Introduction
In the domain of business negotiations, a Letter of intent plays a fundamental role often serving as a formal handshake before entering into a contract. It lays down basis for mutual understanding, demarcates the key terms of an agreement and sets the tone for a contractual relationship. However, the question of whether a Letter of Intent is binding or non-binding requires careful deliberation.
This write-up delves into the nuances of a letter of intent and the impact the distinctions between its binding and non-binding nature can have on the parties involved. As we embark on this exploration, it becomes apparent that the seemingly straightforward nature of letter of intent contradicts a complex web of legal, strategic, and practical considerations.
Reading the Intent behind the Letter of Intent
Prima facie, the title of a letter of intent would undoubtedly pose it as a non-binding intention to enter into a contract. However, it cannot be concluded upon unless the content of the letter has been thoroughly studied. The drafting and tone of the document is what decide its nature.
When drafting a document, simply using terms like ‘letter of intent,’ in the title isn’t enough to reveal its legal nature. To truly understand the parties’ intentions, you have to read the whole document. The ‘non-binding clause’ becomes relevant only in the context of the entire piece.
In terms of language, it’s important not to sound like a typical legal document. The document one is proposing should feel more like an exploration, keeping things open-ended and provisional.
When it comes to non-binding obligations, one needs to be careful with the wording. It is better to avoid using strong terms that make it appear in such a way that the commitments are enforceable. This kind of document is more about expressing aspirations than creating strict obligations.
However, there are certain provisions that inherently require the need for enforceability. Such clauses are likely to have an impact irrespective of the execution of any further transactions. Clauses like confidentiality have to be considered under all circumstances. Hence, the drafting needs to be such that it does not sabotage the ongoing arrangements of the parties.
The governing law and jurisdiction clause should be specific. Instead of applying to the entire document, it should focus on certain terms or any potential future agreements. A broad application might give the impression that the parties wanted the whole document to be binding.
In a recent legal ruling, a two-judge bench of the Supreme Court, as observed in the case of South Eastern Coalfields Ltd vs. S. Kumar’s Associates AKM (JV), 2021 SCC OnLine SC 486, emphasized that the letter of intent under scrutiny did not carry legal binding force. This decision, however, came with a cautionary tone from the court, urging careful consideration of the legal implications. The Court mentioned that “It is no doubt possible to construe a letter of intent as a binding contract if such an intention is evident from its terms. But then the intention to do so must be clear and unambiguous as it takes a deviation from how normally a letter of intent has to be understood”.
Prospective sellers should thoroughly review and consider exclusivity clauses, acknowledging that even if discussions on a transaction appear to have halted, they may still be constrained by limitations preventing them from exploring other alternatives. Additionally, potential buyers should be aware that economic conditions could ameliorate before the exclusivity period expires, constraining the ability to negotiate exclusively with the prospective buyer until a definitive agreement is finalized.
Evidence in the Court of Law
A Letter of Intent, whether binding or non-binding, can also be produced as evidence in the court of law. The legal effect of such evidence is a question that can be examined upon by the Court at the evidence stage of any litigation or legal proceeding.
Conclusion
Therefore, one must remember that courts look at the bigger picture. Discussions before and after the document, the relationship between the parties, and their conduct on such letter of intent all play a role in figuring out what the parties really intended with the non-binding document.
The article is written by Ms. Veerti Shah – Manager and Mr. Nilesh Javkar – Senior Manager – Legal Agreements!
Author Bio
