Case Law Details
SMS Logistics Vs Commissioner of Customs (General) (Delhi High Court)
Introduction: In the case of SMS Logistics vs. Commissioner of Customs, the appellant, a customs broker, was accused of contravening certain regulations, leading to disciplinary proceedings. This article delves into the allegations against the appellant, the relevant regulations, and the analysis of the punishment imposed in this context.
Detailed Analysis: The appellant faced allegations of contravening Regulations 11(d), 11(e), and 11(m) of the CBLR-2013. These regulations pertain to advising clients on compliance, diligence in providing information, and prompt discharge of duties, respectively.
The central issue revolved around a sale transaction between TDAAL and IDDSL. The respondent argued that filing a Bill of Entry in the name of TDAAL violated the Customs Act. However, it was argued that even if the sale was incorrectly reflected as a High Sea Sale (HSS), the error was not of material consequence. Moreover, the appellant questioned why the Bill of Entry should be filed by the seller (TDAAL) rather than the purchaser (IDDSL).
Regulations 11(e) and 11(m) require customs brokers to perform their duties with diligence and efficiency. The key question here was whether treating the sale as an HSS instead of a normal sale amounted to non-compliance with these regulations.
Please become a Premium member. If you are already a Premium member, login here to access the full content.