DCIT Vs Bright Buildtech Pvt. Ltd. (ITAT Mumbai)
No Bogus Loan: ITAT Confirms Creditworthiness of lenders & Rejects Revenue’s Doubts- Shell-Company Allegation Fails: SFIO Clean Report Helps Assessee Win Before ITAT Delhi
A search was conducted in the ACE & Rudra Group on 04.01.2022. Assessee filed ROI declaring loss of ₹15.43 crore. AO noted unsecured loans received from M/s Hallow Securities Pvt Ltd & M/s Dhankalash Distributors Pvt Ltd. AO treated ₹9.60 crore from Hallow Securities & ₹25 lakh from Dhankalash as unexplained, invoking s.68 r.w.s.115BBE, & also disallowed interest of ₹28,07,855/-.
Assessee produced confirmations, ITRs, audited financials & bank statements of lenders. CIT(A) made independent enquiries u/s 250(4), including a direct query to SFIO. SFIO in its written reply clarified that no investigation was pending against Hallow Securities, thereby negating the “shell company” allegation. CIT(A) also examined complete fund-flow, established availability of sufficient funds, & noted that loans were routed through regular banking channels & had been fully repaid in subsequent years.
Tribunal observed that the very same issue—loan from Hallow Securities—was already adjudicated in Allure Developers Pvt Ltd (ITA 3559/Del/2025) where identical facts existed. Tribunal held that the loan was genuine & additions u/s 68 were unsustainable. Applying those findings mutatis mutandis, Tribunal deleted the ₹9.60 crore addition. On the ₹25 lakh loan from Dhankalash Distributors, Tribunal upheld CIT(A)’s finding that the lender had strong creditworthiness, including share capital & reserves above ₹66 crores & significant financial capacity. Revenue could not rebut any factual finding. Once the loan was held genuine, the interest expenditure was also allowed. The appeal of Revenue was dismissed in full.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.


