Summary: Tax deducted at source may exceed the recipient’s final income-tax liability, particularly where the recipient has losses, low taxable margins or a favourable tax treaty position. Under the Income-tax Act, 1961, section 197 allowed the payee to seek a lower or nil deduction certificate, while section 195(2) allowed a payer to obtain a determination of the taxable proportion of a payment to a non-resident. From 1 April 2026, these mechanisms operate under sections 395(1) and 395(2) of the Income-tax Act, 2025. The payee’s lower or nil deduction application is made in Form No. 128, whereas a payer seeking determination of the chargeable portion of a non-resident payment uses Form No. 129. Applications should be supported by income computations, contracts, applicable treaty documentation and other relevant evidence. Certificates must be checked for their validity, specified rate, payer and amount limits. They affect withholding at the payment stage but do not conclusively determine the recipient’s final tax liability.
- Lower or Nil TDS: Choosing Between Payee and Payer Applications
- Section 197 / Section 395(1): Application by the Payee
- Section 195(2) / Section 395(2): Application by the Payer for Non-Resident Payments
- Practical Points Before Applying for Lower or Nil TDS
- 1. Apply Before the Payment
- 2. Prepare the Working
- 3. Do Not Assume a Certificate for the Full Year
- 4. Do Not Treat a Self-Assessed Treaty Rate as a Substitute
- 5. Check the Form and Portal Procedure
- Effect of the Certificate and Final Tax Liability
Lower or Nil TDS: Choosing Between Payee and Payer Applications
Tax deducted at source on a payment can be much higher than the final tax on the income, particularly where the payee has losses, a thin margin or a treaty rate that is lower than the rate the payer would otherwise apply. The Act provides two routes to have tax deducted at a lower rate, or not deducted at all, and the choice depends on who the payee is and what the payment is.
Section 197 / Section 395(1): Application by the Payee
- The assessing officer can issue a certificate authorising deduction at a lower rate, or no deduction, where the payee’s total income justifies it.
- The application is made by the recipient of the income, with estimates of income and tax, details of the past years and the payments expected during the year. Under the 2026 rules, the prescribed application is Form No. 128, replacing Form 13 under the earlier regime.
- The certificate applies to the payer or payers named in it and to the period and amounts stated. The deductor should validate the certificate before applying the lower or nil rate.
Section 195(2) / Section 395(2): Application by the Payer for Non-Resident Payments
- Where only a part of a sum paid to a non-resident is chargeable to tax in India, the payer can apply to the assessing officer to determine the appropriate proportion on which tax has to be deducted. The corresponding provision is now section 395(2) of the Income-tax Act, 2025.
- This route is relevant where the payment includes a reimbursement of costs, a capital receipt or an amount that is not taxable in India under the treaty. The taxable character of each component must be established from the facts and applicable law.
- A related provision allows a non-resident to apply for a certificate for a lower or nil deduction. Under the earlier regime, the non-resident payee’s application for receipt without deduction was addressed by section 195(3), subject to its prescribed conditions. Under the current framework, the applicable payee certificate provisions and procedures must be examined separately.
Practical Points Before Applying for Lower or Nil TDS
1. Apply Before the Payment
A certificate normally operates from the date it is issued or from the start of the period it covers as stated, so delay can leave a payment outside it. The application should therefore be filed sufficiently early through the applicable portal. See Form No. 128 filing guidance.
2. Prepare the Working
The authorities expect a clear computation, the contract, the treaty position, the tax residency certificate and, for a non-resident, a statement of its business connection and permanent establishment position. For the payer’s determination procedure, refer to Form No. 129.
3. Do Not Assume a Certificate for the Full Year
Certificates are often limited by amount and period, and a payer should check that each payment falls within them. The certificate number and validity should also be checked against the relevant TRACES validation records.
4. Do Not Treat a Self-Assessed Treaty Rate as a Substitute
A payer who relies on its own view of the treaty and deducts less than the law requires takes the risk of a short-deduction demand with interest. The distinction between a payment that is not chargeable to Indian tax and a payment requiring a lower withholding determination is important. See TDS on Payments to Non Residents (Section 195).
5. Check the Form and Portal Procedure
The application forms and the manner of filing are prescribed in the rules and have changed over time. The current Form No. 128 applies to lower or nil deduction applications by the payee, while Form No. 129 applies to the payer’s determination of the taxable portion of specified non-resident payments.
Effect of the Certificate and Final Tax Liability
A certificate does not make a payment non-taxable. It only changes the rate or amount of deduction at the time of payment, and the final tax is settled in the return of the payee.
Section numbers and procedure have been renumbered and revised under the Income-tax Act, 2025, applicable from 1 April 2026. The current provisions, forms and time limits should be verified before relying on this note.




