Khazan Singh Anand Vs ITO (ITAT Delhi)
Summary: The Delhi Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, comprising Judicial Member Shri Amit Shukla and Accountant Member Shri Prashant Maharishi, partly allowed the appeal of Khazan Singh Anand Vs ITO for Assessment Year 2016-17 and directed deletion of an addition of ₹22,10,000 made under Section 50C of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The central question was whether the stamp duty valuation of a plot could be substituted for the actual consideration when the assessee had transferred only leasehold rights in the property. The Tribunal held that Section 50C, as interpreted in the precedents relied upon, did not apply to the transfer of leasehold rights in land.
The assessee, an individual, filed his return on 4 July 2016 declaring income of ₹5,67,120. His case was selected for limited scrutiny because the sale consideration disclosed in the income-tax return was lower than the valuation adopted by the stamp duty authority. The assessee had received leasehold rights in Plot No. 25, Pocket A3, Sector 28, Rohini, New Delhi, from the Delhi Development Authority under an allotment letter dated 27 November 2014. The plot cost ₹13,95,120, and the assessee obtained possession on 3 May 2015.
On 26 October 2015, the assessee transferred the leasehold rights to Smt. Deepika Kapoor for ₹20,00,000 under a registered agreement to sell. However, the applicable circle rate or stamp duty valuation of the plot was ₹42,10,000. The assessee computed short-term capital gains by adopting the actual consideration of ₹20,00,000 and supported the transaction value with a valuation certificate issued by a registered valuer. The short-term capital gain declared by the assessee was ₹5,54,880.
The Assessing Officer considered Section 50C applicable and issued a show-cause notice. The assessee replied that the market value of the property was substantially lower than the circle rate and relied on the registered valuer’s certificate. Rejecting this explanation, the Assessing Officer substituted the stamp duty value of ₹42,10,000 for the actual consideration of ₹20,00,000. Consequently, short-term capital gains were recomputed at ₹27,64,880, resulting in an addition of ₹22,10,000. The assessment was completed under Section 143(3), determining total income at ₹27,77,120 against returned income of ₹5,67,120.
The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)-14, New Delhi, upheld the addition by order dated 22 May 2019. Before the Tribunal, the assessee challenged the applicability of Section 50C to leasehold rights. The assessee argued that the provision specifically referred to transfer of a capital asset being land or building or both, whereas leasehold rights constituted a different asset. It was submitted that the assessee had never acquired absolute ownership of the land and had merely transferred the rights allotted by the DDA.
In support of this contention, the assessee relied on Noida Cyber Park Pvt. Ltd. Vs ITO, ITA No. 165/Del/2020, decided on 12 October 2020. The Tribunal also examined the Bombay High Court decision in CIT Vs Greenfield Hotels and Estates Pvt. Ltd., reported at 389 ITR 68, which had upheld the Tribunal’s position that Section 50C was inapplicable to capital gains arising from transfer of leasehold rights. It further referred to Ritz Suppliers Pvt. Ltd. Vs ITO, Pyaribai K. Jain Vs CIT and Kencast Pvt. Ltd. Vs ITO.
The Tribunal observed that the DDA had allotted only leasehold rights to the assessee and that the subsequent transaction with the purchaser concerned those rights. Following the Bombay High Court decision and the coordinate Bench precedents, it accepted the assessee’s contention that Section 50C could not be invoked for the transaction. The Tribunal accordingly allowed Ground No. 2 and directed the Assessing Officer to delete the addition of ₹22,10,000.
Ground No. 1, being general in nature, was dismissed. The remaining grounds concerning the stamp duty valuation, valuation officer reference and computation of short-term capital gains were not separately adjudicated because the assessee had succeeded on the principal legal issue. The appeal was therefore partly allowed. The decision illustrates the distinction drawn in the cited authorities between ownership of land or buildings and leasehold rights for the purposes of Section 50C, although the applicability of that reasoning to other transactions requires consideration of the relevant facts and subsequent judicial developments.
Cases Discussed
- Noida Cyber Park Pvt. Ltd. Vs ITO, Ward 18(4), New Delhi – ITA No. 165/Del/2020, AY 2015-16, dated 12/10/2020 (ITAT Delhi). Relied upon by the assessee for the proposition that Section 50C does not apply to the transfer of leasehold rights in land or building.
- Ritz Suppliers Pvt. Ltd. Vs ITO – 182 ITD 227; 2020-TIOL-307-ITAT-KOL (ITAT Kolkata). Relied upon by the Tribunal in holding that the transfer of leasehold rights falls outside the scope of Section 50C.
- Pyaribai K. Jain Vs CIT – 175 ITD 177 (ITAT Mumbai). Cited by the Tribunal as a supporting precedent for excluding leasehold rights from the applicability of Section 50C.
- CIT Vs Greenfield Hotels and Estates Pvt. Ltd. – (2017) 389 ITR 68; [2017] 77 taxmann.com 308, Income Tax Appeal No. 735 of 2014, AY 2007-08, dated 24/10/2016 (Bombay High Court). The principal High Court precedent relied upon by the Tribunal concerning the non-applicability of Section 50C to the transfer of leasehold rights.
- Kancast Pvt. Ltd. Vs ITO – [2015] 55 taxmann.com 171; 68 SOT 110 (ITAT Pune). Relied upon as a coordinate Bench precedent distinguishing leasehold rights from land or building for the purposes of Section 50C.
FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ITAT DELHI
1. This appeal is filed by the assessee against the order of the ld CIT(A)-14, New Delhi dated 22.05.2019 for the Assessment Year 2016-17, wherein, the appeal filed by the assessee against the order passed u/s 143(3) of the Act, where total income of the assessee was assessed at Rs. 27,77,120/- against the return filed at Rs. 5,67,120/- passed u/s 143(3) of the Act by the ITO, Ward-40(5), Delhi was dismissed.
2. The assessee has raised the following grounds of appeal:-
“1. That on the facts and circumstances of the case, the order datedaslS,12.2016 passed by the Income-tax Officer, Ward 40(5), New Delhi [hereinafter referred to as “the Ld. A.O.”] under section 14313) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 [hereinafter referred to as “the Act”] and as upheld by the Ld. Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) – 14, New Delhi [hereinafter referred to as “the CIT(A)”] is bad at law and mid ab initio.
2. That on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the CIT(A) erred in upholding the Applicability of section SOC of the Act cm transfer of lease hold land.
3. That, without prejudice to the ground no 2 :
That, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and its law, the CIT(A) erred in upholding Rs 42,10,000 as full value of consideration being the value adopted by stamp valuation authority, even when the Ld, AO had not referred this matter to Valuation Officer and or not followed the mandatory procedure law down U/S 50C(2 ) of the Act. where Appellant had disputed the value so adopted and submitted that value adopted by the stamp duty authority is higher than the fair market value.
4. That on the facts and in circumstances of the case, the Ld. CIT(A) erred Rs. 6,38,302/- in upholding the addition to the tune of Rs, 22,10,000/- in short term capital gain as per provision of section 50 C of the Act
5.1 All the above-mentioned grounds are independent and without prejudice General ground to other.”
3. Brief facts of the case shows that the assessee is an individual. He filed his return of income on 04.07.2016 declaring income of Rs. 567120/-. The case of the assessee was selected for limited scrutiny for the reason that sale consideration of property shown in income tax return is less than the value as per stamp authority. Therefore, notice u/s 143(3) was issued on 14.07.2017.
4. During the year it was found that the assessee was allotted leasehold right of plot NO. 25, Pocket A3 in Sector 28, Rohini , New Delhi on 27.11.2014 by Delhi Development Authority. The total cost of the plot was Rs. 1395120/- which was sold on 26.10.2015 for Rs. 20 lakhs. The circle rate of plot as per stamp duty rate was Rs. 42,10,000/-. However, the assessee opted for showing the capital gain on the same by adopting the sale consideration as per sale deed of Rs. 20 lakhs and supported it by a market value certification from registered valuer. The assessee declared the resultant capital gain as short term capital gain of Rs. 554880/-.
5. The ld AO noted that provisions of section 50C applies and therefore, show cause notice was issued on 02.12.2018. The assessee submitted which is reply on 05.12.2018 stating that market value of the above property is very low as compared to circle rate. The assessee supported it by the valuation certificate.
6. The ld AO rejected the contention of the assessee and substituted the sale consideration of Rs. 20 lakhs by the stamp duty valuation u/s 50C of the property of Rs. 4210000/-. Accordingly, short term capital gain was worked out at Rs. 2764880/- against the short term capital gain assessed by the assessee at Rs. 554880/-. Consequently, addition of Rs. 2210000/- was made. The assessment order was passed u/s 143(3) of the Act on 15.12.2018 determining the total income of the assessee at Rs. 2777120/- against the return income of Rs. 567120/-.
7. Aggrieved by the order of the ld AO the assessee preferred appeal before the ld CIT(A) who confirmed the addition and therefore, the assessee is in appeal before us.
8. The rival parties are heard, paper book produced by the ld representative was perused. On careful consideration of the whole issue it is apparent that ground No. 1 is general in nature and hence, same is dismissed.
9. Ground No. 2 and 3 of the appeal are on the merits of the addition. The fact shows that DDA allotted to the appellant the leasehold right of a plot of land at Plot No. 25 Pocket No. 3A, Sector 28, Rohini, New Delhi as per allotment letter dated 27.11.2014. The assessee took the possession of the above plot on 03.05.2015. Above leasehold right were transferred by the assessee as per registered agreement to sale to one Smt. Deepika Kapoor. The claim of the assessee is that provisions of section 50C applies only to the transfer of land and Building or both but it does not extend to the transfer of leasehold right. According to the assessee leasehold rights are neither land or building or both. For this proposition the assessee relied upon the decision of the coordinate bench in case of Noida Cyber Park Pvt. Ltd ITA No. 165/Del/2020 dated 12.10.2020. However, on careful perusal of the fact it is apparent that the issue is squarely covered in favour of the assessee by the decision of the Hon’ble Bombay High Court in 389 ITR 68 CIT Vs. Greenfield Hotels and Estates Pvt. Ltd wherein, the Hon’ble High Court has upheld the order of the coordinate bench holding that provisions of section 50C will not be applicable while computing the capital gain on transfer of leasehold rights in land and plot. The issue is also covered in favour of the assessee by the decision of the coordinate bench in case of Ritz Suppliers Pvt. Ltd Vs. ITO 182 ITD 227 (Kol), Pyaribai K Jain Vs. CIT 175 ITD 177 (Mum), Kencast Pvt. Ltd Vs. ITO 68 SOT 110(Pune). In view of the above binding precedents we allow ground No. 2 of the appeal which challenges that provision of section 50C of the Act do not apply on transfer of leasehold right in plot of land and direct the ld AO to delet the addition of Rs 2210,000/- made u/s 50C of the act . Accordingly, ground No. 2 of the appeal is allowed.
10. Ground no. 3 and 4 are on the merit of the issue which are not required to be adjudicated in view of the finding in ground No. 2 of the appealwherein ld AO s directed to delete the addition of Rs. 2210000/- made u/s 50C of the Act as short term capital gain.
11. Accordingly, appeal of the assessee is partly allowed.
Order pronounced in the open court on 02/12/2020.


