Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Corporate Law

Discharge Rejected in Spurious Liquor Case as Allegations Require Trial: Allahabad HC

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 18948
Case Name
Sanuj Bansal Vs State of U.P. and Another (Allahabad High Court)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Sanuj Bansal Vs State of U.P. and Another (Allahabad High Court)

Summary: The Allahabad High Court, in Sanuj Bansal Vs State of U.P. and Another, dismissed an application under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, seeking quashing of the order dated 20 October 2022 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Court No. 8, Agra, rejecting the applicant’s discharge application. The applicant also sought quashing of the entire proceedings in Sessions Trial No. 1461 of 2021 arising from Case Crime No. 0596 of 2021, registered at Police Station Tajganj, District Agra, under Sections 272, 273 and 304 of the Indian Penal Code and Section 60(A) of the Uttar Pradesh Excise Act. The prosecution arose from allegations concerning spurious liquor and was described by the State as a hooch tragedy.

The applicant contended that he had been implicated without supporting evidence and that the investigating officer had failed to collect material establishing his involvement. According to his counsel, the chargesheet rested merely on allegations in the FIR and statements of witnesses. It was argued that witnesses had casually attributed ownership of the spurious liquor shop to the applicant without documentary or other corroborative evidence. Counsel further submitted that the investigating officer had neither attempted to verify the alleged ownership nor visited the shop. On this basis, the applicant maintained that the trial court’s rejection of his discharge application was illegal, arbitrary and passed without proper application of judicial mind.

Opposing the application, the learned Additional Government Advocate submitted that the matter involved a hooch tragedy and that the FIR and witness statements specifically alleged the applicant’s involvement in the business of spurious liquor. The prosecution asserted that liquor had been purchased from his shop situated at Village Deori. The State argued that, at the preliminary stage, the appropriate enquiry was whether the prosecution evidence, if accepted, would constitute the alleged offences. The truthfulness, sufficiency and acceptability of that evidence were matters for adjudication during trial. Consequently, the State maintained that the proceedings should not be terminated prematurely and that the discharge order did not warrant interference.

After hearing the parties and examining the material placed on record, the Allahabad High Court dismissed the application as devoid of merit. The Court did not accept the request to interfere with the rejection of discharge or to quash the criminal proceedings. The operative order is brief and does not contain a separate detailed evaluation of the evidence or an independent discussion of judicial precedents. The dismissal therefore leaves the prosecution to proceed in accordance with law, without constituting a finding that the allegations against the applicant have been proved.

Subsequent Supreme Court Order: In proceedings arising from the same case, the Supreme Court directed the Trial Court to disregard the alleged confessional statements recorded by police officers and included in the chargesheet, without quashing the prosecution or finally deciding the accused’s entitlement to discharge. Read: Supreme Court Bars Reliance on Police Confessions in Spurious Liquor Prosecution.

FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ALLAHABAD HIGH COURT

Heard learned counsel for the applicant and learned A.G.A. and perused the material placed on record.

Present application has been filed with the prayer to quash the impugned judgement and order dated 20.10.2022 passed by learned Addl. Sessions Judge, Court No. 8, Agra whereby the discharge application of the applicant in Sessions Trial No. 1461 of 2021 arising out of Case Crime No. 0596 of 2021, under Sections 272,273304 IPC and Section 60(A) of the UP Excise Act, P.S. Tajganj, District Agra has been rejected as well as the entire proceedings of the aforesaid case.

Learned counsel for the applicant submitted that applicant has been made accused in the present matter by opposite party no.2 without any evidence and during investigation Investigating Officer also failed to collect any evidence against him and merely on the basis of allegation made in the FIR and in the statement of witnesses charge sheet in the present matter was submitted against him and when he filed discharge application before the trial court then his discharge application was dismissed by the trial court vide order dated 20.10.2022.

He next submitted that the order dated 20.10.2020 is wholly illegal and there is no evidence on record on the basis of which it could be even reflected that applicant was also involved in commission of alleged offence and there is no prima facie evidence against him.

He next submitted that from the perusal of the FIR and the statement of witnesses it appears that they in a very casual manner stated that the spurious liquor shop belongs to applicant but there is no such evidence on record except the bald allegation. During investigation Investigating Officer neither made any attempt to collect any evidence in this regard nor he ever visited the alleged shop of the applicant.

Learned counsel for the applicant has submitted that impugned order rejecting the application for discharge by the court below is wholly illegal, capricious and against weight of evidence on record. He has further submitted that the impugned order has been passed illegally in a routine manner and without application of judicial mind, hence without considering nature of evidence on record and therefore, the same are liable to be quashed.

Per contra, learned AGA opposed the prayer and submitted that it is a case of hooch tragedy and there is specific allegation against the applicant in the FIR and in the statement of witnesses that he was involved in the business of spurious liquor and liquor was purchased from his shop situated at Village Deori. The principle to be adopted in such cases should be that if the entire evidence produced by the prosecution is to be believed would it constitute the offence or not. It is only at the stage of the trial that truthfulness, sufficiency and acceptability of the evidence can be adjudged. Therefore, it will not be proper to truncate or snip the proceeding at this stage. The impugned order passed by the court below is well in conformity in law and does not suffer from error of illegality, irregularity and warrant no interference by this Court.

The application is bereft of merit and having no force it is dismissed accordingly.

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Sandeep Kanoi
Qualification: Graduate, CA in Job / Business, DD
Company: Taxguru Consultancy
Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra
Articles Published: 24,609

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.