Mohammed Mustaque Ahmed Vs JCIT (ITAT Bangalore)
Cash Received to Repay Pressing Debts: Bangalore ITAT Deletes ₹41.91 Lakh Penalty under Section 271D
Introduction
Acceptance of cash towards sale of immovable property may attract a penalty equal to the amount received. However, the existence of a statutory violation does not dispense with the need to examine reasonable cause. Financial distress, persistent recovery demands and complete disclosure of the transaction can become relevant in deciding whether such a penalty should survive.
In Mohammed Mustaque Ahmed v. JCIT, ITA No.1591/Bang/2026, AY 2017-18, decided on 3 November 2026, the Bangalore ITAT deleted a penalty of ₹41,91,500 under section 271D. The assessee had accepted part of the property sale consideration in cash to meet pressing repayment obligations. The Tribunal considered his financial circumstances, disclosure in the registered sale deed and acceptance of the returned income.
Facts of the Case
The assessee filed his return declaring a total income of ₹24,46,490, comprising income from house property, business income, long-term capital gains and income from other sources.
The case was selected for complete scrutiny, inter alia, because of increased cash deposits during demonetisation and the relationship between the property sale consideration and the capital gains disclosed. After examining the details furnished, the Assessing Officer completed the assessment under section 143(3) on 17 December 2019, accepting the returned income.
Subsequently, the Joint Commissioner issued a notice dated 12 February 2020 proposing penalty under section 271D for receipt of ₹41,91,500 in cash towards the property transaction.
Why the Assessee Accepted Cash
The assessee explained that his business was in a very bad financial condition and he was struggling to maintain his family’s day-to-day affairs. He had borrowed through different credit cards and had defaulted on repayment.
According to his explanation, recovery agents were persistently demanding repayment. These circumstances compelled him to request the purchaser to pay part of the sale consideration in cash so that he could discharge credit card liabilities and hand loans.
The assessee emphasised that ₹90 lakh had been received through bank transfer, while the cash component was expressly recorded in the registered sale deed. The entire consideration was disclosed, and the resulting capital gains were offered to tax. There was no allegation that the cash represented undisclosed sale consideration.
Penalty Confirmed by CIT(A)
The Joint Commissioner treated the cash receipt as a violation of section 269SS and imposed an equivalent penalty of ₹41,91,500.
The CIT(A) upheld the levy. It observed that the provisions governing acceptance of a specified sum relating to immovable property, applicable from 1 June 2015, prohibited receipt of ₹20,000 or more otherwise than through the prescribed modes.
Although the cash receipt appeared in the registered sale deed, the CIT(A) held that the assessee had failed to establish reasonable cause. Consequently, disclosure of the transaction did not persuade the first appellate authority to delete the penalty.
Reasonable Cause under Section 273B
Section 271D provides for a penalty equal to the loan, deposit or specified sum accepted in contravention of section 269SS. However, section 273B expressly extends protection against penalty under section 271D where reasonable cause is proved. The statutory scheme therefore requires consideration of the explanation for the failure, alongside the prohibited mode of receipt. 271D
The distinction is significant: proof of a cash receipt establishes the factual foundation for examining the violation, but the assessee’s explanation remains relevant to the ultimate penalty decision.
Tribunal Relies on P.R. Associates
The Bangalore Bench relied upon P.R. Associates v. ACIT (2019) 70 ITR (Trib) 469 (Pune).
In that case, cash borrowings had been taken to meet pressing financial liabilities when the business was inoperative and lenders were demanding repayment. The Pune Tribunal held that the circumstances constituted reasonable cause under section 273B, warranting deletion of penalty.
Applying that reasoning, the Bangalore Tribunal considered the assessee’s financial difficulties and repayment pressures. It also found that the entire cash receipt was recorded in the registered sale deed and disclosed both in the return and during assessment proceedings.
The Tribunal observed that there was no intention to generate unaccounted money or black money. The Assessing Officer had examined the return and accepted the declared income. Considering these circumstances together, it deleted the entire penalty.
Observation Regarding Initiation of Proceedings
The Tribunal additionally noted that the assessment order contained no finding regarding violation of section 269SS. Penalty proceedings had also not been initiated by the Assessing Officer on or before completion of the assessment; the Joint Commissioner issued the notice approximately two months later.
However, the operative reasoning should be read carefully. The order principally grants relief by applying the reasonable-cause precedent and considering the disclosed nature of the transaction. It should not be presented as laying down an independent, universal rule invalidating every subsequent initiation of section 271D proceedings.
Author’s Comments
This decision offers useful support where pressing financial circumstances explain the cash receipt and the transaction is fully disclosed. Nevertheless, disclosure and payment of capital gains tax should not be treated as an automatic exemption from penalty.
The practical lesson is to establish the connection between the financial emergency and acceptance of cash. Credit card statements, repayment demands, recovery correspondence and evidence of utilisation can strengthen that explanation. The ruling recognises that reasonable cause requires a factual assessment, rather than a mechanical penalty merely because cash changed hands.
Cases Discussed
- P.R. Associates Vs ACIT — (2019) 70 ITR (Trib) 469 (Pune); AY 1999-2000. Principle: Cash borrowings undertaken to meet pressing financial liabilities may constitute reasonable cause under Section 273B, depending on the evidence and circumstances. Application: Expressly followed by the Bangalore ITAT in deleting the ₹41,91,500 penalty under Section 271D.
FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ITAT BANGALORE
This appeal at the instance of the assessee is directed against the order of the ld. CIT(A)/NFAC dated 19.02.2026 vide DIN & Order No. ITBA/NFAC/S/250/2025-26/1086233762(1) passed u/s 250 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (in short “the Act”) for the assessment year 2017-18.
2. The assessee has raised the following grounds of appeal:-
1. The order of the authorities below is against the fact and circumstances of the case and equity.
2. On the fact and circumstances of the case, under the provision of the law, and under the judicial precedence, the Joint Commissioner of Income Tax, Range – 7.2, Bangalore erred in levying the penalty u/s 271D of the Income Tax Act, 1961 as the cash receipt of Rs. 41,91,500 at the time of registration as part of the total consideration of Sale Deed dated 23.06.2016, the applicability of Sec. 269SS of the Income Tax Act, 1961 does not arise.
3. On the fact and circumstances of the case, under the provision of the law, and under the judicial precedence, the Joint Commissioner of Income Tax, Range – 7.2, Bangalore erred in levying the penalty u/s 271D of the Income Tax Act, 1961 wherein the Sale transaction of Immovable property dated 23.06.2016 has not been doubted during the course of scrutiny assessment and found to be genuine.
4. On the fact and circumstances of the case, under the provision of the law, and under the judicial precedence, the Joint Commissioner of Income Tax, Range – 7.2, Bangalore erred in levying the penalty u/s 271D of the Income Tax Act, 1961 as the Appellant was under the genuine and bonafide belief that Sec. 269SS of the Income Tax Act, 1961 is not applicable for the cash receipt of Rs. 41,91,500/- at the time of registration as part of the total consideration, which is the reasonable cause u.s 273B of the Income Tax Act, 1961.
5. On the fact and circumstances of the case, and under the provisions of law, the Commissioner of Income Tax Appeals erred in dismissing the appeal relying on the judgments where in the facts of the judgments relied on by the Commissioner of Income Tax Appeals is not similar to the facts of the Appellants case.
6. For these and other reasons which may be adduced at the time of the hearing, the Appellant prays before the Honourable Bench to delete the penalty levied by the Joint Commissioner of Income Tax, Range – 7.2, Bangalore u.s 271D of the Income Tax Act, 1961 for substantial cause of justice and equity.
7. The Appellant Most craves leaves to add, to alter, to amend or to delete any other grounds at the time of the hearing.
3. Brief facts of the case are that the assessee filed his return of income for A.Y.2017-18 on 28.03.2018 by declaring total income of Rs.24,46,490/-, being income from house property, business income, long term capital gains and income from other sources. The said return was thereafter processed u/s 143(1) of the Act by accepting the income returned. Subsequently, the case was selected for complete scrutiny under CASS for the following reasons:-
i) There is abnormal increase in cash deposits during demonetisation period as compared to average rate of cash deposit during pre-demonetisation period.
ii) The assessee has disclosed substantial sale consideration under the head Long Term Capital Gain and the LTCG disclosed before deduction u/s 54B, 54C, 54D, 54G, 54GA of the Act is quite low as compared to sale consideration.
Accordingly, a notice u/s 143(2) of the Act as well as notices u/s 142(1) of the Act were issued calling for the details. In response to the notices, the assessee furnished the details as called for. After verification of the details furnished by the assessee, the assessment was completed by accepting the returned income.
3.1 Thereafter, the ld. JCIT Range-7 (2), Bangalore had issued notice u/s 274 r.w.s. 271D of the Act dated 12.02.2020 directing the assessee to show cause as to why an order imposing penalty u/s 271D of the Act should not be made. The assessee filed his submission on 28.02.2020 by stating that his business was in a very bad shape and he was unable to maintain the day to day affairs of the family. Accordingly, the assessee borrowed money from different credit cards and due to the non-payment, the concerned recovery agents were behind him for recovery of the same. It was submitted that because of this exigency, the assessee requested the buyer to pay some cash for the repayment of his credit card loans and accordingly the assessee was compelled to receive Rs.41,91,500/- by cash which was also reflected in the sale deed and the assessee had duly discharged his tax liability arising on capital gains. Further, it was submitted that due to the above reasonable cause, the assessee accepted the cash even though it is not permitted.
3.2 The ld. JCIT however was of the opinion that the assessee had received Rs.41,91,500/- in cash, which is clear violation of the provisions of section 269SS of the Act. As per the provisions of section 271D of the Act, an amount of Rs.41,91,500/- being the cash received is the penalty to be levied in this case and the same was accordingly levied.
4. Aggrieved by the penalty order passed u/s 271D of the Act dated 18.03.2020, the assessee preferred an appeal before the ld. CIT(A)/NFAC.
5. The ld. CIT(A)/NFAC dismissed the appeal of the assessee by observing that the assessee received Rs.41,91,500/- in cash from the purchase of immovable property. The receipt of cash was clearly reflected in the registered sale deed. The amount received in cash far exceeds the threshold prescribed u/s 269SS of the Act. The provision of section 269SS of the Act, applicable from 01.06.2015, explicitly prohibits acceptance of any specified sum of Rs.20,000/- or more otherwise than through prescribed banking channels. Section 271D of the Act mandates levy of penalty equal to the amount so received in contravention. The ld. CIT(A)/NFAC held that the assessee has failed to establish a reasonable cause either during the penalty proceedings or during the appellate proceedings also and the penalty has been rightly levied u/s 271D of the Act. Accordingly, dismissed the appeal of the assessee.
6. Aggrieved by the order of ld. CIT(A)/NFAC dated 19.02.2026, the assessee has filed the present appeal before this Tribunal. The assessee has filed a paper book in support of his claim.
7. Before us, ld. A.R. of the assessee submitted that the order passed u/s 271D of the Act by the ld. JCIT is without considering the reasonable cause for accepting the cash above the threshold limit as cited by the assessee. The entire sale consideration including the cash component was declared in the income tax return and the capital gains was offered to tax. Further, the assessment order u/s 143(3) of the Act dated 17.12.2019 was passed by accepting the income returned. Out of the entire sales consideration, the assessee received Rs.90,00,000/- through bank transfer. Because of the circumstances and financial constraints, the assessee requested the buyer to pay some cash for the repayment of his card loans and hand loans as the loan recovery agents were constantly following up & demanding cash from the assessee as he was already a defaulter. Lastly, it is submitted that the transactions entered by the assessee are genuine and there is no involvement of any unaccounted money and accordingly prayed to allow the appeal of the assessee.
8. The ld. D.R. on the other hand supported the order of the authorities below and submitted that there is clear violation of the provision of section 269SS of the Act and therefore, the authorities below have rightly levied the penalty of Rs.41,91,500/- and prayed to dismiss the appeal of the assessee.
9. We have heard the rival submissions and perused the materials available on record. On going through the assessment order passed u/s 143(3) of the Act dated 17.12.2019, we take a note of the fact that while passing the assessment order, there is no finding of the AO regarding any violation of provision of section 269SS of the Act. The order of the assessment is very cryptic and only states that after carefully examining the details furnished by the assessee, the assessment is completed accepting the returned income. We also take a note of the fact that even the penalty proceedings u/s 271D of the Act was not initiated by AO on or before the completion of assessment proceedings. Subsequently after a gap of almost 2 months, a notice u/s 274 r.w.s. 271D of the Act was issued to the assessee on 12.02.2020 by the ld. JCIT Range-7(2), Bangalore. On going through the submissions made before the authorities below, we find that the main contention of the assessee is that he was unable to maintain the day to day affairs of his family as the business of the assessee was in a very bad shape and accordingly, the assessee had borrowed money from different credit cards. Further, due to non-payment, the concerned recovery agents were behind the assessee for recovery of the same. Because of the circumstances and financial constraints, the assessee requested the buyer to pay some cash for the repayment of his card loans and hand loans as the loan recovery agents were constantly following up & demanding cash from the assessee as he was already a defaulter. It was submitted that because of this exigency, the assessee was compelled to receive Rs.41,91,500/- by cash. In the instant case, the sale of property and consequent receipt of sale consideration in cash are not disputed by the either side.
9.1 On identical set of facts, the coordinate bench of ITAT, Pune in the case of P.R. Associates v. Asstt. CIT reported in (2019) 70 ITR (Trib) 469 has held as under:-
“4. We have heard the rival submissions and gone through the relevant material on record. There is no denial of fact that the assessee, in fact, raised loans in cash amounting to Rs. 88,18,000 which is in violation of the provisions of section 269SS of the Act. Once there is violation of the provisions of section 269SS, penalty is triggered under section 271D of the Act. However, it is relevant to note that section 273B deals with certain penal provisions, including section 271D, and provides that no penalty shall be imposed if the assessee succeeds in proving that the failure resulting in imposition of penalty was for a reasonable cause. Thus, it is evident that escape from the clutches of penalty under section 271D for violation of the provisions of section 269SS is possible when the assessee succeeds in proving that a reasonable cause existed in terms of section 273B for violation of section 269SS.
5. Adverting to the facts of the instant case, we find that the assessee specifically submitted before the assessing officer during the course of penalty proceedings, which fact has also been captured in the penalty order, that its business was inoperative for the last 7 years and it had already borrowed loans from Shree Suvarna Sahakari Bank Ltd. and many private money lenders since last 10 years. To meet the financial requirements of repayment, for which the lenders were hard pressing, the assessee had to borrow money from unorganized finance sector in cash, which led to the imposition of the instant penalty. Further, the assessee had a bank liability of about Rs. 50 crore against mortgage of assets of about Rs. 5 crore only, which fact has not been falsified. The submissions made by the assessee in this regard have not been controverted by the assessing officer or the learned Commissioner (Appeals) in any manner. When this fact is seen in the light of return filed by the assessee declaring loss of Rs. 4.35 lakhs, it clearly emerges that the loans were taken by the assessee in cash in violation of provisions of section 269SS to meet the financial liabilities. This in our considered opinion constitutes a reasonable cause warranting non-imposition of penalty under section 271D of the Act in terms of section 273B of the Act. We, therefore, order to delete the penalty of Rs. 88,18,000 imposed/enhanced by the Assessing officer/learned Commissioner (Appeals).”
9.2 Respectfully following the above decision of the coordinate bench, in the present case also, there was no intention whatsoever to generate unaccounted money/black money as the assessee had recorded the entire receipt of cash in the registered sale deed and duly disclosed the same not only in the return of income but also during the course of assessment proceedings. The ld. AO has also accepted the returned income while passing order u/s 143(3) of the Act. In view of the aforesaid reasoning and judicial pronouncements cited, we hold that the fact of the instant case penalty u/s 271D of the Act is not warranted and accordingly, we delete the same. It is ordered accordingly.
10. In the result, appeal filed by the assessee is allowed.
Order pronounced in the open court on 3rd Nov, 2026


