Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Goods and Services Tax

Exercising writ jurisdiction inconsistent with legislative intent would render legislative scheme and intention otiose

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2020 taxguru.in 706
Case Name
Assistant Commissioner (CT) LTU Vs Glaxo Smith Kline Consumer Health Care Limited (Supreme Court)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Assistant Commissioner (CT) LTU Vs Glaxo Smith Kline Consumer Health Care Limited (Supreme Court)

In Challenge : – Judgment of the High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad for the State of Telangana and State of Andhra Pradesh.

Constitution of India – Art-226 – Writ Jurisdiction bypassing the statutory provisions – remedy against the assessment order stood foreclosed by Limitation Law – Section 31 AP VAT Act 2005 – appeal against order of assessing authority – statutory provisions – 30 days – further 30 days on furnishing valid reasons for delay beyond first 30 days – but no provisions to condone delay as per statute post 60 days.

AP VAT Rules – Rule 60 – Application dismissed — appealed against — dismissed by the appellate authority citing order of the assessing authority.

Manifest error – Assessee furnished wrong turnover in CST annual return – Form “F” furnished not sufficient as per TTO (CST) – appeal time barred – exercise of Writ Jurisdiction when statutory remedy available – not valid

Facts : Assessee a registered dealer is engaged in the business of Horlicks, Boost, Biscuits,  Ghee, Ayurvedic Medicines etc.. Assessment year 2013-14, CST Returns – Form “F” produced w.r.t. interstate transfers were verified. Final Assessment order passed on 21.6.2017 by the Asst. commissioner raising further demand of Rs.76,73,197/­- under CST against turnover of Rs.3,44,15,240/­-, on finding that Assessee failed to submit Form “F” against turnover reported in CST Returns and was served upon the assessee on next day. No appeal was filed within the statutory period(30+30) days as prescribed under section 31 of the AP VAT Act 2005, however amount equivalent to 12.5% of demand was deposited as mandatory to file appeal.

Application under Rule 60 of the AP Value Added Tax Rules was filed on 8.5.2018, highlighting the error made in raising the said demand on basis of incorrect turnover reported by Assessee, subsequently demand for afresh orders but rejected on 11.5.2018. Therefore assessee filed appeal against order dated 11.5.2018, that was also rejected on 17.8.2018 citing reasons under the assessment order.

Assessee filed first appeal on 24.9.2018 before the first appellate authority against the order dated 21.6.2017 i.e. after a gap of more than 1 year and was dismissed on 25.10.2018 being time barred.

Assessee rather availing statutory remedy of 2nd appeal, filed Writ Petition u/A 226 for quashing of assessment order dated 21.6.2017 being violative of the principle of natural justice, contrary to law and without jurisdiction and sought exemption on basis of Form “F”.

8.11.2018 – Hon’ble High Court allowed the same and noted that :-

a) the Assessee / Respondent had already paid 12.5% of the demand for filling appeal;

b) employee incharge of tax matters, defaulted and therefore suspended;

c) Division bench posted the matter to 19.11.2018 and directed assessee to pay further 12.5 % of disputed amount.

d) Div Bench allowed the writ and quashed asst order dated 21.6.2017 and directed assessing authority to provide fresh opportunity to the assessee/Respondent herein.

Held – Judgment of the High Court was set aside since Writ Petition filed, when assessee could well avail alternative remedy prescribed in the statute. Question of law no longer Res integra.

Held –Exercising jurisdiction inconsistent with legislative intent would render the legislative scheme and intention behind the stated provision ‘otiose’.

Assessee / Respondent further tried luck in light of decision of three judges bench in ITC Ltd. & Anr. v UOI (1998) 8 SCC 610 – wherein the court permitted to resort to remedy of statutory appeal and directed the appellate authority to decide the appeal on merits, after having case travelled to Supreme Court, however of no avail. Court observed in ITC (supra) counsel had no objection for deciding the case afresh.

Observation : Benefit of direction to assessing authority for afresh order could be extended given the natural justice principle and in light of ITC v UOI judgment as referred to by the assessee / Respondent and in light to following judgments :-

N. Balakrishnan v M. Krishnamurthy (1998) 7 SCC 123

Purpose of limitation act is not to destroy rights but is found to fix the life span of the legal remedy for the general welfare. What is primary function of the court is to adjudicate between the parties and to advance substantial justice.

MP Steel Corp v CCE (2015) 7 SCC 58

Principle that courts always lean in favor of advancing the cause of justice where a clear case is made out for so doing, since justice and reason is at the heart of all legislations.

B.T. Purushothama Rai v KG Uthaya (2011) 14 SCC 86

If the explanantion given does not smack of mala fide or is not shown to have been put forth as a part of a dilatory strategy, the court must show utmost consideration to the suitor.

Moreover in tax matters, there are technical interpretations involved and in the era of high competition and daily advancement of taxing statues and its principles there is need to adopt a bonafide lighter approach towards those who are a recourse to economy and pay heavy taxes and that will also help amplify their confidence in Indian legal system especially at a time when there are heavy requirements of much foreign trade and foreign investors to enter into Indian market.

FULL TEXT OF THE SUPREME COURT JUDGMENT

Want to Read the Complete Judgment?

You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.

Read on with Premium
Goes straight to payment. GST invoice included.

One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.

Advertisement

Author Info

Piyush Hans
Name: Piyush Hans
Qualification: LL.B / Advocate
Company: Piyush Hans & Associates
Location: Delhi NCR, Delhi
Articles Published: 2

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.