Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Income Tax

Documentary Trail Wins- Suspicion Cannot Replace Evidence: Penny-Stock Addition Deleted

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2025 taxguru.in 12398
Case Name
Hareshkumar Mafatlal Shah Vs ACIT (ITAT Mumbai)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Related Assessment Year
2014-15
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Hareshkumar Mafatlal Shah Vs ACIT (ITAT Mumbai)

Assessee had declared LTCG of ₹2,41,53,979 from sale of shares of Sunrise Asian Ltd (SAL) & Monarch Health Services Ltd (MHSL), acquired through proper banking channels, held in Demat, & sold on BSE with STT paid. AO treated entire gain as bogus penny-stock accommodation entry based on general investigation statements of one Vipul Bhatt & denied cross-examination. AO added LTCG u/s 68 & alleged commission of ₹9,66,159 u/s 69C. NFAC upheld additions.

Before Tribunal, Assessee relied on multiple binding precedents:

  • Gujarat HC – Divyaben Prafulchandra Parmar,
  • MP HC (Indore) – Nilesh Jain (HUF), holding SAL transactions genuine,
  • ITAT Mumbai – Lalitaben Praful Shah, relying on Bombay HC – Jamnadevi Agarwal,
  • Bombay HC – Shyam R Pawar, emphasising that once documentary evidence such as contract notes, Demat proofs & bank entries are produced, Revenue must bring positive corroboration of sham nature.

Tribunal noted that AO produced no evidence linking Assessee with any operator, nor any irregularity in scrips SAL & MHSL. SEBI’s final orders also did not name Assessee. Udit Kalra (Delhi HC), relied upon by NFAC, was found factually distinct since that case involved “Kappac Pharma” with proven manipulation & delisting.

Once genuine documentary trail exists—purchase invoice, payment by cheque, Demat credit, sale through exchange with STT—the burden shifts to AO. As AO didn’t discharge this burden, additions u/s 68 & 69C were held unjustified. Tribunal followed Shyam R Pawar (Bom HC), holding that suspicion cannot override documented evidence.

Want to Read the Complete Judgment?

You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.

Read on with Premium
Goes straight to payment. GST invoice included.

One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Vijayakumar Shetty
Qualification: CA in Practice
Company: Shetty & Co, Chartered Accountants, Mangalore
Location: Mangalore, Karnataka
Articles Published: 7,718

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.