Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Goods and Services Tax

Circular Cannot Deny Interest Refund After GST Export Tax Refunded: P&H HC

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 18904
Case Name
Ernst and Young LLP Vs Union of India and Others (Punjab and Haryana High Court)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Ernst and Young LLP Vs Union of India and Others (Punjab and Haryana High Court)

Circular Cannot Bar Refund of Interest Paid Under Rule 96A, Once the Tax on Delayed Export Realisation Is Refunded

The Hon’ble Punjab and Haryana High Court in Ernst and Young LLP v. Union of India and Others [CWP-19850-2024 dated September 30, 2026] quashed paragraph 4.6 of Circular No. 197/09/2023-GST dated July 17, 2023 to the extent it bars refund of interest paid under Rule 96A(1) of the CGST Rules, 2017, and held that where the tax paid on account of delayed realisation of export proceeds has been refunded, the Revenue cannot retain the interest paid on that tax merely on the strength of a circular, as such retention must have an independent basis in the Act or the Rules.

Facts:

  • Ernst and Young LLP (the“Petitioner”) exports professional services to clients located outside India without payment of IGST, having furnished a Letter of Undertaking (“LUT”) under Rule 96A of the CGST Rules, 2017.
  • Rule 96A(1)(b), as applicable to the Petitioner, required the export consideration to be realised in convertible foreign exchange within one year from the date of invoice, failing which the tax along with interest under Section 50 of the CGST Act, 2017 was payable.
  • The Petitioner could not realise the consideration within one year and therefore deposited the tax along with interest. The consideration was, however, subsequently realised, though after the prescribed period.
  • The Petitioner claimed refund of both the tax and the interest. The tax was refunded vide orders dated April 12, 2022 and April 13, 2022, but the refund of interest was rejected.
  • The Additional Commissioner (Appeals), CGST, Gurugram upheld the rejection vide order dated February 28, 2023 by relying on paragraph 4.6 of Circular No. 197/09/2023-GST, which provides that no refund of the interest paid in compliance with Rule 96A(1) shall be admissible.
  • Aggrieved, the Petitioner filed a writ petition seeking to quash the appellate order to that extent and a declaration that paragraph 4.6 of the Circular is ultra vires the CGST Act.

Contentions of the Petitioner:

  • The Act does not prescribe any time limit for receipt of payment in convertible foreign exchange under Section 2(6)(iv) of the IGST Act, 2017; the one-year period is found only in Rule 96A, and a condition in the Rules cannot curtail what the Act itself recognises as an export of services (relying on Zenith Spinners).
  • Interest under Section 50 is compensatory and depends on the principal tax. Once the supply is accepted as zero-rated and the tax is refunded, the interest cannot survive independently (relying on Pratibha Processors, Jayathi Krishnaand Bill Forge).
  • A circular cannot create a restriction not contemplated by the statute or the Rules (relying on Ratan Melting & Wire Industries).
  • In the alternative, the amount is refundable under Section 54(1) of the CGST Act read with Rule 89(2)(k), as the provision covers tax, interest paid thereon and “any other amount paid”.

Contentions of the Respondents:

  • Rule 96A(1)(b) is a machinery provision giving effect to Section 2(6)(iv) of the IGST Act. The liability to interest arose on default and subsequent realisation of proceeds does not wipe it out.
  • Interest under Section 50 is compensatory for the period the Revenue remained deprived of the tax (relying on Associated Cement Co. Ltd.), and Pratibha Processorsis distinguishable.
  • Rule 96B, which deals with export of goods, provides for refund of tax but not of interest, which is consistent with paragraph 4.6 of the Circular.
  • Section 54 does not create an independent right to refund of interest which is otherwise non-refundable (relying on Mafatlal Industriesand Dilip Kumar & Co.), and an exporter who realises proceeds in time cannot be equated with one who does not, so there is no violation of Article 14.

Issues:

  • Whether, once the tax deposited under Rule 96A of the CGST Rules, 2017 has been refunded upon subsequent realisation of the export proceeds, the Revenue can still retain the interest paid on such tax solely on the strength of paragraph 4.6 of Circular No. 197/09/2023-GST dated July 17, 2023?
  • Whether a circular can impose a restriction on refund of interest when Section 54(1) of the CGST Act expressly contemplates refund of tax and interest paid thereon, and neither the Act nor Rule 96A provides for such retention?
  • Whether the silence of Rule 96B on refund of interest can be imported into Rule 96A to sustain the denial of refund?

Held:

The Hon’ble Punjab and Haryana High Court in CWP-19850-2024 held as under:

  • Observed that Rule 96A(1)(b) requires payment of tax with interest under Section 50 on failure to realise the export proceeds in time, but it does not provide for the consequence where the proceeds are subsequently realised and the tax is refunded, nor does it provide that the interest shall nevertheless be retained. The bar on refund of interest is found only in paragraph 4.6 of the Circular.
  • Noted that Section 54(1) of the CGST Act expressly contemplates a claim for refund of tax and interest, if any, paid on such tax, besides any other amount paid, and is wide enough to cover a claim for refund of interest paid along with the tax.
  • Observed that the refund of tax is significant. Having accepted the subsequent realisation and refunded the tax, the Revenue cannot justify retention of the interest merely by relying on paragraph 4.6, and the retention must be tested on the provisions of the Act and the Rules.
  • Held that a circular may clarify how a statutory provision is to be administered but cannot override or alter the statute, as reiterated by the Constitution Bench in Ratan Melting & Wire Industries. Paragraph 4.6, to the extent it prohibits refund of interest, travels beyond the Act and the Rules and must yield to them.
  • Rejected the Revenue’s submission that the liability to interest had crystallised and could not be undone, holding that once the tax is refunded, retention of the interest must have an independent statutory basis, and none was pointed out except paragraph 4.6.
  • Held that Associated Cement, Mafatlal Industriesand Dilip Kumar & Co. do not answer the narrow question, and that the Revenue’s attempt to distinguish Pratibha Processors and Jayathi Krishna was not persuasive, as interest is compensatory and ordinarily follows the principal amount.
  • Held that reliance on Rule 96B is misplaced, as it operates in a different field (recovery and restoration of refund on export of goods), and its silence on refund of interest cannot be imported into Rule 96A or used to restrict Section 54(1). The Article 14 argument was held not to require adjudication.
  • Directed that paragraph 4.6 of Circular No. 197/09/2023-GST is bad in law and quashed to the extent it provides that no refund of interest paid under Rule 96A(1) is admissible where the tax paid along with such interest has been refunded upon realisation of the export proceeds.
  • Directed that the appellate order dated February 28, 2023 be set aside to the extent it rejects the refund of interest and that the Respondents refund the interest, corresponding to the tax already refunded, within eight weeks from receipt of the certified copy of the order, failing which interest under Section 56 of the CGST Act shall be payable from the date of expiry of that period until actual payment.
  • Hence, the writ petition was allowed without any order as to costs.

Our Comments:

Provisions invoked. The dispute sits at the intersection of the zero-rating provisions and the refund machinery. Section 2(6) of the IGST Act, 2017 defines “export of services” and clause (iv) requires the payment to be received in convertible foreign exchange, but does not prescribe any time limit. Section 16 of the IGST Act zero-rates exports and allows export under bond or LUT without payment of tax. Rule 96A(1)(b) of the CGST Rules, 2017 is the source of the one-year period, and on default it requires payment of the tax with interest under Section 50 of the CGST Act. Section 54(1) of the CGST Act covers refund of “any tax and interest, if any, paid on such tax or any other amount paid”, and Section 56 provides interest on delayed refunds.

The Circular position. Circular No. 125/44/2019-GST dated November 18, 2019 clarified the manner of compliance with Rule 96A(1). Thereafter, Circular No. 197/09/2023-GST dated July 17, 2023 clarified that on subsequent realisation of the export proceeds, the exporter can claim refund of the tax paid earlier, but no refund of interest would be admissible. This is the line the High Court has now struck down. The practical effect is that the Circular, as interpreted by the departmental authorities, had converted an interest cost into a permanent levy even on a transaction the Department itself accepted as a genuine export.

Pari materia and supporting judgments. The ruling is in line with the settled principle that a circular cannot travel beyond the statute. The Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in Commissioner of Central Excise, Bolpur v. Ratan Melting & Wire Industries [2008 (231) E.L.T. 22 (S.C.)] held that circulars contrary to the statutory provisions have no existence in law. On the nature of interest, Pratibha Processors v. Union of India [(1996) 11 SCC 101] and Commissioner of Customs v. Jayathi Krishna & Co. [2000 (119) E.L.T. 4 (S.C.)] support the view that interest is compensatory and follows the principal duty, so that it cannot survive where the principal is not payable. Commissioner of Central Excise and Service Tax, LTU, Bangalore v. Bill Forge Pvt. Ltd. [2012 (279) E.L.T. 209 (Kar.)] also recognises the compensatory character of interest. Further, in Union of India v. Zenith Spinners [2015 (326) E.L.T. 23 (S.C.)], affirming [2015 (326) E.L.T. 97 (Guj.)], the power to prescribe conditions and safeguards for a facility was held not to extend to curtailing the substantive benefit conferred by the statute, which is the same logic applied to Rule 96A and the Circular.

Contrary view. The Revenue relied on Associated Cement Co. Ltd. v. Commercial Tax Officer, Kota [(1981) 4 SCC 578] for the proposition that interest is compensatory for the period of default and survives later events, on Mafatlal Industries Ltd. v. Union of India [(1997) 5 SCC 536] for the rule that refund is governed strictly by the statutory scheme, and on Commissioner of Customs (Import), Mumbai v. Dilip Kumar & Co. [(2018) 9 SCC 1] for strict construction. The Court held that none of these answers the narrow question of whether interest on a refunded tax can be retained without statutory authority. It is also noteworthy that the Court accepted the Revenue’s argument only partly: it did not hold that interest was never payable for the period of default, but that the retention after refund of the tax needs an independent legal basis.

Key takeaways for exporters.

  • Exporters of services who paid tax and interest under Rule 96A(1)(b) on delayed realisation, and whose interest refund was rejected or not claimed, should examine a refund claim under Section 54(1) read with Rule 89(2)(k), keeping the two-year limitation in Section 54(1) in view.
  • Pending appeals and refund applications before the Appellate Authorities should now be supplemented with this judgment, specifically on the ground that paragraph 4.6 has been held to be bad in law.
  • The judgment is of the Punjab and Haryana High Court and is binding within its territorial jurisdiction while being of strong persuasive value elsewhere. Until the Board withdraws or amends the Circular, or the matter is carried further by the Revenue, exporters outside the jurisdiction may need to pursue writ remedies to obtain relief.
  • Where refund is not made within eight weeks of receipt of the certified copy of the order, the amount carries interest under Section 56 of the CGST Act.

We recommend that exporters maintain complete records of FIRC or bank realisation certificates and the dates of payment of tax and interest under Rule 96A, as these will be the primary documents in any claim for refund of interest.
Cases Discussed

  • Zenith Spinners v. Union of India (Gujarat High Court; 2015 (326) E.L.T. 97 (Guj.)). Petitioner relied on statutory benefits not being curtailed by subordinate conditions.
  • Union of India v. Zenith Spinners (Supreme Court; 2015 (326) E.L.T. 23 (S.C.)). Affirmance cited by petitioner.
  • Pratibha Processors v. Union of India (Supreme Court; (1996) 11 SCC 101). Compensatory nature of interest; relied upon in reasoning.
  • Commissioner of Customs v. Jayathi Krishna (Supreme Court; judgment cites 2002 (119) E.L.T. 4 (S.C.)). Interest follows principal liability; source citation retained.
  • Commissioner of Central Excise and Service Tax, LTU, Bangalore v. Bill Forge Pvt. Ltd. (Karnataka High Court; 2012 (279) E.L.T. 209 (Kar.)). Compensatory character of interest.
  • Commissioner of Central Excise, Bolpur v. Ratan Melting & Wire Industries (Supreme Court (Constitution Bench); 2008 (231) E.L.T. 22 (S.C.)). Circular cannot override statutory provisions.
  • Ambe Wire Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India (W.P.(C) No. 4066/2021; court/date not specified in judgment). Cited by petitioner.
  • Associated Cement Co. Ltd. v. Commercial Tax Officer, Kota (Supreme Court; (1981) 4 SCC 578). Revenue cited compensatory interest; distinguished.
  • Mafatlal Industries Ltd. v. Union of India (Supreme Court; (1997) 5 SCC 536). Revenue cited statutory refund scheme; distinguished.
  • Commissioner of Customs (Import), Mumbai v. Dilip Kumar & Co. (Supreme Court; (2018) 9 SCC 1). Revenue cited strict construction; distinguished.
  • R.K. Garg v. Union of India (Supreme Court; (1981) 4 SCC 675). Revenue cited fiscal classification; not decisive.

FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA HIGH COURT

1. This writ petition has been filed by the petitioner, Ernst and young LLP, seeking quashing of the order dated 28.02.2023 passed by the Appellate Authority, i.e., Additional Commissioner (Appeals), Gurugram, to the extent that it rejects the petitioner’s claim for refund of interest paid under Rule 96A of the Central Goods and Services Tax Rules, 2017 (“the Rules”). The petitioner has further sought a declaration that Paragraph 4.6 of the Circular No.197/09/2023 GST dated 17.07.2023 is ultra vires the provisions of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (“the CGST Act”), to the extent that it provides that a supplier is not entitled to seek refund of interest paid under Rule 96A of the Rules.

2. The facts of the case, which are largely undisputed, may be noticed as under.

2.1 The petitioner is engaged in the export of professional services to clients located outside India. In respect of the exports in question, the petitioner did not pay Integrated Goods and Services Tax (IGST) at the time of supply, having furnished a Letter of Undertaking (LUT) under Rule 96A of the Central Goods and Services Tax Rules, 2017 (for short, “the CGST Rules”). The said Rule permits an exporter to export goods or services without upfront payment of tax, subject to fulfilment of the conditions prescribed thereunder.

Rule 96A(1)(b) of the CGST Rules, as applicable to the case of the petitioner, required the payment for export of services to be realised in convertible foreign exchange within a period of one year from the date of the invoice. In the event of failure to realise such payment within the stipulated period, the exporter was required to pay the tax which would otherwise have been payable on such export, along with interest under Section 50 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (for short, “the CGST Act”) for the period of delay.

3. In the present case, the petitioner could not realise the export consideration within the stipulated period of one year and, accordingly, deposited the tax along with interest in terms of Rule 96A of the CGST Rules. It is not in dispute that the export consideration was subsequently realised by the petitioner, though after expiry of the aforesaid period.

Upon receipt of the foreign remittance, the petitioner sought refund of both the tax as well as the interest deposited by it. The refund of the tax component was allowed. The claim for refund of interest, however, was declined. The petitioner carried the said rejection in appeal, but without success. The rejection of refund of interest came to be affirmed by the Appellate Authority vide the impugned order dated 28.02.2023, inter alia, by placing reliance upon paragraph 4.6 of Circular No. 197/09/2023-GST dated 17.07.2023.

4. The short question that, therefore, arises for consideration is whether, once the tax deposited by the petitioner under Rule 96A of the CGST Rules has been refunded upon subsequent realisation of the export proceeds, the interest paid along with such tax can still be retained by the Revenue solely on the strength of paragraph 4.6 of Circular No. 197/09/2023-GST dated 17.07.2023, which provides that no refund of the interest paid in compliance with Rule 96A(1) shall be admissible.

5. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the expression “export of services” is defined under Section 2(6) of the Integrated Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017. Clause (iv) thereof requires that the payment for such service be received by the supplier in convertible foreign exchange, but the Act itself does not prescribe any time limit within which such payment is to be received. The period of one year finds mention only in Rule 96A of the CGST Rules, which is in the nature of subordinate legislation prescribing the conditions and safeguards for export without payment of tax.

It is, thus, contended that a condition prescribed by the Rules cannot be construed so as to curtail or alter what the principal enactment itself recognises as an “export of services”.

6. In support of the aforesaid contention, reliance is placed upon the judgment of the Gujarat High Court in Zenith Spinners v. Union of India, 2015 (326) E.L.T. 97 (Guj.), which was affirmed by the Supreme Court in Union of India v. Zenith Spinners, 2015 (326) Ε.L.T. 23 (S.C.). On the strength of the aforesaid decisions, it is contended that the power to prescribe conditions, safeguards and procedures in respect of a facility conferred by the statute cannot be exercised in a manner which has the effect of curtailing or restricting the substantive benefit granted by the statute itself.

7. Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits, with reference to paragraphs 4.5 to 4.7 of Circular No. 197/09/2023-GST dated 17.07.2023, that the Circular itself recognises that where the export proceeds are realised beyond the period prescribed under Rule 96A, the benefit of zero-rated supply would not be denied and the tax earlier deposited may be refunded as “excess payment of tax”. Once the export proceeds have been realised and the tax deposited on account of delay in such realisation has itself been refunded, it is contended that the Revenue cannot retain the interest paid on that very tax by treating the tax liability as having subsisted during the intervening period.

8. The argument is carried further with reference to Section 50 of the CGST Act. Interest under the said provision, according to learned counsel, is compensatory in character and is dependent upon the principal liability to tax. Once the transaction is accepted as a zero-rated supply and the tax paid under Rule 96A is refunded, the interest paid thereon cannot survive independently. Reliance for this proposition is placed upon Pratibha Processors v. Union of India, (1996) 11 SCC 101; Commissioner of Customs v. Jayathi Krishna, 2002 (119) E.L.T. 4 (S.C.); and Commissioner of Central Excise and Service Tax, LTU, Bangalore v. Bill Forge Pvt. Ltd., 2012 (279) E.L.T. 209 (Kar.).

9. Learned counsel also assails paragraph 4.6 of the Circular insofar as it provides that the interest paid in compliance with Rule 96A(1) would not be refundable. It is urged that neither Section 16 of the IGST Act nor Rule 96A of the CGST Rules authorises retention of such interest after the underlying tax itself has been refunded. A departmental circular, it is submitted, cannot create a liability or impose a restriction which is not contemplated by the statute or the Rules. Reliance in this regard is placed upon the Constitution Bench judgment of the Supreme Court in Commissioner of Central Excise, Bolpur v. Ratan Melting & Wire Industries, 2008 (231) E.L.T. 22 (S.C.), as also upon Ambe Wire Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India, W.P.(C) No. 4066/2021.

10. Lastly, an alternative submission is made that even if the amount is not held refundable as interest under Section 50 of the CGST Act, its refund would nevertheless be available under Section 54(1) of the Act read with Rule 89(2)(k) of the CGST Rules. Learned counsel draws attention to the language of Section 54(1), which permits refund not only of tax and interest paid thereon but also of “any other amount paid”. It is, accordingly, submitted that where the Revenue has no authority in law to retain the amount, refund thereof cannot be denied merely because it was originally deposited as interest under Rule 96A.

11. Per contra, learned Senior Standing Counsel appearing for the respondents opposes the petition and submits that Rule 96A(1)(b) of the CGST Rules is a machinery provision intended to give effect to the requirement under Section 2(6) (iv) of the IGST Act that payment for export of services be received in convertible foreign exchange. Failure to realise the export proceeds within the prescribed period attracts the liability to tax along with interest, and subsequent realisation of such proceeds does not wipe out the interest liability which had already arisen for the period of default.

12. It is further contended that interest under Section 50 of the CGST Act is compensatory in nature and is payable for the period during which the Revenue remained deprived of the tax. Subsequent realisation of the export proceeds cannot undo that period of default. Reliance is placed upon Associated Cement Co. Ltd. v. Commercial Tax Officer, Kota, (1981) 4 SCC 578. Pratibha Processors v. Union of India, 1996 (88) E.L.T. 12 (S.C.), and the decisions following it are sought to be distinguished on the ground that they arose in a different statutory setting where the underlying duty itself ceased to be payable.

13. Learned Senior Standing Counsel also draws support from Rule 96B of the CGST Rules relating to export of goods, which contemplates refund of tax upon subsequent realisation of export proceeds but makes no corresponding provision for refund of interest. This, according to him, is consistent with paragraph 4.6 of the Circular, which permits refund of tax but not of the interest paid for the period of default.

14. The alternative claim under Section 54 of the CGST Act is also resisted on the ground that refund is governed by the statutory scheme and Section 54 cannot be construed as creating an independent right to refund interest which is otherwise not refundable under Rule 96A read with the Circular. Reliance is placed upon Mafatlal Industries Ltd. v. Union of India, (1997) 5 SCC 536, and Commissioner of Customs (Import), Mumbai v. Dilip Kumar & Co., (2018) 9 SCC 1.

15. Lastly, the plea based on Article 14 is opposed by contending that an exporter who realises the export proceeds within the prescribed period cannot be equated with one who does so after the stipulated period. Reliance is placed upon R.K. Garg v. Union of India, (1981) 4 SCC 675, for the latitude available to legislation dealing with economic and fiscal matters.

16. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and, with their assistance, perused the record.

17. Before dealing with the rival submissions, it would be useful to notice Section 54(1) of the CGST Act, which provides for refund and reads as under:-

“(1) Any person claiming refund of any tax and interest, if any, paid on such tax or any other amount paid by him, may make an application before the expiry of two years from the relevant date in such form and manner as may be prescribed: Provided that a registered person, claiming refund of any balance in the electronic cash ledger in accordance with the provisions of sub-section (6) of section 49, may claim such refund in the return furnished under Section 39 in such manner as may be prescribed.”

18. Section 54(1) expressly contemplates refund not only of tax but also of interest, if any, paid on such tax, besides “any other amount” paid by a person. The provision, therefore, is wide enough to encompass a claim for refund of interest paid along with the tax, subject, of course, to the other requirements of the Act and the Rules.

19. Rule 96A(1) (b) requires an exporter of services, who has exported without payment of tax under an LUT, to realise the export proceeds within the prescribed períod. On failure to do so, the tax becomes payable along with interest under Section 50. The Rule, however, does not provide for the consequence where the export proceeds are subsequently realised and the tax so deposited is refunded. More particularly, it does not provide that the interest paid along with such tax shall nevertheless be retained. The restriction against refund of interest is found in paragraph 4.6 of the Circular.

20. In the present case, there is no dispute that the export proceeds were eventually realised in convertible foreign exchange. It is equally undisputed that, upon such realisation, the respondents refunded the tax deposited by the petitioner under Rule 96A. The dispute survives only in respect of the interest paid on that tax.

21. The refund of the tax is significant. Having accepted the subsequent realisation of the export proceeds and refunded the tax paid under Rule 96A, the Revenue cannot justify retention of the interest merely by relying upon paragraph 4.6 of the Circular. Whether such interest can be retained must ultimately be tested on the provisions of the Act and the Rules.

22. Paragraph 4.6 of Circular No. 197/09/2023-GST dated 17.07.2023 reads as under:-

“It is also clarified that in such cases subsequent to export of the goods or realization of payment in case of export of services, as the case may be, the said exporters would be entitled to claim refund of the integrated tax so paid earlier on account of goods not being exported, or as the case be, the payment not being realized for export of services, within the time frame prescribed in clause (a) or (b), as the case may be, of sub-rule (1) of rule 96A. It is further being clarified that no refund of the interest paid in compliance of sub-rule (1) of rule 96A shall be admissible.”

23. The Circular thus permits refund of the tax upon subsequent realisation of the export proceeds, but denies refund of the interest paid on such tax. The difficulty is that neither Rule 96A nor Section 54 contains any corresponding stipulation that the interest must continue to be retained even after the tax has been refunded. On the contrary, Section 54(1) expressly refers to a claim for refund of “tax and interest, if any, paid on such tax”. The denial of refund of interest under paragraph 4.6 must, therefore, have support in the statute or the Rules and cannot rest upon the Circular alone.

24. It is settled principle that a circular issued by the Board may clarify the manner in which a statutory provision is to be administered, but cannot override or alter the statute. The Constitution Bench in Commissioner of Central Excise, Bolpur v. Ratan Melting & Wire Industries, 2008 (231) E.L.T. 22 (S.C.), reiterated that a circular contrary to the statutory provisions cannot prevail. Paragraph 4.6 of the Circular must, therefore, yield of its prohibition against refund of interest, which travels beyond the Act or the Rules.

25. We may now deal with the submissions advanced on behalf of the respondents.

26. The first submission is that the liability to interest on tax crystalllised when the petitioner failed to realise the export proceeds within the prescribed period and that subsequent realisation cannot undo the default. We are unable to accept the submission in the absolute form in which it is advanced. The Circular itself recognises the consequence of subsequent realisation and permits refund of the tax paid under Rule 96A. Once the tax is refunded, retention of the interest paid thereon must have an independent statutory basis. No such provision has been pointed out to us except paragraph 4.6 of the Circular.

27. The reliance upon Associated Cement Co. Ltd. v. Commercial Tax Officer, Kota (supra) also does not carry the matter further. There can be no dispute with the general proposition that tax, interest and penalty are distinct concepts. The question here, however, is narrower: whether interest paid on a tax subsequently refunded can nevertheless be retained when the statute and the Rules do not expressly provide for such retention. The said decision does not answer this question.

28. The respondents have also sought to distinguish Pratibha Processors (supra) and Jayathi Krishna (supra). The distinction does not persuade us. The principle relevant for the present purpose is that interest is compensatory and ordinarily follows the principal amount on which it is levied. Once the tax deposited under Rule 96A has been refunded upon subsequent realisation of the export proceeds, the Revenue must demonstrate the statutory basis for retaining the interest independently of that tax. Bill Forge Pvt. Ltd. (supra), though rendered in a different factual context, also recognises the compensatory character of interest.

29. The reliance upon Rule 96B is equally misplaced. Rule 96B operates in a different field and deals with recovery of refund already granted in respect of export of goods where the sale proceeds are not realised, and restoration of the refund upon subsequent realisation. Its silence regarding refund of interest cannot be imported into Rule 96A so as to create a restriction which is not expressly found there. Much less can such silence restrict the scope of Section 54(1) of the Act.

30. Mafatlal Industries Ltd. (supra) does not advance the case of the respondents either. The proposition that a claim for refund must be governed by the statute is unexceptionable. The petitioner, however, rests its claim upon Section 54(1) itself, which expressly refers to refund of tax and interest paid thereon. Similarly, the principle stated in Dilip Kumar & Co. (supra) concerning strict construction of exemption provisions cannot permit an executive circular to introduce a restriction which is not found in the statutory provision governing the claim.

31. The argument founded upon Article 14 also need not detain us. The question before us is not on an identical footing. The question is whether, after the tax paid under Rule 96A has been refunded upon subsequent realisation of the export proceeds, the interest can continue to be retained without statutory authority. The validity of such retention must be determined by the Act and the Rules and not by drawing a comparison between the two classes of exporters. The reliance upon R.K. Garg v. Union of India (supra), therefore, does not alter the position.

32. In view of the above, we are of the considered opinion that paragraph 4.6 of Circular No. 197/09/2023-GST dated 17.07.2023, insofar as it provides that no refund of interest paid under Rule 96A(1) shall be admissible even where the tax deposited under the said Rule is subsequently refunded, cannot be sustained. Neither Rule 96A nor the provisions of the Act provide for retention of such interest in these circumstances, whereas Section 54(1) expressly contemplates a claim for refund of tax and interest paid thereon. A circular cannot impose a restriction which does not find place in the Act or the Rules. To that extent, paragraph 4.6 of the Circular must yield to the statutory provisions.

Conclusion

33. For the reasons recorded above, the petition is allowed, without any order as to costs, in following terms:

(a) Paragraph 4.6 of Circular No. 197/09/2023-GST, dated 17.07.2023 is declared bad in law and is hereby quashed, to the extent that it provides that no refund of interest paid in compliance of Sub-Rule (1) of Rule 96A of the Rules shall be admissible where the tax paid along with such interest has subsequently been refunded upon realization of the export proceeds.

(b) The order dated 28.02.2023 passed by the Additional Commissioner (Appeals), CGST, Gurugram is hereby set aside to the extent that it rejects the petitioner’s claim for refund of interest paid under Rule 96(C) of the Rules. The respondents are accordingly directed to refund to the petitioner interest paid under Rule 96(A), corresponding to the tax already refunded vide Order in Original No.ZR0604220172351 dated 13.04.2022 and, No. ZT0604220158439 dated 12.04.2022, within a period of eight weeks from the date of receipt of the certified copy of this order.

(c) In the event that the refund is not made within the aforesaid period, the amount payable shall carry interest under Section 56 of the Act, calculated from the date of expiry of the said period until the date of actual payment. Pending application(s), if any, shall stands disposed of.

Advertisement

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.