Cargo Motors Pvt. Ltd. Vs DCIT (Delhi High Court)
Summary: Delhi High Court held that for computing disallowance under Section 14A read with Rule 8D, only those investments which actually yielded exempt income during the relevant assessment year could be considered. Cargo Motors Pvt. Ltd. had earned dividend income of Rs.12,92,735 from Tata Motors Ltd., Tata Consultancy Services Limited and Mundra Port. Its investment in these three companies was Rs.2,59,11,939, whereas its total investments were Rs.24,22,14,939. The Assessing Officer nevertheless applied 0.5% to total average investments and, after reducing Rs.1,29,274 already disallowed by the assessee, made a further disallowance of Rs.6,05,176. The CIT(A) and ITAT upheld the adjustment. The High Court held that Section 14A is the charging provision while Rule 8D merely provides the method or mechanism for determining expenditure incurred in relation to income not forming part of total income. Consequently, Rule 8D cannot enlarge the scope of Section 14A. Following ACB India Ltd., Caraf Builders & Constructions Pvt. Ltd. and decisions of the Madras and Calcutta High Courts, the Court held that only investments yielding exempt income could enter the relevant investment base. It also rejected the Revenue’s reliance on CBDT Circular No.5/2014,, following PCIT Vs IL & FS Energy Development Company Ltd., holding that the Circular cannot override the express provisions of Section 14A read with Rule 8D. The substantial question of law was accordingly answered in favour of the assessee.
Cases Discussed
- ACB India Limited (formerly M/s Aryan Coal Benefications (P) Ltd.) Vs Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, ITA No. 615/2014, 374 ITR 108 (Delhi High Court), decided on 24.03.2015 — Followed for holding that the Assessing Officer cannot factor the entire investment portfolio into the Rule 8D computation where the statutory formula concerns investments relating to exempt income.
- Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax-2 Vs M/s Caraf Builders & Constructions Pvt. Ltd., 414 ITR 122 (Delhi High Court) — Followed on the Rule 8D investment base; the Court reproduced the finding that total investments could not be substituted for investments which yielded exempt income.
- The Commissioner of Income Tax, Chennai Vs Shriram Ownership Trust, 318 CTR 233 (Madras High Court) — Followed for holding that investments yielding no exempt income were to be excluded while computing the Section 14A disallowance.
- M/s Marg Limited Vs CIT, Chennai, T.C.A. Nos.41 to 43 and 220 of 2017, decided on 30.09.2020 (Madras High Court) — Referred to in Shriram Ownership Trust as deciding the question concerning investments yielding no exempt income in favour of the assessee.
- Pragathi Krishna Gramin Bank Vs JCIT, (2018) 95 taxmann.com 41 (Karnataka High Court) — Referred to as the Karnataka High Court authority followed in Marg Limited.
- ACIT, Circle 17(1), New Delhi Vs Vireet Investment (P) Ltd., (2017) 82 taxmann.com 415 (ITAT Delhi-Special Bench) — Referred to for the proposition that the Rule 8D computation should be confined to investments yielding exempt income.
- Commissioner of Income-tax, Central-1, Chennai Vs Chettinad Logistics (P) Ltd., (2017) 80 taxmann.com 221 (Madras High Court) — Followed for holding that Rule 8D only provides a method of determining expenditure relating to exempt income and cannot go beyond Section 14A.
- Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Central-1, Kolkata Vs M/s Shalimar Pellet Feeds Ltd., 2022 (2) TMI 1209 (Calcutta High Court) — Followed for holding that Rule 8D could be applied only with reference to shares which yielded dividend income during the year under consideration.
- REI Agro Ltd. Vs DCIT, (2013) 35 taxmann.com 404 — Referred to in Shalimar Pellet Feeds Ltd. on the Rule 8D investment-base issue.
- Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax-04 Vs IL & FS Energy Development Company Ltd., ITA No.520/2017, [2017] 84 taxmann.com 186 (Delhi High Court), decided on 16.08.2017 — Followed for holding that CBDT Circular No.5/2014 cannot override the express provisions of Section 14A read with Rule 8D and that the statutory scheme concerns actual exempt income of the relevant year.
- Commissioner of Income Tax Vs Walfort Share and Stock Brokers Pvt. Ltd., [2010] 326 ITR 1 (Supreme Court) — Referred to while explaining the statutory mandate and object of Section 14A concerning expenditure incurred in relation to exempt income.
- Cheminvest Ltd. Vs Commissioner of Income Tax-VI, (2015) 378 ITR 33 (Delhi High Court) — Referred to in the extracted reasoning from IL & FS Energy Development Company Ltd.; the Court held that CBDT Circular No.5/2014 did not warrant reconsideration of Cheminvest.
- M/s Redington (India) Ltd. Vs Additional Commissioner of Income Tax, Company Range-V, Chennai, TCA No.520 of 2016, decided on 23.12.2016 (Madras High Court) — Referred to for holding that Section 14A is relatable to actual income rather than notional or anticipated income and for rejecting the Revenue’s reliance on the CBDT Circular.
FULL TEXT OF THE JUDGMENT/ORDER OF DELHI HIGH COURT
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.


