Addressing Issues in the Issuance of GST Orders and Recovery Proceedings under the GST Act, 2017
The Goods and Services Tax (GST) regime, implemented through the GST Act, 2017, has introduced various provisions to ensure proper taxation and compliance. The GST authorities, under the provisions of Sections 73 and 74, are tasked with issuing orders for the demand of unpaid taxes, penalties, and interest. However, the process of issuing these orders and initiating recovery proceedings has faced several challenges that significantly impact taxpayers’ cash flows and compliance. This article aims to examine the issues related to the issuance of orders, the role of Form GST DRC-07, and the challenges faced by taxpayers in the recovery process.
Time Limits for Issuance of Orders and Demand under the GST Act, 2017
The GST Act prescribes specific time limits within which orders for raising demands under Sections 73 and 74 must be issued. Additionally, the Act allows the issuance of orders under various other sections, including Section 52, 62, 63, 64, 75, 76, 122, 123, 124, 125, 127, 129, and 130. These orders play a crucial role in the assessment and recovery of taxes owed by taxpayers.
Form GST DRC-07 and the Recovery Process
As per Rule 142(5) of the CGST Rules, 2017, a summary of any order issued for raising a demand should be electronically uploaded in Form GST DRC-07. This form specifies the tax amount, interest, penalty, and other charges payable by the taxpayer. The uploaded summary acts as a notice for recovery as per Rule 142(6), making it an essential step for initiating the recovery process.
However, a significant issue arises when GST authorities fail to promptly upload orders or summaries in Form DRC-07 on the GSTN Portal. Without this, the recovery process cannot be effectively initiated. While this should be a routine procedure, a number of issues have come to light due to incorrect or delayed actions by the authorities.
Key Issues Faced by Taxpayers
Several difficulties have been identified by taxpayers during the demand and recovery process. Some of the most pressing concerns include:
1. Multiple Uploads of DRC-07
In many instances, the summary of the order is uploaded multiple times on the GSTN Portal. This results in multiple debits being made to the taxpayer’s E-Liability Ledger, complicating the financial records and creating unnecessary difficulties for taxpayers when trying to manage their liabilities.
2. Incorrect Deduction of Refunds
Another common issue arises when GST authorities process refund applications. While processing refunds, authorities sometimes deduct amounts from the liability ledger, only to release the remaining refund balance. This results in the same tax demand being recovered twice, leading to a double recovery. There is no instant mechanism in place for taxpayers to reclaim the wrongly deducted amount, creating cash flow disruptions.
3. Incorrect Financial Year Reporting
In cases where demand is raised for multiple financial years, authorities sometimes upload a consolidated demand that wrongly reflects a single financial year. When the demand is split into individual years, errors in tax, interest, and penalty amounts further aggravate the issue. These discrepancies create significant complications for taxpayers when reconciling their financials.
4. Wrong Place of Supply for IGST
In certain cases, the place of supply for IGST demands is incorrectly mentioned, which is causing confusion and delays in the correct calculation of tax liabilities, particularly when cross-border transactions are involved.
5. Issues in Adjusting Demand
When a taxpayer pays the demand through Form DRC-03 during an audit or assessment, but the subsequent demand is incorrectly uploaded with wrong amounts or wrong place of supply, it creates difficulties in adjusting the earlier paid amount against the new demand. This issue prevents taxpayers from properly reconciling their liabilities.
6. Challenges with Appeal Pre-Deposit and Refund
Another significant challenge is the issue faced by taxpayers during the appeal process. When making pre-deposit payments for appeals, the incorrect uploading of demand summaries in DRC-07 complicates matters. Additionally, claiming refunds of pre-deposit payments becomes a cumbersome process when the demand summary is inaccurately prepared.
Rectification of Orders – A Crucial Need
While the GST Act provides for the rectification of errors through an application, the authorities are often slow to address such issues. As a result, taxpayers are left in a situation where they cannot get the issues rectified in a timely manner, and the window for filing an appeal may close before the issue is resolved.
The delay in rectification or failure to update the records on the GSTN Portal has a serious impact on taxpayers’ business operations, causing cash flow disruptions and increased compliance costs.
A Call for Immediate Action
Given the severe impact of these issues on taxpayers, it is imperative that the authorities address the challenges related to the rectification of GST orders and recovery processes. To improve the situation, the following steps can be considered:
- Priority for Rectification of Orders: Authorities should expedite the disposal of rectification applications to avoid the expiration of the appeal period.
- Creation of Dedicated Rectification Cells: Establishing dedicated cells at each GST Commissionerate to promptly resolve issues related to erroneous orders and discrepancies in demand summaries can provide immediate relief to taxpayers.
- Automation and Real-Time Updates: Incorporating automated systems and real-time updates for the correction of orders can reduce the chances of errors and ensure timely action.
Conclusion
The issues related to the manual issuance of orders, the multiple uploads of DRC-07, and incorrect reporting of demands are causing significant challenges for taxpayers. These issues not only affect compliance but also harm the taxpayers’ financial standing due to delayed refunds and double recoveries. To resolve these concerns, it is essential for the GST authorities to prioritize the rectification of errors and create a more efficient and transparent system for the recovery process. By implementing these improvements, the government can enhance the ease of doing business and provide a more efficient, taxpayer-friendly GST regime.
I hope this article helps you understand the issues and provides guidance. In case of any query, you can reach out to me on cacs.bhagyashri@gmail.com
Author Bio
