Shailendra Agarwal Vs Asit Upadhyaya & Ors. (NCLAT Delhi)
Summary: NCLAT Delhi dismissed the appeal of Shailendra Agarwal, suspended director of NHA Infrabuild Pvt. Ltd., and upheld initiation of CIRP on a Section 7 application filed by homebuyers of the Nikhil Park Royale project. The Tribunal rejected the contention that the application was barred by limitation despite the stated default dating back to 10 December 2015. It held that failure to hand over possession and continuing failure to refund the allottees constituted a continuing cause of action under Section 22 of the Limitation Act. Further, the Corporate Debtor had acknowledged amounts due to the allottees in its balance sheet as on 30 June 2022 without any caveat; such acknowledgment extended limitation under Section 18. The Supreme Court’s COVID-19 limitation-extension orders also supported the conclusion that the petition was within time. On the statutory threshold under the second proviso to Section 7(1) of the IBC, the project had 247 units while the respondents collectively held 34 allotted units, satisfying the requirement of 100 allottees or 10% of total allottees, whichever is lower. Crucially, NCLAT held that homebuyers do not cease to be financial creditors merely because they have obtained Recovery Certificates or decrees under RERA. Following Vishal Chelani v. Debashis Nanda and Rahul Gyanchandani v. Parsvnath Landmark Developers Pvt. Ltd., it held that such allottees remain financial creditors under Section 5(8)(f) and are counted for the Section 7 threshold where possession has not been delivered and deposits have not been fully refunded. The Tribunal also rejected the Section 65 plea of fraudulent or malicious initiation, holding that cogent evidence was required and mere allegations of forum shopping, disputed allotments or recovery certificates were insufficient. Conversion of the erstwhile firm into the Corporate Debtor did not extinguish its pre-existing liabilities under Sections 369 and 370 of the Companies Act, 2013. The appeal was consequently dismissed and CIRP was directed to continue.
Cases Discussed
- Sesh Nath Singh & Anr. Vs Baidyabati Sheoraphuli Co-operative Bank Ltd. & Anr., Civil Appeal No. 9198 of 2019 (Supreme Court) — Relied upon by the respondents on the proposition that limitation goes to maintainability and can be examined by the Court/Tribunal; NCLAT relied on the principle while rejecting the appellant’s objection concerning absence of specific pleadings on limitation.
- Mist Direct Sales Private Limited Vs Nitin Batra & Ors., Company Appeal (AT) (Insolvency) No. 127 of 2023 (NCLAT)— Relied upon by the respondents in support of their contention that failure to deliver possession constitutes a continuing breach for purposes of Section 22 of the Limitation Act.
- Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. Vs A. Balakrishnan & Anr., (2022) 9 SCC 186 (Supreme Court) — Relied upon regarding the effect of a recovery certificate and the fresh right/cause of action available to a financial creditor where the amount under the judgment, decree or recovery certificate remains unpaid.
- Shelendra Kumar Sharma Vs DSC Ltd., 2019 SCC OnLine NCLAT 1274 (NCLAT) — Relied upon by the respondents while contesting the Corporate Debtor’s allegations of forgery and the scope of adjudication under the IBC.
- Pioneer Urban Land and Infrastructure Ltd. Vs Union of India, (2019) 8 SCC 416 (Supreme Court) — Relied upon for the position that RERA and IBC remedies operate in their respective spheres and that IBC provides a collective insolvency-resolution mechanism for homebuyers.
- Monotrone Leasing Pvt. Ltd. Vs PM Cold Storage Private Ltd., 2020 SCC OnLine NCLAT 581 (NCLAT) — Relied upon for Section 65 IBC; fraudulent or malicious initiation must be supported by substantial documentary evidence and cannot rest on bare assertions.
- Asset Reconstruction Co. (India) Ltd. Vs Bishal Jaiswal & Anr., (2021) 6 SCC 366 (Supreme Court) — NCLAT considered the ruling that an entry in a balance sheet can constitute acknowledgment under Section 18 of the Limitation Act, subject to the facts, accompanying notes and caveats. NCLAT found no caveat attached to the acknowledgment of amounts due to the allottees in the present case.
- Bengal Silk Mills Co. Vs Ismail Golam Hossain Ariff, 1961 SCC OnLine Cal 128 : AIR 1962 Cal 115 (Calcutta High Court) — Discussed through the Supreme Court’s decision in Bishal Jaiswal regarding acknowledgment of liability in balance sheets.
- Bachhaj Nahar Vs Nilima Mandal & Anr., (2008) 17 SCC 491 (Supreme Court) — Relied upon by the appellant for the rule that courts should not decide a case outside the pleadings. NCLAT distinguished it because limitation had to be examined and the Section 7 petition and accompanying documents disclosed continuing default.
- Sushil Ansal Vs Ashok Tripathi & Ors., 2020 SCC OnLine NCLAT 680 (NCLAT) — Relied upon by the appellant to contend that RERA recovery-certificate/decree holders could not be treated as financial creditors. NCLAT held that the contention could not survive the subsequent Supreme Court ruling in Vishal Chelani.
- Vishal Chelani & Ors. Vs Debashis Nanda, (2023) 10 SCC 395 (Supreme Court) — Applied to hold that an allottee who obtains a decree/recovery relief under RERA does not cease to belong to the class of homebuyers/financial creditors.
- Rahul Gyanchandani & Ors. Vs Parsvnath Landmark Developers Pvt. Ltd., 2024 SCC OnLine NCLAT 469 (NCLAT) — Applied for the proposition that obtaining a recovery certificate does not alter an allottee’s underlying status and such homebuyers remain subject to the threshold requirement under the second proviso to Section 7(1).
- Babulal Vardharji Gurjar Vs Veer Gurjar Aluminium Industries Pvt. Ltd. & Anr., (2020) 15 SCC 1 (Supreme Court) — Relied upon by the appellant on limitation. NCLAT distinguished it because the present Section 7 petition pleaded continuing default and the record contained the balance-sheet acknowledgment dated 30.06.2022.
- Supriya Singh & Ors. Vs Ansal Urban Condominiums Pvt. Ltd., Company Appeal (AT) (Insolvency) No. 1974 of 2024 (NCLAT) — Distinguished on facts. That matter concerned pre-CIRP cancellations, treatment under the resolution plan and commercial wisdom of the CoC; those circumstances were absent in the present dispute.
- Vashdeo R. Bhojwani Vs Abhyudaya Co-operative Bank Ltd. & Anr., Civil Appeal No. 11020 of 2018 / (2019) 9 SCC 158 (Supreme Court) — Distinguished because it concerned limitation arising from a financial creditor’s recovery certificate in a loan-default setting, whereas the present dispute involved homebuyer-allottees and continuing non-delivery/refund obligations.
FULL TEXT OF THE NCLAT JUDGMENT/ORDER
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.





