Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Company Law

Group Company Loans, Guarantees and Investments: Sections 185 & 186 & Special Resolution Pitfalls

Summary: Sections 185 and 186 of the Companies Act, 2013 regulate loans, guarantees, securities and investments made by companies, including transactions between group entities. Section 185 restricts loans and related guarantees or security involving directors and persons in whom directors are interested, subject to specified exemptions and conditions, including shareholder approval and use of funds for principal business activities in applicable cases. Section 186 prescribes aggregate financial limits for loans, guarantees, security and investments, generally based on the higher of 60% of paid-up share capital, free reserves and securities premium or 100% of free reserves and securities premium. Transactions exceeding the applicable limit require prior shareholder approval by special resolution, subject to statutory exemptions. Companies must also comply with board approval requirements, prescribed interest rates, maintenance of registers, financial statement disclosures and applicable ROC filings. Common compliance failures include incorrectly assuming exemptions for all group companies, overlooking corporate guarantees, charging inadequate interest and ignoring cumulative exposure. Contraventions can attract statutory penalties, audit reporting consequences and potential regularisation requirements. Companies should assess both provisions independently before undertaking intra-group funding transactions.

Advertisement

Introduction 

Group companies lend to each other, give guarantees for each other’s borrowings and invest in each other’s shares. Sections 185 and 186 of the Companies Act, 2013 regulate these transactions, and they apply to private companies as well as public ones. Because the two sections work differently and the exemptions are specific, intra-group funding is one of the most common places where a compliance gap is found at audit. This article sets out how the two sections fit together.

1. Section 185: loans to directors and connected persons

Section 185 deals with loans to directors and to persons in whom directors are interested. In its present form, a company may not directly or indirectly advance a loan, including a loan represented by a book debt, or give any guarantee or provide any security in connection with a loan taken by:

  • any director of the company, or of a company which is its holding company, or any partner or relative of any such director;
  • any firm in which any such director or relative is a partner; or
  • any private company of which any such director is a director or member, or any body corporate whose board is accustomed to act on the directions of the company’s directors, or a company in which a specified proportion of voting power is held by such directors.

The prohibition has exceptions. A company can give a loan or guarantee to a person in whom a director is interested, provided that a special resolution is passed, the explanatory statement discloses the loan details, and the loan is used by the borrower only for its principal business activities. The interest rate must not be lower than the prevailing yield of a Government security of the closest tenor. There are also exemptions for loans to a managing or whole-time director as part of the conditions of service or under a scheme approved by the members, and for transactions between a holding company and its wholly owned subsidiary, or a guarantee or security given by a holding company in respect of a loan taken by its subsidiary from a bank or financial institution, subject to the use of the funds for the principal business activities.

2. Section 186: limits on loans, guarantees and investments

Section 186 covers inter-corporate loans, investments, guarantees and security. A company must not make investments through more than two layers of investment companies, with specified exceptions. It must not, directly or indirectly, give any loan to any person or body corporate, give any guarantee or provide security in connection with a loan to any other body corporate or person, or acquire by subscription, purchase or otherwise the securities of any other body corporate, exceeding the higher of:

  • sixty per cent of its paid-up share capital, free reserves and securities premium account; or
  • one hundred per cent of its free reserves and securities premium account.

Beyond that limit, a prior special resolution of the shareholders is required. The calculation counts the aggregate of all such loans, guarantees, security and investments, not each transaction alone. It is therefore possible for a series of individually small advances to push a company over the limit without any single approval being triggered.

3. Other conditions in Section 186

  • Board approval, by a resolution passed with the consent of all directors present at the meeting, is needed before the loan or investment is made, and, where there is a term loan from a public financial institution, prior approval of that institution is needed.
  • The rate of interest on a loan must not be lower than the prevailing yield of a Government security closest to the tenor of the loan.
  • A register of loans, guarantees, security and investments must be maintained and made available for inspection.
  • Details of loans, guarantees, security and investments must be disclosed in the financial statements.
  • Certain transactions are exempt, including those between a holding company and its wholly owned subsidiary, and certain categories of companies such as those that carry on infrastructure financing or lending as their ordinary business.

4. How the two sections interact

Section 185 asks who the borrower is. Section 186 asks how much the company has deployed in total. A loan to a company in which a director is interested has to clear both: the special resolution and the use-of-funds condition under Section 185, and the limit and approvals under Section 186. A loan to a fellow subsidiary, as opposed to a wholly owned subsidiary of the lender, does not enjoy the holding company exemption and should be tested under both sections. Related party transaction rules under Section 188 and the interest and tax treatment, including transfer pricing for cross-border group loans, add further layers.

5. Common errors

1. Treating all group companies as exempt, when the exemption applies to a holding company and its wholly owned subsidiary only.

2. Giving a corporate guarantee for a sister company’s loan without looking at either section.

3. Charging interest below the Government security yield, or charging none.

4. Ignoring the aggregate when a series of small loans builds up to exceed the Section 186 limit.

5. Passing a board resolution but not the special resolution, or passing it after the money has gone out.

6. Failing to file the special resolution with the Registrar, or to record the transaction in the register.

6. Consequences of getting it wrong

Both sections carry penalties on the company and on the officers in default, and for Section 185 the penalty provisions include imprisonment for officers in default in addition to a fine. In practice, auditors may qualify the report on a contravention and the matter must also be addressed in the report under the Companies (Auditor’s Report) Order. A transaction that was not approved properly may have to be regularised, and in some cases the amount must be recovered.

7. A short checklist

1. Identify the borrower, and its relationship with the lender and the lender’s directors.

2. Test the transaction under Section 185 and note the exemption relied on, if any.

3. Compute the Section 186 limit using the latest audited balance sheet and the aggregate of existing loans, guarantees and investments.

4. Obtain board approval, and shareholder approval by special resolution where required, before the transaction.

5. Fix a compliant rate of interest and record the end use of funds.

6. Update the register and the disclosures, and file the resolution with the Registrar on time.

This article is for general information only and is not professional advice. The Act, the Rules and the latest amendments should be consulted for a specific transaction.

Advertisement

Author Info

Sudheer Nagavarapu
Qualification: CS, LL.B / Advocate, Post Graduate
Company: A2consultants
Location: Hyderabad, Telangana
Articles Published: 22

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *