Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Corporate Law

Supreme Court Bars Reliance on Police Confessions in Spurious Liquor Prosecution

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 18949
Case Name
Sanuj Bansal Vs State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr. (Supreme Court of India)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Sanuj Bansal Vs State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr. (Supreme Court of India)

Summary: The Supreme Court of India, in Sanuj Bansal Vs State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr., addressed a significant evidentiary irregularity arising from a criminal prosecution concerning allegedly spurious liquor in Uttar Pradesh. The matter reached the Supreme Court after the Allahabad High Court had dismissed the accused’s application under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, challenging the rejection of his discharge application. The central issue before the Supreme Court, as reflected in its subsequent order, concerned the inclusion of alleged confessional statements recorded by police officers in the chargesheet. The Supreme Court made it clear that such statements could not remain part of the chargesheet for consideration and directed the Trial Court to ignore them. The order did not quash the prosecution or finally decide the accused’s entitlement to discharge.

The underlying prosecution arose from Sessions Trial No. 1461 of 2021, originating in Case Crime No. 0596 of 2021 at Police Station Tajganj, District Agra. The offences mentioned in the Allahabad High Court order were under Sections 272, 273 and 304 of the Indian Penal Code and Section 60(A) of the Uttar Pradesh Excise Act. According to the prosecution, the case involved a hooch tragedy and allegations that spurious liquor had been purchased from a shop situated at Village Deori, allegedly connected with the applicant. The prosecution maintained that the FIR and witness statements specifically implicated him in the business of spurious liquor. These allegations formed the basis of the criminal proceedings and the dispute over whether sufficient material existed to require the applicant to face trial.

Before the Allahabad High Court, the applicant contended that he had been falsely implicated without reliable supporting evidence. His counsel submitted that the investigating officer had failed to collect independent material connecting him with the alleged offences and that the chargesheet had been submitted merely on the basis of allegations in the FIR and statements of witnesses. It was specifically argued that the allegation regarding ownership of the spurious liquor shop was unsupported by corroborative evidence. The investigating officer, according to the applicant, had neither visited the alleged shop nor made any meaningful attempt to verify its ownership. The applicant therefore challenged the order dated 20 October 2022 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Court No. 8, Agra, rejecting his discharge application, and sought quashing of the criminal proceedings.

The State opposed the application before the High Court, maintaining that the prosecution involved serious allegations arising from a hooch tragedy. The learned Additional Government Advocate argued that the FIR and witness statements contained specific allegations against the applicant and that the evidence, if accepted at face value, disclosed the alleged offences. The State further submitted that the truthfulness, sufficiency and acceptability of prosecution evidence could properly be examined during trial rather than conclusively determined at the discharge stage. On this reasoning, it was contended that the criminal proceedings should not be prematurely terminated. After hearing the parties and examining the material, the Allahabad High Court dismissed the application on 1 March 2023 as being without merit, thereby declining to interfere with the discharge order.

The subsequent Supreme Court proceedings brought a distinct issue into focus: the presence of alleged confessional statements recorded by police officers in the chargesheet. The Supreme Court examined an affidavit filed by Shri Prashant Kumar, Director General of Police, Uttar Pradesh. According to the affidavit, investigating officers in Uttar Pradesh were not recording confessional statements as a general practice, and the present matter was described as an exception in which the chargesheet contained alleged confessional statements recorded by the police. The Director General of Police also assured the Supreme Court that appropriate action would be taken against the investigating officer concerned. The Court recorded these statements without making a broader finding that similar irregularities had occurred in other investigations.

The Supreme Court expressly directed that police-recorded confessional statements forming part of the chargesheet must be ignored by the Trial Court. The direction is consistent with the evidentiary protection traditionally reflected in Section 25 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, which prohibits proof of a confession made to a police officer against an accused. The distinction between inadmissible police confessions and other legally admissible evidence is important: the Supreme Court’s direction addressed the impugned confessional material and did not amount to an adjudication that every other item of prosecution evidence was inadmissible. Nor did the supplied order determine whether the remaining evidence was sufficient for conviction, discharge or any other final relief.

The Supreme Court’s intervention is also relevant to the manner in which investigating agencies prepare chargesheets. A chargesheet should not place before the Trial Court material that is legally prohibited from being relied upon as a police confession. The distinction between a confession and other investigative material is recognised in criminal evidence law, including the limited statutory treatment of information leading to discovery of facts. The Supreme Court’s order in this case, however, did not separately examine the application of any discovery exception or evaluate particular portions of the alleged statements. Its operative direction was confined to excluding the police-recorded confessional statements from consideration, with the Trial Court expressly instructed to take note of that requirement.

The combined effect of the two orders is therefore limited but significant. The Allahabad High Court had declined to quash the prosecution at the preliminary stage, while the Supreme Court subsequently ensured that the criminal trial would not proceed on the basis of the police-recorded confessional statements identified in the chargesheet. The Supreme Court also recorded the Director General of Police’s assurance regarding action against the investigating officer and directed that the petition be listed for hearing on 15 October 2024. The supplied Supreme Court order was thus an interlocutory direction concerning the treatment of inadmissible material, not a final judgment disposing of the criminal proceedings. The prosecution’s ultimate outcome and the final disposal of the Supreme Court petition are not established by the two orders reproduced below.

Earlier Allahabad High Court Judgment: The Allahabad High Court had dismissed the accused’s application under Section 482 of the CrPC challenging the rejection of his discharge application, holding that the allegations required examination at trial. Read: Discharge Rejected in Spurious Liquor Case as Allegations Require Trial: Allahabad HC.

FULL TEXT OF THE SUPREME COURT JUDGMENT/ORDER

We have perused the affidavit of Shri Prashant Kumar, Director General of Police, Uttar Pradesh. He has stated that in the State of Uttar Pradesh, confessional statements are not being recorded by the Investigating officers and the present case is an exception where charge-sheet contains alleged confessional statements of the accused recorded by the police. He has assured that appropriate action will be taken against the concerned Investigating Officer.

It is obvious that confessional statements recorded by the Police Officers which are part of the charge-sheet cannot remain a part thereof and the same must be ignored. The Trial Court to take note of this.

List the petition for hearing on 15th October, 2024.

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Sandeep Kanoi
Qualification: Graduate, CA in Job / Business, DD
Company: Taxguru Consultancy
Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra
Articles Published: 24,609

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.