PCIT Vs AMD India Private Limited (Karnataka High Court)
Summary: The Karnataka High Court, in PCIT Vs AMD India Private Limited, ITA Nos. 97 and 96 of 2026, decided on 24 September 2026 (2026:KHC:52885-DB), dismissed two appeals filed by the Revenue under Section 260A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, concerning Assessment Year 2013-14. The dispute involved transfer pricing adjustments, selection of comparable companies, computation of the Profit Level Indicator (PLI), treatment of provisions for bad and doubtful debts, and taxation of equipment supplied free of cost by an Associated Enterprise (AE) under Section 28(iv) of the Income-tax Act. The assessee, formerly known as AMD Research and Development Centre India Private Limited, had declared income of ₹21,34,01,430. Following scrutiny of its international transactions, the Transfer Pricing Officer proposed adjustments aggregating to ₹19,63,80,045 relating to software development services and receivables. Separately, the Assessing Officer made an addition of ₹7,73,50,917 under Section 28(iv), treating the value of machinery and testing equipment supplied free of charge by the AE as a taxable business benefit. The CIT(A) restricted this addition to 12% of the equipment’s value, while the Tribunal subsequently deleted the remaining addition. On the transfer pricing issues, the High Court upheld the exclusion of Persistent Systems Limited, Larsen & Toubro Infotech Limited and Mindtree Limited from the comparable set because their turnover exceeded ₹200 crore. Although the Income-tax Act and Rules do not prescribe a specific upper turnover threshold, the Court observed that company size is a relevant factor when evaluating comparability under the Transactional Net Margin Method (TNMM), alongside the functions performed, assets employed and risks assumed. Following SAP Labs India Private Limited Vs ITO, ITA No. 10 of 2011 and connected matters, decided on 28 August 2026 (Karnataka High Court), it found no infirmity in applying the ₹200 crore upper turnover filter. Regarding computation of the PLI, the assessee demonstrated that depreciation represented approximately 5.72% of its software development segment costs, compared with an average of 4.05% for the selected comparables. These differences arose from variations in asset composition, technology and investment levels. The Tribunal accepted the use of cash PLI by excluding depreciation to achieve a more reliable comparison of operating margins. The High Court upheld this approach, relying on PCIT Vs Novell Software Development India (P.) Ltd., (2021) 126 taxmann.com 29 (Karnataka High Court), and held that no substantial question of law arose. The Court also rejected the Revenue’s objection to including provisions for bad and doubtful debts in operating expenditure while computing transfer pricing margins. It observed that the applicable Rules did not mandate exclusion of such provisions and that exclusion could be justified where the expenditure represented an extraordinary item. Since no evidence established that the provision was extraordinary in the assessee’s case, its treatment as a normal business expense connected with sales was upheld. The Court also referred to Principal CIT Vs Business Process Outsourcing India Private Limited, (2018) taxcorp (DT) 73195 (Karnataka High Court), where similar treatment had been sustained. The principal substantive issue concerned the free supply of testing equipment by the AE. The assessee explained that the equipment was supplied exclusively for testing software developed for the AE, that ownership and title remained with the AE, and that the equipment was neither capitalised in the assessee’s financial statements nor subjected to any depreciation claim. Upon completion of testing, the equipment was required to be re-exported or disposed of as scrap depending on its useful life. The High Court held that the mere availability of AE-owned equipment for performing contractual services did not establish a taxable business benefit or perquisite under Section 28(iv) in the circumstances presented. Following PCIT Vs Sony India Software Centre (P.) Ltd., (2025) 177 taxmann.com 206 (Karnataka High Court), the Court upheld deletion of the addition, including the 12% amount earlier sustained by the CIT(A). Concluding that none of the issues raised by the Revenue gave rise to a substantial question of law, the Karnataka High Court dismissed both appeals. The judgment emphasises the importance of actual ownership and economic benefit when applying Section 28(iv), as well as functional comparability, depreciation differences and the ordinary business character of expenditure in transfer pricing analysis.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.





