Susheela Janardhan Vs ITO (ITAT Bangalore)
Unsigned Electronic Tax Notices Invalidate Assessments: Bangalore ITAT Follows Karnataka High Court
Introduction
The Bangalore Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal has quashed two assessments founded on unsigned notices, notwithstanding the Revenue’s argument that electronically communicated notices were sufficiently authenticated by the Assessing Officer’s printed name and designation.
The common order in Susheela Janardhan v. ITO and Priemary Agri Credit Co-operative Bank Limited v. ITO, ITA Nos. 1827/Bang/2025 and 2666/Bang/2025, dated 3 November 2026, examines the interplay between Section 282A, electronic communication and binding jurisdictional precedent.
The Tribunal ultimately followed the Karnataka High Court’s decision in Yeshoda Electricals and allowed both appeals without examining the disputed additions on merits.
Background of the Two Appeals
In Susheela Janardhan’s case, concerning AY 2017–18, the assessee filed her return declaring income of ₹15,55,490. The return was selected for limited scrutiny to verify cash deposits.
She challenged the notice under Section 143(2), dated 9 August 2018, on the ground that it was unsigned. The assessment involved denial of a Section 54 deduction of ₹1,90,05,000 and an addition of ₹4,90,000 under Section 69C, relating to cash expenditure on jewellery.
In the co-operative bank’s appeal for AY 2019–20, the challenge concerned an unsigned Section 148 notice dated 31 March 2023, along with unsigned notices under Section 142(1). The disputed assessment included treating approximately ₹6.14 crore, described by the assessee as a loan liability, as unexplained money under Section 69A.
Both assessees contended that the absence of signatures invalidated the foundational notices and consequently the assessments.
Assessees’ Argument: A Jurisdictional Defect Cannot Be Ignored
The assessees principally relied upon the Karnataka High Court’s judgment in Pr. CIT v. Yeshoda Electricals, ITA No. 261/2021 connected with ITA No. 264/2021, dated 24 September 2025, bearing neutral citation 2025:KHC:38487-DB.
That judgment concerned an unsigned reassessment notice issued on 22 March 2012. The High Court held that an unsigned jurisdictional notice was invalid and that Section 282A(2) did not dispense with the requirement of signing merely because the issuing authority’s name and office appeared on the document.
According to the assessees, judicial discipline required the Tribunal to follow this jurisdictional ruling. Printed particulars of the officer could not substitute the statutory requirement of a validly issued notice.
Revenue’s Argument: Electronic Authentication Is Different
The Revenue advanced a detailed distinction between paper notices and electronic notices, relying on the amendment to Section 282A by the Finance Act, 2016.
Its contention was that the amended provision contemplated alternative modes: a notice could be signed and issued in paper form, or communicated electronically in accordance with the prescribed procedure.
The Revenue therefore relied upon Section 282A(2) read with Rule 127A, arguing that electronic notices bearing the issuing authority’s name and office satisfied the authentication requirement.
It further submitted that Yeshoda Electricals concerned a manual notice issued before the amendment, making its factual and statutory setting distinguishable.
The Revenue also relied on Asro Arcade v. ITO [2026] 186 taxmann.com 313 (Delhi), described in the Tribunal’s order as accepting an electronically generated notice bearing the officer’s name and designation despite the absence of a handwritten or digital signature.
Tribunal’s Decision: Jurisdictional High Court Followed
The Tribunal expressly recognised the distinction pressed by the Revenue. It noted that the earlier Tribunal decision in Yeshoda Electricals concerned a manual notice and contained observations distinguishing digital documents.
It also recorded that the notices before it were digital notices.
Nevertheless, the Bench ultimately followed the Karnataka High Court’s decision in Yeshoda Electricals and treated the unsigned notices as invalid.
In Susheela Janardhan’s case, the Tribunal specifically recorded that although a signed notice was shown before it, the original notice did not display a signature, containing only the issuing authority’s name, designation and address.
Consequently, the Tribunal quashed the assessment proceedings in both cases. Once the foundational challenge succeeded, it considered examination of the substantive additions unnecessary.
Author’s Comments
The decision provides significant support to taxpayers challenging unsigned jurisdictional notices in Karnataka, including notices communicated electronically.
However, the reasoning requires careful presentation. Yeshoda Electricals itself concerned a manual notice issued in 2012. The present Tribunal acknowledged this distinction but nevertheless applied the jurisdictional High Court’s ruling to the digital notices before it.
Accordingly, the order should not be described as a Karnataka High Court judgment directly deciding the validity of post-amendment electronic notices. It is a Tribunal decision extending the jurisdictional ruling to the facts before it.
Equally, the decision does not establish that every electronic notice lacking a visible signature is automatically invalid throughout India. The competing interpretation of Section 282A and Rule 127A, reflected in the Revenue’s submissions, remains material.
For practitioners, the practical lesson is to examine the original electronic notice, its authentication and the applicable jurisdictional precedents. The merits of the Section 54 claim, jewellery expenditure and loan-related addition were left undecided, since both assessments were quashed on the preliminary legal ground.
Cases Discussed
- R. Giridhar v. CIT — (1984) 145 ITR 246 (Karnataka); (1984) 17 Taxman 120; decided on 20.10.1983. The Karnataka High Court considered the effect of an unsigned sheet accompanying an assessment order and the applicability of Section 292B. The decision was discussed in relation to curable defects.
- Vikas Gupta v. Union of India — (2022) 448 ITR 1 (Allahabad); [2022] 142 taxmann.com 253. The Allahabad High Court held that signing a notice under Section 282A(1) was a mandatory requirement for its legal effectiveness.
- Bharat Krishi Kendra v. Union of India — [2022] 136 taxmann.com 245 (Chhattisgarh). The decision was referred to regarding authentication of approval under Section 151 where the issuing authority’s particulars and document identification details appeared on the record.
- Yeshoda Electricals v. ACIT — [2023] 154 taxmann.com 677 (Bangalore Tribunal); decided on 03.02.2021. The Tribunal considered the validity of an unsigned reassessment notice dated 22.03.2012. This was the underlying Tribunal decision subsequently examined by the Karnataka High Court.
- Prakash Krishnavtar Bhardwaj v. ITO — (2023) 451 ITR 27 (Bombay); [2023] 150 taxmann.com 60; decided on 09.01.2023. The Bombay High Court’s ruling concerning unsigned income-tax notices was discussed in the context of statutory authentication requirements.
- Jindal Exports and Imports (P.) Ltd. v. DCIT — (2024) 469 ITR 601 (Delhi); [2023] 152 taxmann.com 609; decided on 26.07.2023. The Delhi High Court set aside notices that failed to identify the issuing officer by name and designation, considering Section 282A and the applicable CBDT instructions.
- Toyota Tsusho India (P.) Ltd. v. DCIT — (2024) 468 ITR 29 (Karnataka); [2024] 164 taxmann.com 85; decided on 13.02.2024. The Karnataka High Court considered the legal effect of a transfer pricing order that had not been physically or digitally signed within the prescribed limitation period.
- Mytheenkunju Muhammed Kunju Kandathil Jewellers v. DCIT — [2024] 160 taxmann.com 630 (Cochin Tribunal); (2024) 113 ITR (Trib.) 40. The Tribunal considered authentication under Section 282A read with Rule 127A and the effect of the issuing authority’s name and designation appearing on electronically communicated documents.
- Doddagarudanahalli Vyavasaya Seva Bank Niyamitha v. ITO — [2025] 174 taxmann.com 864 (Karnataka); decided on 03.04.2025. The Karnataka High Court decision was cited in the submissions concerning the validity of unsigned statutory documents.
- Pr. CIT v. Yeshoda Electricals — ITA Nos. 261/2021 and 264/2021; 2025:KHC:38487-DB; decided on 24.09.2025. The Karnataka High Court held that an unsigned jurisdictional notice was invalid and that Section 282A(2) did not dispense with the requirement of signing. This was the principal binding precedent followed by the Bangalore Tribunal.
- Ambernath City Hospital (P.) Ltd. v. Union of India — [2026] 182 taxmann.com 268 (Bombay); decided on 06.01.2026. The Bombay High Court decision was considered in the discussion concerning unsigned notices and statutory authentication.
- Asro Arcade v. ITO — [2026] 186 taxmann.com 313 (Delhi); decided on 16.04.2026. The Delhi High Court accepted authentication of an electronically generated reassessment notice bearing the issuing officer’s name and designation under Section 282A(2), notwithstanding the absence of a handwritten or digital signature. The Revenue relied on this decision to distinguish the earlier Karnataka High Court ruling.



