR 9C as ‘Credit notes accounted for in the audited Annual financial statement but are not permissible under GST’
Let us illustrate in what situations financial credit notes can be issued by the supplier
It is relevant to note here that many traders are wrongly issuing GST Credit notes for post supply discount transactions which were not in line with Section 15 read with Section 34 of CGST Act. In this regard, reliance can be placed on advance ruling of Ultratech Cement Limited ( Mahrashtra AAR No. GST-ARA-34/2017-18/B-56, dated 27.6.2018)
Many recipients instead of issuing delivery challan on returned goods they were recognising purchase returns as sale transactions and issuing tax invoices on the same without reversing any input tax credit on returned goods. This procedure was not recognised under Section 34 of CGST Act. To clarify this issue, the department vide Department Circular 72/46/2018-GST dated 26.10.2018 has clarified that for returned goods the dealer can follow either of the two procedures mentioned below.
This clarification ensures to bring uniformity with respect to procedural compliance of returned goods. However, there are certain dealers following hybrid procedure where recipient is issuing tax invoice on returned goods and original supplier is issuing GST Credit notes on the same. There may be various reasons for the same like non recipient of account copy from the supplier in timely manner or non reconciliation of GST Returns with GSTR 2A.
This practice may unnecessarily invite litigation from the department end. For example in GSTR 9 there is Table 8 which mandates reconciliation between GSTR 2A & GSTR 3B Input Tax Credit. The relevant extract of GSTR 9 table 8 is exhibited as under:
In the GST Returns of recipient when hybrid model is followed, the Table 8D will be negative, as Table 8A auto populates net of Input Tax Credit with Credit notes from GSTR 2A. In this situation, the original supplier might have issued credit notes but the recipient might not have recognised the same by not reversing of Input Tax Credit in GSTR 3B. This may result in negative balance in Table 8D of GSTR 9 inviting unnecessary litigation from the department as the same depicts as excess claim of input tax credit in GSTR 3B over GSTR 2A.
So adequate care should be taken by the dealers while dealing with Credit notes in GST Returns by complying with Section 34 read with procedures laid in department Circular 72/46/2018-GST dated 26.10.2018.
( the author of this article can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org )