DCIT Vs Jayant Shamji Chheda (ITAT Mumbai)
Summary: ITAT Mumbai dismissed the Revenue’s appeals for Assessment Years 2014-15 and 2016-17, upholding the CIT(A)’s deletion of substantial additions relating to unsecured loans and a Section 14A disallowance. For AY 2014-15, the Assessing Officer had treated unsecured loans of Rs.16.67 crore as unexplained under Section 68 and had also questioned Rs.9.50 crore repaid to Shri Pankaj D. Goshar as an alleged accommodation entry. The Tribunal noted that additional evidence furnished before the CIT(A) had been remanded to the Assessing Officer, but no effective independent verification or cross-checking of the creditors was undertaken. The CIT(A), after examining confirmations, bank statements, income-tax records and other documents, found the identity and creditworthiness of the lenders and genuineness of the transactions established. The Tribunal found no valid reason to interfere. It also sustained deletion of the additions concerning Shri Pankaj D. Goshar after considering the evidence and the CIT(A)’s findings on the alleged penny-stock LTCG and uncorroborated WhatsApp material. For AY 2016-17, the Tribunal similarly upheld deletion of a Rs.2 crore Section 68 addition concerning two lenders, noting the documentary evidence and repayment through banking channels. On Section 14A read with Rule 8D, the Tribunal upheld the CIT(A)’s finding that recording dissatisfaction having regard to the assessee’s accounts was mandatory before invoking Rule 8D. Consequently, both Revenue appeals were dismissed.
Cases Discussed
- PCIT (Central)-1 Vs NRA Iron & Steel (P.) Ltd., (2019) 103 taxmann.com 48 (SC) — Relied upon by the Revenue on the assessee’s burden to establish identity, creditworthiness and genuineness under Section 68; the Tribunal held the Revenue’s reliance did not dislodge the creditor-wise evidence accepted by the CIT(A).
- CIT Vs United Commercial & Industrial Co. (P.) Ltd., (1991) 56 Taxman 304 (Calcutta High Court) — Relied upon by the Revenue on the statutory burden under Section 68 and the insufficiency of banking channels alone where genuineness remains unproved.
- S. Hastimal Vs CIT, (1963) 49 ITR 273 (Madras High Court) — Cited by the assessee in support of the Section 68 challenge.
- CIT Vs Orissa Corporation (P.) Ltd. (Supreme Court) — Cited by the assessee on discharge of the initial evidentiary burden relating to cash credits.
- CIT Vs Vrindavan Farms (P.) Ltd., ITA Nos. 71-72 & 84 of 2015, dated 12.08.2015 — Cited by the assessee in support of deletion of the unsecured-loan addition.
- DCIT Vs Rohini Builders, (2003) 127 Taxman 523 (Gujarat High Court) — Relied upon in the reproduced appellate reasoning concerning documentary proof and loan transactions.
- PCIT Vs Ojas Tarmake (P.) Ltd., (2023) 156 taxmann.com 75 (Gujarat High Court) — Relied upon on repayment of loans through banking channels together with supporting evidence while considering Section 68.
- CIT Vs Ayachi Chandrashekhar Narsangji, (2014) 42 taxmann.com 251 (Gujarat High Court) — Relied upon on the relevance of accepted subsequent repayment of the loan.
- PCIT Vs Bairagra Builders (P.) Ltd., (2024) 164 taxmann.com 162 (Bombay High Court) — Cited by the assessee in support of its Section 68 case.
- PCIT Vs Skylark Build, ITA No.616 of 2016, order dated 24.10.2018 (Bombay High Court) — Relied upon in the CIT(A)’s reasoning concerning repayment and genuineness of creditors.
- PCIT Vs Wel Intertrade (P.) Ltd., (2023) 152 taxmann.com 663 (Delhi High Court) — Cited by the assessee in support of deletion under Section 68.
- CIT Vs Lavanya Land (P.) Ltd., (2017) 83 taxmann.com 161 (Bombay High Court) — Cited by the assessee in support of its Section 68 case.
- Nemi Chand Kothari Vs CIT, (2004) 139 Taxman 213 (Gauhati High Court) — Cited by the assessee concerning the evidentiary burden under Section 68.
- M/s NH Securities Ltd. Vs DCIT, ITA No.1079/Mum/2018, dated 24.03.2021 (ITAT Mumbai) — Cited by the assessee in support of the loan-addition issue.
- ITO 41(3)(1) Vs Mr. Bhagwati Prasad N. Rungta, ITA No.1574/M/2024, order dated 22.01.2025 (ITAT Mumbai) — Reproduced by the CIT(A) on documentary evidence, repayment through banking channels and Section 68.
- CCIT(OSD)/PCIT Vs Bhupendra Champaklal Dalal, (2024) 160 taxmann.com 645 (Bombay High Court) — Referred to in the reproduced precedent concerning repayment of credit and deletion of Section 68 addition.
- CIT Vs P. Mohanakala, (2007) 291 ITR 278 (Supreme Court) — Discussed in the reproduced Bombay High Court reasoning on factual appreciation of cash-credit transactions.
- CIT Vs Mahaveer Crimpers, 95 taxmann.com 323 (Gujarat High Court) — Relied upon in the CIT(A)’s reasoning concerning source, creditworthiness, repayment and Section 68.
- Shyam R. Pawar (Bombay High Court) — Referred to through the earlier order concerning Shri Pankaj D. Goshar and the alleged bogus LTCG in Pine Animation Ltd.
- Ziauddin A. Siddique (Bombay High Court) — Referred to through the earlier order concerning Shri Pankaj D. Goshar and the alleged bogus LTCG.
- Principal Commissioner of Income Tax Vs Bombay Stock Exchange Ltd., 113 taxmann.com 303 (Bombay High Court) — Followed on the requirement of recording dissatisfaction having regard to the assessee’s accounts before invoking Rule 8D.
- Maxopp Investment Ltd. Vs CIT, (2018) 402 ITR 640 (Supreme Court) — Considered through Bombay Stock Exchange Ltd. on the statutory precondition for application of Rule 8D.
FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ITAT MUMBAI
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.



