Section 115BAC: Revised Tax Framework for Individuals and HUFs
The Indian taxation landscape is often regarded as intricate, characterized by numerous exemptions, deductions, and varying tax brackets. The Finance Act of 2020 aimed to alleviate this intricacy by introducing an optional tax structure through Section 115BAC of the Income Tax Act, 1961. This provision empowers taxpayers to select between the longstanding tax framework (commonly referred to as the old regime) and a new, streamlined approach with diminished tax rates. However, this simplification necessitates the relinquishment of most exemptions and deductions. The following exposition examines the subtleties of Section 115BAC, evaluating its characteristics, benefits, drawbacks, and practical ramifications.
Principal Characteristics of Section 115BAC
1. Scope of Application
Section 115BAC is applicable to:
Individuals: This includes any individual taxpayer, whether employed, self-employed, or otherwise.
Hindu Undivided Families (HUFs): HUFs are also entitled to opt for the new tax framework.
It is critical to highlight that corporations and partnerships are not eligible under this section.
2. Taxation Rates Under Section 115BAC
The revised tax framework offers lower taxation rates compared to the previous regime. The applicable rates are as follows:
| Total Income (INR) | Tax Rate (%) |
| Up to 2,50,000 | Nil |
| 2,50,001 to 5,00,000 | 5% |
| 5,00,001 to 7,50,000 | 10% |
| 7,50,001 to 10,00,000 | 15% |
| 10,00,001 to 12,50,000 | 20% |
| 12,50,001 to 15,00,000 | 25% |
| Above 15,00,000 | 30% |
These rates provide an alternative to the existing slab rates ranging from 5% to 30% but necessitate numerous deductions and exemptions.
3. Conditions for Choosing the New Framework
Taxpayers aiming to benefit from the reduced taxation rates under Section 115BAC must meet specific conditions:
Exemptions and Deductions Not Applicable:
Numerous exemptions and deductions available under the old regime are not permitted under Section 115BAC. Key exclusions include:
- Standard Deduction(INR 50,000 for salaried individuals under Section 16).
- House Rent Allowance (HRA) under Section 10(13A).
- Deductions under Chapter VI-A: This includes:
- Section 80C (e.g., LIC, PPF, ELSS)
- Section 80D (medical insurance)
- Section 80E (education loan interest)
- Section 80G (donations to specified funds)
- Interest on housing loans under Section 24(b) (for self-occupied properties).
- Leave Travel Allowance (LTA) and additional special allowances.
Permitted Deductions:
In spite of the aforementioned exclusions, several deductions are still allowed:
- Employer’s contribution to the NPS under Section 80CCD(2).
- Standard deduction for family pension (limited to INR 15,000).
4. Selection of the New Framework
Salaried Individuals:
Salaried individuals have the option to alternate between the old and new frameworks each fiscal year during the income tax return filing process.
Nonetheless, if they select the new framework for tax deduction at source (TDS) purposes through their employer, they retain the option to choose the old framework when filing their returns.
Business Owners and Professionals:
Business owners and professionals face more limitations. Once they opt for Section 115BAC, reverting to the old framework is not permitted unless they cease to earn income from their business or profession.
Benefits of Section 115BAC
Reduced Tax Rates: The predominant advantage lies in the lower tax rates, which can result in considerable savings for taxpayers without necessitating major investments or eligible deductions.
Streamlining: The new framework simplifies tax calculations by removing the necessity to monitor multiple exemptions and deductions.
Adaptability: Salaried taxpayers possess the adaptability to assess and alternate between the old and new frameworks annually, based on their financial circumstances.
Advantageous for Specific Taxpayers: Taxpayers who do not invest in tax-saving instruments or have minimal eligible deductions will find the new framework particularly beneficial.
Drawbacks of Section 115BAC
Elimination of Deductions and Exemptions: Taxpayers who depend on exemptions such as HRA and deductions like 80C may perceive the new framework as less appealing.
Unsuitable for High-Investment Taxpayers: Individuals who make significant investments in tax-saving schemes, including PPF, ELSS, and housing loans, may discover that the old framework yields greater benefits.
Minimal Benefits for Lower Income Groups: For those in lower income brackets (below INR 7,50,000), the tax savings under Section 115BAC may not be substantial compared to the old framework, particularly when accounting for deductions such as 80C and 80D.
Comparative Analysis: Traditional vs. Modern Tax Regimes
Example 1: Salaried Individual Without Investments
Gross Income: INR 10,00,000
Deductions Claimed (Traditional Regime): None
| Regime | Taxable Income | Tax Liability (INR) |
| Old Regime | 10,00,000 | 1,12,500 |
| New Regime | 10,00,000 | 75,000 |
In this scenario, the modern regime provides a greater benefit due to the lower tax rates.
Example 2: Salaried Individual With Deductions
Gross Income: INR 10,00,000
Deductions Claimed (Traditional Regime): INR 2,50,000 (80C, 80D, Standard Deduction, etc.)
| Regime | Taxable Income | Tax Liability (INR) |
| Old Regime | 7,50,000 | 52,500 |
| New Regime | 10,00,000 | 75,000 |
In this instance, the traditional regime proves to be more beneficial because of the claimed deductions.
Factors to Consider Before Selecting Section 115BAC
Investment Strategies: Assess whether your investments in tax-saving vehicles such as PPF, ELSS, and housing loans render the traditional regime more advantageous.
Income Bracket: Taxpayers with higher income levels and fewer deductions may find the modern regime more beneficial.
Annual Financial Assessment: For salaried individuals, the option to switch regimes yearly offers significant adaptability, making it crucial to evaluate both alternatives annually.
Employer Factors: Employees choosing the modern regime for TDS purposes should ensure it aligns with their annual tax return submissions.
Practical Considerations
For Employers:
Employers must permit employees to select their preferred regime for TDS calculations; however, this decision does not constrain employees from making different choices during annual tax returns.
For Tax Practitioners:
Tax practitioners should educate clients on the ramifications of both tax regimes and support them in making informed selections reflective of their financial positions.
For Policymakers:
The dual tax structure presents an administrative complication, necessitating vigilant oversight to prevent misuse of the provided flexibility.
Conclusion
Section 115BAC significantly alters the Indian taxation framework by introducing a simplified, lower-rate tax option. While it offers substantial advantages for taxpayers lacking significant deductions, its effectiveness hinges on individual financial circumstances. Taxpayers are encouraged to perform a thorough comparative analysis annually to select the regime that minimizes their tax obligations. For the government, this dual-system strategy strikes a balance between simplicity and adaptability to meet varied taxpayer needs.
As the Indian economy progresses, Section 115BAC stands as an initiative to reconcile tax simplification with fiscal responsibility. Taxpayers and their advisors must remain diligent and well-informed to optimize advantages under this provision.
Author Bio
Pls check whether the above article is correct or not