Avnash Amarlal Vs ACIT (ITAT Bangalore)
Seized Cash and Jewellery Linked to Business Income Cannot Attract Section 115BBE: Bangalore ITAT
Introduction
Income surrendered during a search does not automatically become unexplained income taxable under section 115BBE. Where the assessee establishes its connection with business activities through statements, financial records and supporting documents, its character as business income must be examined on those facts.
This distinction was reiterated by the Bangalore ITAT in Shri Avnash Amarlal v. ACIT, ITA No. 2646/Bang/2025, Assessment Year 2019-20, order dated 3 November 2026. The Tribunal accepted the assessee’s contention that the disputed search disclosure represented business income taxable at normal rates, rather than income attracting sections 69 and 69A read with section 115BBE.
Search and Disclosure of Income
A search conducted on 20 July 2018, in connection with the Bowring Institute and the assessee’s group, resulted in the seizure of ₹3.90 crore from a locker. Another ₹20 lakh was seized from his residence.
The authorities also found gold and diamond jewellery valued at approximately ₹8.11 crore, besides two watches valued at ₹16.25 lakh.
The assessee explained that the cash represented earnings from real estate commission and money lending activities. He had included the disputed amounts in the business income disclosed in his return.
Regarding jewellery, he relied upon purchase bills and wealth-tax returns filed by himself and family members. He also explained that the watches had been gifted by his sister, while stating that their value had nevertheless been offered as business income to buy peace.
Assessing Officer’s Objection
The Assessing Officer considered the explanations insufficient. According to him, recording assets in the accounts after their discovery during a search did not cure the earlier failure to record them.
He treated the ₹4.10 crore cash component as unexplained money under section 69A, reducing the corresponding amount from business income. The jewellery and watches were treated as unexplained investments under section 69.
The dispute therefore concerned the character and applicable rate of taxation, rather than simply whether the disclosed amounts should be included in total income.
The CIT(A) upheld this treatment because the assessee had allegedly failed to substantiate the claimed business source through adequate documentary evidence.
Search Statement Supported the Business Source
Before the Tribunal, the assessee relied on his statement recorded under section 132(4).
In answers to questions 21 and 22, he had explained that the cash arose from commission activities involving real estate and money lending. The explanation linking the cash to business was therefore present during the search itself.
The Tribunal also noted that purchase bills had been produced for diamonds worth approximately ₹2.05 crore. Regarding the remaining jewellery, the assessee had explained that it was acquired from unaccounted business income.
These circumstances were examined alongside the financial statements and earlier disclosures, rather than treating the surrender in isolation.
Financial Statements and Wealth-Tax Returns
The Tribunal examined audited financial statements showing that business constituted the assessee’s principal source of income. The search disclosure had also been incorporated under business income in the financial statements for the relevant year.
Earlier wealth-tax returns disclosed gold and diamond jewellery belonging to the assessee and family members. These documents supported the explanation regarding the jewellery found during the search.
The Tribunal additionally considered a notarised retraction affidavit dated 23 July 2018, executed three days after the search, explaining that the assessee had been unable to identify during the search the jewellery already disclosed in wealth-tax returns.
Relief thus rested on the combined evidentiary record, including contemporaneous explanations, financial statements and historical asset disclosures.
Earlier Bangalore Tribunal Decisions
The Tribunal relied upon ITO v. Ramachandra Setty & Sons [2024] 163 taxmann.com 666 (Bangalore–Trib.). That decision recognised business-income treatment where the evidence connected the income with business and the Revenue failed to establish a different source.
It also referred to Bhawarlal HUF v. DCIT, ITA No. 1759/Bang/2025, concerning excess stock explained as having been acquired from business profits.
Applying these decisions, the Tribunal accepted the business connection demonstrated by the assessee and allowed the appeal, holding that the disputed cash and jewellery were taxable at normal rates.
Author’s Comments
The decision highlights the distinction between unaccounted business income and amounts remaining unexplained as to their nature and source. Section 69A requires examination of the explanation offered; discovery of an unrecorded asset alone does not complete that enquiry.
However, merely describing a surrender as business income in the return is insufficient. Section 115BBE expressly covers specified deemed income even when reflected in the return. Consequently, voluntary disclosure by itself does not exclude its application.
The strength of this case lay in the supporting evidence and the explanation given from the beginning. Nor should the order be read as holding that every asset found with a businessman necessarily represents business income. The assessee’s own financial statements recorded other heads of income.
For practitioners, the practical lesson is to establish a credible business nexus, supported by contemporaneous statements, business records, purchase documents and earlier asset disclosures. The ruling provides useful Bangalore Tribunal support where those facts exist; its application remains evidence dependent.
Cases Discussed:
- ITO Vs Ramachandra Setty & Sons — [2024] 163 taxmann.com 666 (ITAT Bangalore), order dated 10 June 2024; relied upon for business-income treatment of unexplained receipts where supported by business nexus.
- Bhawarlal HUF Vs DCIT — ITA No. 1759/Bang/2025, order dated 8 June 2025 (ITAT Bangalore); relied upon regarding excess stock and business profits.
- Deepak Setia Vs DCIT — 106 ITR (Trib) 125 (ITAT Amritsar); quoted within Ramachandra Setty & Sons.
- Banti Kumar Vs ACIT — 157 taxmann.com 245 (ITAT Amritsar); quoted within Ramachandra Setty & Sons.
- DDK Spinning Mills Vs DCIT — 157 taxmann.com 817 (ITAT Chandigarh); quoted within Ramachandra Setty & Sons.
- Pramod Singhala Vs CIT — 154 taxmann.com 347 (ITAT Chandigarh); quoted within Ramachandra Setty & Sons.
FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ITAT BANGALORE
This is an appeal filed by the assessee challenging the order of the Ld.CIT(A) – 15, Bengaluru dated 16/09/2025 in respect of the A.Y. 2019-20.
2. The brief facts of the case are that the assessee is an individual and filed his return of income on 22/09/2019 admitting total income of Rs. 19,26,46,830/- which was processed u/s. 143(1) of the Act. In the said return, the assessee had declared a business income of Rs. 18,11,15,214/-, short term capital gains of Rs. 1,17,05,917/- and income from other sources of Rs. 10,700/-. There was a search conducted in the case of the assessee on 20/07/2018 in connection with the search proceedings in the group case of M/s. Bowring Institute and Shri Avnash Amarlal Group etc. Pursuant to the said search, notice u/s. 153A was issued on 22/03/2019 and the assessee filed his return of income on 06/05/2019 admitting the very same income. Subsequently, notice u/s. 143(2) of the Act was issued seeking the supporting documents in support of the claims made in the return of income. During the assessment, it was noticed that there was a search and at the time of search, cash of Rs. 3,90,00,000/- was found and seized from the locker of the assessee in the premises of Bowring Institute. During the search, in the residence of the assessee, an amount of Rs. 23,28,900/- was found and out of the said amount, Rs. 20,00,000/- was seized by the authorities. On that basis, a show cause notice was issued proposing to add the said cash as income of the assessee u/s. 69A of the Act. The assessee submitted his reply that the said cash was admitted and declared as business income of the previous year and the assessee had explained that he has earned the said sum by way of commission activities of real estate and money lending activities. Insofar as the seizure of Rs. 20 Lakhs from the residence of the assessee, the assessee explained that these are the cash balance of various members of the family and therefore, no addition u/s. 69A could be made. The AO had not accepted the said explanation on the ground that recording in accounts subsequently would not foreclose / mitigate the default of non-recording detected earlier during the course of search. The AO also observed that without any corroborative evidences to support such entries and offering the same to tax in the return of income for the search A.Y. would not satisfy the nature and source thereof and therefore, the provision of section 69A would apply. On that score, the AO had confirmed the addition of Rs. 4,10,00,000/- but reduced the said income from the business income and added to the income from other sources u/s. 69A of the Act.
3. Apart from the cash seizure at the time of search, jewelry worth 751.52 grams of gold, 81.470 kt diamond worth of Rs. 8,11,25,242/- was also found in the locker of the assessee in the Bowring Institute. The authorities had also found two watches in the locker which were also seized and the value of the said watches has been estimated at Rs. 16,25,000/-. Based on the above said seizures, a show cause notice was issued to the assessee why the value of the jewelries and the watch should not be considered as an unexplained investment u/s. 69 of the Act. The assessee filed his response and submitted that he has already reported the value of the jewelry and the watches in the business income reported by him during the previous year. The assessee also submitted that the jewelries found in the locker was already reported in the wealth tax return filed by the assessee and his family members Asardas Amarlal HUF, Ekta Avinash Kukreja and Kiran Amarlal and therefore, it should not be taxed u/s. 69 of the Act. Insofar as the watches seized, it was the submission of the assessee that the said watches were gifted by his sister and in any event, to buy peace with the Department, the assessee had reported the value of the jewelry and the watches in the return of income and added back to the business income. The AO not accepted the said explanations on the ground that the accounting of the jewelry and the watches in the books of accounts is without any evidence and therefore, section 69 would be attracted. The AO further stated that any subsequent recording in accounts after having been deducted, would not be in the nature of regular accounting but only an attempt to cure the default. Therefore, the AO had not accepted the explanation and also treated the said value of the jewelry and watches as unexplained investment u/s. 69 of the Act.
4. During the course of search, undated promissory notes were also seized in folder number A/B1/11. The AO had treated the amount mentioned in the said promissory notes and issued a show cause notice to explain the said transactions and also asked why the said value of the undated promissory notes should not be added back to the income of the assessee. The assessee replied that promissory notes for value of Rs. 5,56,35,000/- were signed by Shri Mahabaleshwarappa and he also passed away on 18/12/2009 and therefore, even assuming that they are the evidence, it should not be added during the year. Insofar as the promissory notes for a value of Rs. 2,48,50,000/-, the assessee submitted that the promissory notes are related to the old transactions and cannot be added for the current A.Y. The AO in view of the fact that the promissory notes are undated and not recorded in the books, the same were added in the year of search and treated as unexplained investment u/s. 69 of the Act on protective basis. Insofar as the undated promissory notes pertaining to M/s. Jewels De Paragon Ltd., the assessee submitted that the said promissory notes were also signed by Mahabaleshwara who passed away on 18/12/2009. Therefore, the AO had made the addition on protective basis u/s. 69 of the Act.
5. The assessee challenged the said order before the Ld.CIT(A) – 15, Bengaluru. The assessee submitted that the AO had erred in treating the cash seizure as unexplained money u/s. 69A of the Act by treating the said income under the head income from other sources when the assessee had accepted the said income and offered under the head business income in his return of income. Similarly, the assessee had made the plea in respect of the seizure of the old jewelry / diamonds and two watches. Insofar as the undated promissory notes seized, the assessee submitted that all the promissory notes are undated and also the assessment made on the protective basis on the assessee is not correct when there is no substantive addition made in the hands of another person or in the hands of the same person for another A.Y. The Ld.CIT(A) had confirmed the additions made u/s. 69A and 69 of the Act on the ground that the assessee could not substantiate the claim of business income with supporting documentary evidence. Insofar as the protective assessment made based on the seizure of the undated promissory notes, the Ld.CIT(A) after getting a remand report from the AO, had concluded that there is no substantive assessment in respect of the protective assessment of promissory notes. The Ld.CIT(A) after considering the said remand report had concluded that there is no substantive assessment in any other assessment year in the hands of the assessee or in the hands of Ittina Properties Pvt. Ltd. and therefore, by relying on the several orders of the Coordinate Benches of this Tribunal had held that the protective assessment could not be sustained without making any substantive assessment. The Ld.CIT(A) also considered the submission that the promissory notes are old one which was signed by Shri Mahabaleshwarappa who expired on 18/12/2009 and therefore, the promissory notes seized at the time of search relates back to the year 2009 or earlier and it cannot be related to the F.Y. 2018-19. On that basis, the Ld.CIT(A) had deleted the addition made on protective basis based on the seizure of the promissory notes.
6. The assessee challenged the order of the Ld.CIT(A) insofar as it confirms the additions made u/s. 69A and 69 of the Act before this Tribunal.
7. At the time of hearing, the Ld.AR submitted that the assessee had admitted the cash found during the course of search and offered the same under the head business income and therefore, the said addition could not be made as unexplained money u/s. 69A of the Act. The Ld.AR further submitted that there was no other source for cash except the business income and therefore, the said income was properly included in the financials of the assessee and reported in the return of income as business income and therefore submitted that the AO without having any other information about the source of the cash, apart from the business activities, could not be made addition u/s. 69A of the Act. The Ld.AR also submitted that the jewelry and watches found at the time of search also purchased out of the business profits and therefore, the said investments are not to be treated as unexplained investment u/s. 69 of the Act. The Ld.AR also submitted that the assessee voluntarily included the value of jewelry and watches under the head business income and therefore, there is no logic in confirming the addition u/s. 69 of the Act without having any other evidences to show that the assessee is earning the income from other sources. The Ld.AR also filed a paper book and also a compilation of case laws and submitted that the documents enclosed in the paper books would establishes the fact that the assessee is having only business income and therefore, the cash and jewelry seized could be treated as business income taxable at the normal rate and not at the special rate as prescribed u/s. 115BBE of the Act. The Ld.AR also furnished the copy of the sworn statement recorded u/s. 132(4) of the Act given by the assessee at the time of search and relied on several questions and answers to show that the assessee had right from the beginning had contested that the seizure of the cash as well as the jewelries are from the business income. The Ld.AR also filed a copy of the retraction affidavit dated 23/07/2018 which is just 3 days away from the date of search and therefore, prayed that the additions are to be treated as business income and not the income from other sources taxable u/s. 69 and 69A of the Act.
8. The Ld.DR submitted that the assessee had admitted the omissions in his sworn statement but later on, gave some explanations to treat the said income as business income which could not be accepted. The Ld.DR further submitted that the AO had given clear findings on the submissions made by the assessee which was also confirmed by the Ld.CIT(A) and therefore, prayed that the appeal may be dismissed.
9. We have heard the arguments of both sides and perused the materials available on record.
10. As seen from the statement recorded u/s. 132(4) of the Act, the assessee to the question number 21 had answered that the cash is earned out of small commission income from real estate and lending activities. The assessee further answered that he would like to offer this unaccounted income as his income for the current year i.e. A.Y. 2019-20. For the question no. 22, the assessee had again reiterated the submissions already made and submitted that the cash seized is earned out of various small commission activities of real estate and money lending activities. From the said statement, it is admitted by the assessee that the cash seized at the time of search belongs to him and also earned out of the business activities of commission and money lending.
11. Insofar as the jewelry seized at the time of search, the assessee admitted that the jewelries are belonged to him and also produced the bills for the purchase of diamonds worth Rs. 2,05,42,031/-. Insofar as the balance amount of jewelry and diamonds, the assessee had admitted that the jewelries were acquired from his unaccounted business income.
12. We have also perused the paper book filed by the assessee for A.Y. 2015- 16 wherein in page no. 119, the wealth tax return copy for the A.Y. 2015-16 was filed in which the assessee had mentioned the gold jewelry and diamond as his movable property. In page no. 124 of the paper book, the assessee had also furnished the net wealth of the movables of Ekta Avinash Kukreja which includes gold jewelry, silver articles and diamond jewelry. Similarly, in page 134, the copy of the wealth tax return filed in respect of Kiran Amarlal was also enclosed to show that the gold jewelry, silver articles and diamond jewelries were shown as the movables. In the paper book at page 149, the assessee had furnished the audited financial statements for the year ending 31/03/2019. In the said statement, the assessee had added the income which was found at the time of search, which includes gold jewelry / diamond, watches, cash and other receivables, under the head Income from Business. In the statement of total income furnished by the assessee for the A.Y. 2019-20, we find that the assessee had earned income from house property, income from business, income from capital gains and income from other sources. The assessee had shown the cash seized as well as the value of the jewelry as business income while filing the return of income. We have also perused the audited financial statements for the A.Y. 2018-19 in which also the assessee had earned business income as the main source of income.
13. From the said audited financial statements furnished by the assessee, it came to light that the assessee is earning major income through doing the business and on that basis only, he had included the said cash seizure as well as the value of the jewelries as business income. The fact of earning the said cash and jewelries are also vouched by the assessee while giving the statement u/s. 132(4) of the Act. The assessee based on the said documents furnished in the paper book had demonstrated that he is earning business income and therefore, the cash and the jewelries are his business income. We have also perused the notarized retraction affidavit filed by the assessee on 23/07/2018 in respect of the jewelries in which the assessee had explained that he was not able to state about the jewelries at the time of search, that has been disclosed by him as well as his family members in the returns filed under the Wealth Tax Act.
14. We have also gone through the several orders of the Coordinate Bench of this Tribunal relied on by the assessee. In the order dated 10/06/2024, reported in (2024) 163 taxmann.com 666 (Bangalore) in the case of ITO vs. Ramachandra Setty & Sons wherein the Coordinate Bench had held as follows:
“18.4 Further, the revenue authorities were not able to submit any evidence to show that such income is not connected with the business income of the assessee or accumulated from non-recognising sources. Hence, all the incomes earned by the assessee are only from the business income of the assessee, there do not arise any question as to application of provisions of section 69 or 69A or 69B or 69C of the Act. Hence, taxing such income at special rate u/s 115BBE of the Act is improper. It is settled principle of law that when there is no separate source of income identified during the course of search action or survey or during the course of assessment proceedings or appellate proceedings, any income arising to the assessee shall be treated to be out of the normal business of the assessee only. For this purpose, we place reliance on the judgement of Deepak Setia Vs. DCIT reported in 106 ITR (Trib) 125 (Amritsar).
18.5 Further, same view was taken by this coordinate bench of Tribunal in the case of Banti Kumar Vs. ACIT 157 Taxmann.com 245 (Amritsar).
18.6 Further, in the case of DDK Spinning Mills Vs. DCIT 157 Taxmann.com 817 (Chd.) wherein held that when during the course of survey, assessee surrendered certain amount on account of addition made to factory building, since source of investment in said building was stated to be out of business income, which was duly honoured by assessee while filing the return of income, wherein amount was offered to tax under head “business income” and tax was paid on the same at normal rate, provisions of section 69B r.w.s. 115BBE of the Act could not be invoked so as to make addition on account of certain amounts treating it as unexplained investment. Same view was taken by coordinate bench of Chandigarh Bench in the case of Pramod Singhala Vs. CIT (154 Taxmann.com 347).
18.6 Hence, the addition sustained by ld. CIT(A) at Rs.1,36,73,613/- u/s 69B r.w.s. 115BBE of the Act has to be treated as income from business. Similarly, in the case of jewellery found at the business premises of the assessee at Rs.4,11,86,426/- to be treated as business income of the assessee and to be assessed accordingly. Thus, the grounds of appeal of the revenue are dismissed and grounds of appeal of the assessee are allowed.”
15. We have also gone through the order of the Coordinate Bench of this Tribunal dated 08/06/2025 in ITA No. 1759/Bang/2025 in the case of Bhawarlal HUF vs. DCIT wherein similar dispute arose and the Coordinate Bench of this Tribunal had held that section 69A has no applicability.
……………….”
“12. ………… During the course of survey there is no evidence found by the survey party that the excess stock was acquired by the assessee not as a business income of the assessee and further there was no evidence found that assessee is carrying on any other business or any other activity. In fact the assessee during the course of assessment proceedings has explained that the above cash is undisclosed sales of the assessee and the excess stock is also purchased out of his business profits. It can be a case of an undeclared business income, but it cannot be a case of undisclosed income of the assessee. Neither during the course of survey nor in the statement or any other evidence found during the course of survey shows that there is any other source of income of the assessee other than the business. Naturally therefore in case of excess stock found during the carrying on of the business such stock is generated out of the business income and therefore the provisions of section 69A has no applicability.
……………….”
16. In the present case also, it was established by the assessee that he is having business income and therefore, the cash found and the jewelries seized were treated as business income and also reported in the return of income filed for the A.Y. 2019-20. The documents enclosed in the paper book also supports the stand of the assessee. The AO had no other material evidence to show that the assessee is also earning other incomes and therefore, it should be treated as other income liable to be taxed u/s. 69 & 69A of the Act. The copies of the wealth tax returns of the assessee as well as the family members would supports the fact that the jewelries are declared in the wealth tax returns. Further, the answers given by the assessee in the 132(4) statement also supports the case of the assessee. Therefore, based on the discussions made above as well as by considering the various documents furnished by the assessee, it is evident that the assessee is earning business income and therefore, the seizures made at the time of search were added as business income. The Coordinate Bench orders also supports the case of the assessee. We, therefore, accept the plea made by the assessee that the cash and jewelries seized during the search are business income liable to be taxed under the normal rate and not at the special rate and allow the grounds raised by the assessee.
17. In the result, the appeal filed by the assessee is allowed.
Order pronounced in the open court on 03rd November, 2026.


