S V Halavagali and Sons Vs Superintendent of Central Excise & Ors. (Karnataka High Court)
Summary: The Karnataka High Court, in S V Halavagali and Sons Vs Superintendent of Central Excise & Ors., considered whether a taxpayer’s transitional CENVAT credit claim could be rejected merely because the amount was inadvertently reported under the wrong column of Form GST TRAN-1. The petitioner, a partnership firm registered under the Goods and Services Tax law, was engaged in supplying goods falling under Chapters 8432, 31010010 and 10091090. Following scrutiny of its GST returns, the Superintendent of Central Excise, Gadag, issued a show cause notice dated 9 December 2022 seeking an explanation. The petitioner responded and claimed CENVAT credit of ₹6,18,796 relating to Central Excise duty on goods held in stock as on 30 June 2017. A hearing was fixed for 24 January 2023, and the petitioner claimed to have furnished additional supporting documents. Subsequently, another notice dated 6 February 2023 questioned the transitional-credit claim because the petitioner had reported it under Table 7(d) of Form GST TRAN-1 in terms of Rule 117(4) of the CGST Rules, 2017. The department took the view that the petitioner was not entitled to the credit. The petitioner maintained that the entry under Column 7(d), instead of Column 7(b), was an inadvertent mistake and that the necessary invoices and documents were available to establish the claim under the correct column. Challenging the adverse order dated 20 February 2023, the petitioner approached the High Court under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution, seeking its quashing and consideration of the reply dated 13 February 2023.
Before the High Court, the respondents contended that the petitioner had an alternative statutory appellate remedy under Section 107 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017. The petitioner, however, relied on an earlier judgment of the Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court in W.P.(MD) No. 15531 of 2020 and W.M.P.(MD) No. 13042 of 2020, involving an analogous mistake in reporting a transitional-credit claim under an incorrect column. In that case, the taxpayer had entered the claim under Column 7(d) instead of Column 7(a), and the Madras High Court directed the competent authority to verify the supporting materials and grant relief if the claim was found to be established. Justice Anant Ramanath Hegde examined that decision and the petitioner’s records. The Court noted that the petitioner consistently maintained that the correct entry should have been made under Column 7(b), rather than Column 7(d), and asserted that invoices and other relevant documents were available to substantiate the claim. In these circumstances, the Court considered it appropriate to set aside the impugned order and remit the matter to the original authority for fresh consideration. The judgment did not treat the incorrect TRAN-1 entry as automatically establishing eligibility for credit; instead, it recognised the need to examine the substantive claim on the basis of documentary evidence.
Accordingly, the Karnataka High Court set aside the impugned order dated 20 February 2023, produced as Annexure-K, along with the consequential notice produced as Annexure-L, and remitted the matter to the Superintendent of Central Excise for reconsideration. The authority was directed to examine the petitioner’s claim under Column 7(b), provided supporting documents were available, and to grant consequential relief if the claim was established in accordance with law. The Court expressly clarified that it had not expressed any opinion on the merits of the petitioner’s entitlement and that the competent authority must independently determine the claim’s admissibility. It further directed the authority to process the claim within three months from receipt of a copy of the order. The writ petition was disposed of on these terms. The decision demonstrates that an inadvertent error in selecting the appropriate column of GST TRAN-1 need not conclusively defeat a transitional-credit claim when the taxpayer offers supporting documentation. However, the taxpayer remains responsible for establishing eligibility, and the department retains the authority to verify the claim before allowing the credit. The ruling therefore provides procedural relief and an opportunity for substantive examination rather than unconditional sanction of the ₹6,18,796 claimed.
Cases Discussed:
Madras High Court decision in W.P.(MD) No. 15531 of 2020 and W.M.P.(MD) No. 13042 of 2020. The Karnataka High Court examined this precedent, in which a transitional-credit claim was mistakenly entered under Column 7(d) instead of Column 7(a). The Madras High Court had directed the competent authority to verify the supporting documents and grant relief if the claim was established. The uploaded judgment does not identify the parties or decision date of this precedent.
FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT
1. Heard learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and the learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
2. The petitioner is assailing the order dated 20.02.2023 passed by respondent No.1-Superintendent of Central Excise, Gadag and has also sought a direction against respondent No.1 to consider the reply dated 13.02.2023.
3. The petitioner is a partnership firm registered under the Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017. The petitioner is engaged in supply of goods coming under the Chapter 8432, 31010010 and 10091090. Respondent No.1 has issued show cause notice dated 09.12.2022 on the premise that GST returns submitted by the petitioner were the subject matter of scrutiny and sought explanation from the petitioner.
4. The petitioner has replied to the said notice and claimed CENVAT Credit of Central Excise duty on the stock of goods held on 30.06.2017, for Rs.6,18,796/-. Pursuant to the reply, hearing was fixed on 24.01.2023. Petitioner further claims that he has produced additional documents in support of his defence. Thereafter respondent No.1 issued one more notice dated 06.02.2023 on the premise that the petitioner has filed TRAN-1 claim under Table 7(d) in terms of Rule 117(4) of Central Goods and Services Tax Rules, 2017 and took a view that the petitioner is not entitled to CENVAT credit.
5. It is the case of the petitioner that he made a claim under column ‘7(d)’ inadvertently, instead of making a TRAN-1 claim under column ‘7(b)’. The petitioner however submits that error is inadvertent and he has the documents to support his claim for necessary credit under the Head ‘7(b)’.
6. Learned counsel for the respondents would submit that the impugned order is available under Section 107 of CGST Act.
7. Learned counsel for the petitioner in reply would contend that the Madurai Bench of Madras High Court has dealt with similar issue where the claim is inadvertently made under the inapplicable head and the Writ Court entertained the petition and issued a direction to the respondent-Authority to verify the claim of the petitioner and if the claim is found to be supported by materials, to grant necessary relief as available under law. This Court has perused the aforementioned judgment.
8. From the aforementioned judgment, in W.P.(MD) No.15531/2020 and W.M.P.(M.D.) NO.13042/2020, it can be noticed that in the said case, the claim was made under Column 7(d) of the Form instead of 7(a) and while allowing the writ petition, the Court directed the respondents to forward the petitioner’s application to the concerned authority and directed the concerned authority to verify the correctness of the claim made and it further directed that if satisfied with respect to the claim, the authority shall grant the relief sought in the writ petition.
9. This Court has also perused the records in the case. The petitioner makes claim that he ought to have filed returns under by making a claim under Column 7(b) and erroneously he made a claim under Column 7(d). Since the petitioner has claimed that he has necessary invoices and documents to support his claim under column ‘7(b)’, this Court is of the view that the impugned order is to be set aside and matter is remitted to respondent No.1.
10. Respondent No.1 shall consider the claim of the petitioner under Column 7(b) of CGST Rules, 2017, if there are supporting documents to make claim under Column 7(b). If the claim is established then the consequential relief should follow.
11. With the above observations, petition is disposed of.
12. It is made clear that this Court has not expressed any opinion on the merits of the claim of the petitioner. The authority shall consider the merits of the claim of the petitioner in accordance with law.
13. Annexure-K is set aside, and consequential order Annexure-L notice issued pursuant to Annexure-K is also set aside.
14. Respondent No.1 shall process petitioner’s claim within three months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.




