Rakesh Kumar Khare Vs ITO (ITAT Jabalpur)
Books Rejected, but Profit Cannot Be Picked at Will: ITAT Orders Five-Year Average Instead of Ad Hoc 8%
Rejection of Books Does Not Justify an Arbitrary Rate
The Jabalpur Tribunal upheld rejection of the assessee’s books because essential stock and trading records were not produced. However, it rejected both the 14.72% profit rate adopted by the Assessing Officer and the 8% rate sustained by the CIT(A) for want of a reasoned basis.
The Tribunal directed a fresh computation using the simple average of the assessee’s net-profit percentages for the immediately preceding five assessment years.
It also restored a separate ₹32,50,800 addition relating to an unexplained change in opening creditors for verification. The assessee therefore obtained reconsideration of both additions, while the rejection of books remained intact.
Missing Records Lead to Rejection of Accounts
The assessee, engaged in liquor trading and property development, filed his return on 5 September 2017, declaring income of ₹13,40,980.
His case was selected for complete scrutiny under CASS. The relevant business turnover was ₹7,21,37,618, against which the assessee declared a net-profit rate of 1.93%.
To verify the trading results, the Assessing Officer sought shop-wise stock or inventory registers, sales and purchase records, and expense ledgers.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.





