Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Fema / RBI

Round-Tripping Risks in India–UAE Business Structures: FEMA, Tax and Substance Issues

Summary: India–UAE business structures can support international fundraising, regional expansion and legitimate investment into India. However, where capital moves from India to a Dubai company and later returns as equity, loans, acquisition funding or service-related payments, the arrangement requires careful examination under both foreign-exchange and tax laws. Round-tripping is not automatically unlawful under the 2022 overseas-investment framework, but the permissibility of a particular structure depends on the Indian investor’s eligibility, bona fide overseas activity, financial-commitment limits, subsidiary layers and reporting. The UAE entity’s investment into India must separately satisfy foreign-investment entry routes, sectoral restrictions, pricing, beneficial-ownership and filing requirements. A commercial licence, corporate bank account or nominal office cannot substitute for real management, decision-making and documented business activity. Other areas of exposure include intercompany loans and external commercial borrowing conditions, transfer pricing, withholding tax, general anti-avoidance rules, India–UAE treaty eligibility, place of effective management and permanent-establishment risk. UAE Corporate Tax and free-zone qualification must also be evaluated rather than assuming all Dubai income is tax-free. Resident individuals may face additional restrictions compared with Indian corporate investors. The key practical safeguard is a complete ownership and funds-flow map supported by investment approvals, bank records, valuations, contracts, service evidence, management records and timely filings. Compliance should be revisited whenever the group adds subsidiaries, changes control, raises debt, issues guarantees or restructures. The decisive distinction is not simply whether funds return to India, but whether the entire arrangement has a genuine commercial purpose and satisfies each applicable regulatory framework.

Advertisement

Introduction

A common India–UAE structure begins with a simple commercial idea: an Indian entrepreneur establishes a company in Dubai, develops international operations and later uses the UAE company to invest in or conduct business with India.

The arrangement may appear commercially sensible. Dubai can provide access to regional customers, international banking, investors, logistics and a stable business environment. However, the structure becomes more sensitive when money originating from India travels through the UAE entity and returns to India as equity, debt, service payments or acquisition funding.

This movement is commonly described as round-tripping.

Round-tripping is not automatically prohibited merely because an Indian resident owns a UAE company that subsequently invests in India. The real questions are whether the structure complies with the overseas-investment rules, foreign-investment conditions, subsidiary-layer restrictions, tax laws and reporting requirements—and whether the UAE company performs a genuine commercial role.

A Dubai trade license and corporate bank account do not, by themselves, make the arrangement defensible.

What does round-tripping mean?

In a typical round-tripping structure, funds or value leave India, pass through an overseas entity and return to India directly or indirectly.

Examples include:

  • An Indian company establishing a Dubai subsidiary that later acquires shares in an Indian company;
  • An Indian resident funding a UAE company that invests in an Indian start-up;
  • A Dubai holding company acquiring the Indian business of its own promoter;
  • An Indian company lending to a UAE subsidiary that subsequently lends to an Indian group entity;
  • Indian profits being paid to a UAE company as service fees and later reinvested in India;
  • A UAE entity raising overseas finance secured by Indian assets and using the funds for Indian operations; or
  • An Indian-owned Dubai company establishing several subsidiaries before investing back into India.

Not every circular movement of funds is abusive. A UAE regional headquarters may have legitimate reasons to invest in India after raising international capital or developing operations across several countries.

The risk arises where the Dubai entity is inserted mainly to disguise ownership, obtain treaty relief, avoid Indian restrictions, convert domestic funds into apparently foreign investment or create an artificial tax advantage.

Round-tripping is no longer examined through a blanket assumption

Historically, India’s overseas-investment framework created substantial difficulty where an overseas entity established by an Indian resident proposed to invest back into India.

The Overseas Investment Rules, 2022 provide a more structured position. They do not impose a universal prohibition on every foreign entity that has Indian investment from investing into India.

Instead, the rules focus on conditions such as:

  • The foreign entity carrying on a bona fide business activity;
  • The Indian investor being eligible to make ODI;
  • Compliance with financial-commitment limits;
  • Proper reporting through an authorised dealer bank;
  • The legal form and limited liability of the foreign entity;
  • Restrictions on prohibited activities;
  • The number of subsidiary layers;
  • Compliance with Indian foreign-investment rules; and
  • The commercial substance and tax purpose of the arrangement.

This change should not be interpreted as unrestricted permission. A structure may satisfy the subsidiary-layer test and still fail under tax, transfer-pricing, beneficial-ownership or anti-abuse rules.

The two-layer restriction is central

A person resident in India cannot make financial commitment in a foreign entity that has invested or subsequently invests into India, directly or indirectly, if the arrangement results in a structure containing more than two layers of subsidiaries.

The restriction applies both when the financial commitment is first made and when the UAE company later changes its structure.

This means the review cannot stop after the Dubai company is incorporated. A later acquisition, new subsidiary, restructuring or Indian investment may cause a previously acceptable structure to exceed the permitted layers.

The RBI has also clarified that no additional subsidiary layer should be added to an existing structure that already contained two or more layers when the Overseas Investment Rules came into force.

Certain regulated classes of companies may fall within specified exceptions, but an ordinary trading, consultancy, technology or holding structure should not assume that an exception applies.

“Subsidiary” has a wider practical impact than many promoters expect

For the overseas-investment framework, a foreign entity can be treated as having a subsidiary where it exercises control.

Control can arise through:

  • The right to appoint a majority of directors;
  • Shareholding;
  • Management rights;
  • Shareholders’ agreements;
  • Voting agreements;
  • Policy-making rights; or
  • Voting rights of 10% or more, depending on the relevant circumstances.

A business owner may look only at companies labelled “subsidiary” in the accounts. The authorised dealer bank may examine the wider rights held through agreements and indirect ownership.

Minority stakes, joint ventures and special-purpose vehicles must therefore be mapped carefully. Dividing ownership among related parties does not necessarily prevent the entities from being treated as controlled parts of one structure.

How a simple India–Dubai–India structure may arise

Consider an Indian private company that establishes a wholly owned Dubai holding company. The Dubai company later subscribes to shares in another Indian operating company.

The arrangement creates both:

  • Outward investment from India into the UAE; and
  • Foreign investment from the UAE into India.

The outward leg must comply with the Overseas Investment Rules, Regulations and RBI reporting directions. The inward leg must separately comply with India’s foreign-investment framework, including entry route, sectoral limits, pricing, reporting and beneficial-ownership requirements.

Approval or reporting of one leg does not validate the other.

The Indian company cannot rely on its ODI filing to establish that the UAE company’s investment into India is permitted. Similarly, acceptance of an Indian foreign-investment filing does not confirm that the original overseas investment or subsidiary structure complied with FEMA.

The UAE company must conduct a bona fide business activity

Overseas investment is generally permitted only in a foreign entity carrying on a bona fide business activity—an activity legally permissible in India and the UAE.

A Dubai entity created exclusively to receive Indian funds and reinvest them in India may attract greater scrutiny, particularly where it has:

  • No employees;
  • No suitable premises;
  • No independent directors or management;
  • No operating expenditure;
  • No customers outside the Indian group;
  • No commercial risk;
  • No authority over its bank account;
  • No ability to make investment decisions; or
  • No reason to exist apart from obtaining tax or regulatory treatment.

A holding company is not automatically invalid merely because it does not sell goods or services. Holding companies can serve genuine purposes, including regional investment, fundraising, risk separation, acquisition management and succession planning.

However, the commercial purpose must be documented and reflected in actual conduct.

A free-zone license does not establish commercial substance

Indian promoters sometimes assume that incorporation in a recognised Dubai free zone proves that the entity is genuinely based in the UAE.

A license proves that the company is legally registered. It does not prove where decisions are made, who controls the funds or what economic activity occurs.

An authority may examine:

  • Where directors and investment committee members meet;
  • Who evaluates and approves Indian investments;
  • Where contracts are negotiated;
  • Who controls online banking;
  • Whether the UAE company bears real financial risk;
  • Whether it has qualified personnel;
  • Whether it earns income from independent commercial activity;
  • Whether its premises are appropriate; and
  • Whether its records support the stated purpose.

A flexi-desk, nominee officer and pre-prepared board minutes will not compensate for decisions that are actually made from India.

Indian investment into the UAE must be properly reported

The original investment in the Dubai company must comply with the overseas-investment framework.

Depending on the facts, the Indian investor may need to complete:

An Indian investor with overdue ODI reporting may be prevented from making further remittances or financial commitments until the default is regularised.

A round-tripping review should therefore begin with the history of the Dubai company—not only its proposed investment into India.

The inward Indian investment is a separate regulated transaction

When the UAE company invests in India, it is treated as a person resident outside India for FEMA purposes, subject to the applicable rules.

The Indian recipient must examine:

  • Whether foreign investment is permitted in the sector;
  • Whether the investment falls under the automatic or government route;
  • Applicable sectoral caps;
  • Pricing guidelines;
  • Permitted instruments;
  • Beneficial ownership;
  • Entry conditions;
  • Reporting requirements;
  • Downstream investment;
  • Mode of payment; and
  • Repatriation rights.

A Dubai company cannot invest in a restricted Indian activity merely because its ultimate owner is Indian.

Similarly, the fact that the ultimate beneficial owner already controls the Indian recipient does not remove the transaction from foreign-investment rules.

Beneficial ownership must be disclosed correctly

Banks and regulators increasingly examine the individuals who ultimately own or control a UAE investor.

The Dubai company should be able to provide:

  • Incorporation documents;
  • Current trade license;
  • Register of shareholders;
  • Ultimate-beneficial-owner information;
  • Organisational chart;
  • Passport and address records;
  • Source-of-funds evidence;
  • Details of directors and authorised signatories;
  • Audited or reliable financial statements; and
  • Explanation of the commercial purpose of the Indian investment.

Using relatives, employees or nominees to fragment ownership does not necessarily change the beneficial-ownership conclusion.

Misalignment among the UAE register, Indian filings, bank records and actual control can result in delayed remittances, rejected reporting or regulatory enquiries.

Source of funds is often the decisive issue

A legitimate Dubai company should be able to explain where the money used for the Indian investment came from.

Possible sources include:

  • Capital properly remitted from India;
  • Profits earned from genuine UAE operations;
  • Capital raised from independent foreign investors;
  • Borrowing from a UAE or international lender;
  • Sale of a genuine overseas asset; or
  • Dividends received from another foreign investment.

The risk rises where the UAE company receives funds shortly before investing in India and has no independent income or commercial history.

Authorities may ask whether:

  • The Indian promoter funded the UAE company;
  • The investment was financed through an undisclosed loan;
  • Indian group companies made excessive service or royalty payments to Dubai;
  • The UAE entity borrowed against a guarantee from India;
  • The funds came from another related offshore entity; or
  • The arrangement disguises Indian capital as foreign capital.

A complete banking trail should be maintained from the original source to the final Indian investment.

Service payments can create indirect round-tripping concerns

Round-tripping does not occur only through share capital.

An Indian company may pay management fees, consultancy charges, commissions, royalties or interest to its Dubai affiliate. The UAE company may then use those receipts to invest in India.

The arrangement becomes vulnerable where the payment:

  • Does not correspond to a genuine service;
  • Is disproportionate to the work performed;
  • Is supported by generic invoices;
  • Is immediately returned to India;
  • Has no commercial benefit for the Indian payer;
  • Is determined only after profits are known; or
  • Is inconsistent with the parties’ functions and risks.

Such payments may be challenged under transfer-pricing rules, withholding provisions, permanent-establishment principles and general anti-avoidance rules.

The strongest evidence is not the agreement alone. It is the record of work actually performed, people involved, deliverables provided and business benefit received.

Loans through Dubai require special caution

An Indian-owned UAE company may lend money to an Indian group entity, or raise an overseas loan and on-lend the funds to India.

This does not automatically become permissible foreign borrowing merely because the lender is incorporated in Dubai.

The transaction may need to comply with:

The Indian promoter should not use shareholder advances, current accounts or informal intercompany entries as substitutes for a compliant borrowing arrangement.

Resident individuals face additional structural restrictions

An Indian resident individual may establish or acquire an operating UAE company under the permitted ODI route, subject to the Liberalised Remittance Scheme and other conditions.

However, resident individuals have more limited flexibility where the foreign entity has or acquires subsidiaries.

A resident individual who has made ODI without control should not later acquire control in a foreign entity that establishes or acquires a subsidiary. The prescribed restrictions applicable to resident-individual ODI must be reviewed before the Dubai company becomes a holding vehicle.

A structure that is available to an Indian company may not be equally available to a resident individual.

This distinction is particularly important where a founder initially establishes a small Dubai consultancy and later converts it into an international holding company.

Round-tripping can trigger Indian tax anti-avoidance rules

FEMA compliance does not guarantee tax acceptance.

India’s General Anti-Avoidance Rules continue under the current income-tax framework. An arrangement can be challenged where its main purpose is to obtain a tax benefit and it contains features associated with an impermissible avoidance arrangement.

Authorities may examine whether the Dubai structure:

  • Creates rights or obligations not normally created between independent parties;
  • Misuses or abuses tax provisions;
  • Lacks commercial substance;
  • Uses accommodating parties;
  • Produces an outcome inconsistent with the arrangement’s real purpose; or
  • Routes income through the UAE primarily to reduce Indian tax.

A structure may have valid incorporation documents and still lack tax substance.

Treaty benefits are not automatic

A UAE company investing in India may seek relief under the India–UAE Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement for dividends, interest, royalties, capital gains or business income.

Treaty eligibility requires more than a UAE Tax Residency Certificate.

The Indian payer or tax authority may examine:

  • Whether the UAE company is the beneficial owner of the income;
  • Whether it has a permanent establishment in India;
  • Whether its residence claim is supportable;
  • Whether the arrangement satisfies applicable anti-abuse provisions;
  • Whether it is merely a conduit;
  • Who controls the income;
  • Whether it is required to pass the funds to another person; and
  • Whether the company performs meaningful commercial functions.

A Dubai company funded, managed and contractually controlled from India may struggle to support the intended treaty result even if it holds a valid license and residency certificate.

Place of effective management can reverse the intended outcome

A UAE company may be incorporated in Dubai but effectively managed from India.

Place of effective management broadly concerns the location where key management and commercial decisions necessary for conducting the business as a whole are actually made.

Risk factors include:

  • Indian promoters making all investment decisions;
  • UAE directors approving decisions after the event;
  • Contracts being negotiated and signed from India;
  • Dubai bank accounts being controlled from India;
  • No senior personnel operating in the UAE;
  • Accounting and records being maintained only in India; and
  • The company’s strategic direction being determined by the Indian parent.

If the UAE company is treated as an Indian tax resident, the expected tax and holding-company benefits may be substantially altered.

Permanent-establishment exposure must also be considered

Even if the UAE company remains a UAE tax resident, it may create an Indian permanent establishment.

This can arise where the UAE company has:

  • A fixed place available to it in India;
  • Employees performing core business functions in India;
  • A dependent agent concluding or securing contracts;
  • Senior management operating from India;
  • Long-duration service activities; or
  • Indian facilities used as more than preparatory support.

A Dubai holding or service company that performs nearly all its functions through Indian personnel may face attribution of profits to India.

UAE Corporate Tax has changed the commercial calculation

The UAE should no longer be viewed as a jurisdiction in which every company automatically pays no tax.

A Dubai company must consider UAE Corporate Tax registration, taxable income, transfer pricing, related-party disclosures and record-keeping.

A free-zone company may qualify for preferential treatment only if it satisfies the prescribed conditions. Merely holding a free-zone license does not guarantee a 0% rate on every category of income.

An Indian investment structure should examine:

  • Nature of income received from India;
  • Qualifying and non-qualifying income;
  • Adequate substance;
  • Related-party transactions;
  • Audited financial statements where required;
  • Elections and reliefs;
  • Withholding taxes paid in India; and
  • Availability of foreign tax credit.

The UAE tax analysis should be completed before projecting the benefits of the structure.

Transfer pricing applies in both directions

Transactions between the Indian business and its UAE affiliate must be commercially priced and documented.

Common transactions include:

  • Management and consultancy fees;
  • Loans and interest;
  • Guarantees;
  • Royalties;
  • Cost-sharing arrangements;
  • Purchase and sale of goods;
  • Marketing support;
  • Software and technology services;
  • Staff secondments; and
  • Reimbursement of expenses.

Authorities may question both excessive payments from India and undercharging by the UAE company.

A structure designed only around withholding rates, without analysing functions, assets and risks, is unlikely to remain defensible.

A practical Dubai holding-company example

Assume an Indian technology company establishes a wholly owned Dubai holding company. The stated objective is to raise capital from Middle Eastern investors and expand across the Gulf.

The Dubai company rents an office, appoints experienced management, opens its own bank account and develops operations in the UAE. It raises capital from an independent investor and later acquires 40% of another Indian technology company.

This structure is not necessarily prohibited merely because capital returns to India. However, it requires a connected review of:

  • The Indian company’s original ODI;
  • The Dubai company’s commercial activity;
  • Control and subsidiary layers;
  • Source of the acquisition funds;
  • Indian foreign-investment conditions;
  • Valuation and pricing;
  • Beneficial ownership;
  • Form FC, UIN, APR and FLA reporting;
  • Indian inward-investment reporting;
  • Transfer pricing;
  • UAE Corporate Tax;
  • Treaty eligibility; and
  • Actual location of management.

Now consider a different arrangement. An Indian promoter sends funds to a newly incorporated Dubai company with no employees or operations. The funds are immediately invested into the promoter’s Indian business at a higher valuation. Management, banking and investment decisions remain in India.

Even if the corporate filings are completed, the second structure carries substantially greater FEMA, valuation, tax and anti-abuse risk.

The difference lies in commercial purpose and operational facts—not the appearance of the Dubai incorporation certificate.

Warning signs that attract scrutiny

A round-tripping structure deserves deeper review where:

  • The UAE entity has no independent business purpose;
  • Funds return to India shortly after leaving;
  • The investment passes through multiple holding companies;
  • Ownership is split among related nominees;
  • The UAE company has no personnel or decision-making capability;
  • Indian residents control every UAE bank transaction;
  • Service payments lack evidence;
  • The Indian valuation changes substantially within a short period;
  • The UAE entity invests mainly in its promoter’s Indian business;
  • Loans are routed through informal current accounts;
  • ODI and inward-investment filings show inconsistent ownership;
  • The structure exceeds or may exceed the subsidiary-layer restriction;
  • The UAE company claims treaty benefits without beneficial ownership; or
  • Corporate documents do not reflect actual conduct.

No single factor automatically proves non-compliance. Several factors together can make the structure difficult to defend.

Due diligence before implementing the structure

Before an Indian-owned UAE company invests into India, the parties should prepare a complete structure memorandum covering:

  • Identity and residence of every investor;
  • Direct and indirect ownership;
  • Voting and management rights;
  • All subsidiaries and controlled entities;
  • Source and movement of funds;
  • Original ODI compliance;
  • Financial-commitment limits;
  • Proposed Indian investment route;
  • Sectoral caps and approvals;
  • Pricing and valuation;
  • Beneficial ownership;
  • Transfer pricing;
  • Tax residence and treaty entitlement;
  • UAE Corporate Tax;
  • Place of effective management;
  • Permanent-establishment risk; and
  • Ongoing reporting obligations.

The organisational chart should show all entities, not only the companies directly involved in the remittance.

Compliance does not end after the first investment

A permissible structure can become problematic later.

Events requiring renewed review include:

  • Establishing another UAE or overseas subsidiary;
  • Acquiring control in a joint venture;
  • The Dubai company investing into another Indian entity;
  • Adding a holding company above the UAE business;
  • Introducing a trust or foundation;
  • Issuing guarantees;
  • Providing intercompany loans;
  • Changing the shareholders’ agreement;
  • Relocating management to India;
  • Selling part of the UAE company; and
  • Bringing new investors into the structure.

The finance and legal teams should review the complete ownership chart before every material restructuring.

Practical checklist

Before implementing an India–UAE–India structure, confirm:

  • The UAE company has a genuine commercial purpose;
  • The Indian outward investment was lawfully made and reported;
  • Form FC, UIN and evidence-of-investment requirements are complete;
  • APR and FLA filings are up to date;
  • The UAE entity and its subsidiaries have limited liability where required;
  • The complete structure remains within the subsidiary-layer restriction;
  • Control rights have been analysed, not merely ownership percentages;
  • The UAE company’s source of funds is documented;
  • Indian foreign-investment entry conditions are satisfied;
  • Sectoral caps and government approvals have been reviewed;
  • Valuation is commercially supportable;
  • Beneficial ownership is consistently disclosed;
  • Loans comply with the applicable borrowing framework;
  • Related-party transactions are priced at arm’s length;
  • UAE management and operational substance are real;
  • Treaty and foreign-tax-credit positions are supportable;
  • POEM and permanent-establishment risks have been considered; and
  • Future restructuring will be reviewed before implementation.

Conclusion

Round-tripping is not determined solely by drawing a line from India to Dubai and another line back to India. The regulatory outcome depends on the purpose, ownership, control, subsidiary layers, source of funds and actual operation of the structure.

A genuine Dubai headquarters or holding company can invest in India where the outward and inward transactions comply with the applicable rules. The arrangement becomes vulnerable when the UAE company serves mainly as a conduit, lacks decision-making substance or is used to recharacterise Indian funds as foreign capital.

The strongest India–UAE structure is one that can explain, with documents and commercial evidence, why the Dubai company exists, what functions it performs, where its money came from and why its Indian investment makes business sense.

Advertisement

Author Info

Mandeep Singh
Qualification: CA in Job / Business
Company: KPM GLOBAL
Location: Dubai, Dubai
Articles Published: 48

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *