Agarwal Metals & Alloys Vs C.C.-Kandla (CESTAT Ahmedabad)
Summary: CESTAT Ahmedabad allowed the appeals of Agarwal Metals & Alloys (AMA), its partners Vipul Agarwal and Samir Agarwal and Ramesh Kumar H. Jain, setting aside customs duty demands, confiscation and penalties arising from alleged undervaluation of imported aluminium scrap. AMA imported various grades of aluminium scrap from Europe, the Middle East and USA through Nhava Sheva, Kandla and ICD Tughlakabad. DRI alleged that the imports were grossly undervalued and that differential consideration was remitted to overseas suppliers in cash. The Department principally relied upon DGOV Alert Circular No.14/2005 dated 16.12.2005, statements, three insurance policies, a report obtained through the Embassy of India at Brussels and third-party material. The assessable value was redetermined by applying discount bands to London Metal Exchange prices of virgin aluminium.
The Tribunal held that the case was squarely covered by its decision in Sunland Metal Recycling Industries because the allegations and evidence were substantially similar. It found that the adjudicating authority had redetermined the value on the basis of the DGOV circular while overlooking contemporaneous import data. Where contemporaneous values were available, those values constituted the proper basis for redetermination, and the statutory Customs Valuation Rules had to be applied sequentially. The prices declared by AMA were found comparable with, or higher than, contemporaneous imports considered in Sunland Metal and Pushpak Metal Corporation. The Tribunal reiterated that LME prices of virgin metal could not mechanically determine the value of aluminium scrap and that departmental guidelines could not override the Customs Valuation Rules.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.






