Ashok Kumar Vs State of Union Territory Chandigarh (Supreme Court of India)
Summary: The Supreme Court, in Ashok Kumar Vs State of Union Territory Chandigarh, set aside the Punjab and Haryana High Court’s order dated 21 July 2023 refusing anticipatory bail to a police official accused of forging service reports connected with summons issued by the State Consumer Dispute Redressal Commission. The prosecution arose from FIR No. 05/2023 dated 15 June 2023, registered at Vigilance Police Station, Chandigarh, for offences under Sections 419, 465, 468 and 471 read with Section 120-B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, and Section 7-C of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. The appellant had initially approached the Sessions Court and thereafter the High Court, but both courts declined anticipatory bail. The Supreme Court subsequently examined whether the appellant’s cooperation with the investigation and the State’s justification for custodial interrogation warranted a different exercise of discretion.
The prosecution alleged that the appellant, while serving as Moharrir Head Constable, was responsible for effecting service upon persons summoned by the State Consumer Dispute Redressal Commission. According to the Public Prosecutor before the High Court, the appellant had forged service reports to enable several persons, including builders, to evade service. The prosecution also relied upon a forensic report which, according to its submissions, indicated that the appellant had forged signatures and handwriting of other officials. The High Court considered the allegations of forgery and fabrication sufficiently serious to decline anticipatory bail. These allegations, however, remained matters for investigation and trial and were not findings of criminal guilt.
Before the High Court, the petitioner had contended that he was falsely implicated and that the FIR had been registered several years after the alleged occurrence. His counsel pointed out that a departmental enquiry had commenced on 20 March 2017 and that he had cooperated with the enquiry. The petitioner also relied upon his nearly 30-year unblemished service record and argued that there was no material establishing that he had favoured any person. The State opposed bail by relying on the alleged fabrication of service reports and forensic findings. On 21 July 2023, the High Court dismissed the petition, holding that the serious allegations did not warrant the concession of anticipatory bail.
In the Supreme Court, the appellant challenged the refusal of anticipatory bail. On 25 August 2023, the Supreme Court had issued notice and granted interim protection against arrest. Following that protection, the appellant appeared before the Investigating Officer, participated in interrogation and had his statements recorded. His specimen signatures and handwriting were also collected and sent to the Forensic Science Laboratory. The appellant relied upon these developments to submit that he had cooperated with the investigation and should be granted anticipatory bail. The Union Territory of Chandigarh opposed the request, asserting that the appellant was the principal accused and that custodial interrogation remained necessary.
The Supreme Court observed that the FIR originated from a departmental enquiry initiated sometime in 2017 and that approximately six years had elapsed before the criminal case was registered. However, the Court expressly clarified that this delay alone was not sufficient to justify anticipatory bail. The decisive consideration was that the appellant had already joined the investigation and cooperated with the investigating agency. The Court therefore examined whether the prosecution had established an adequate investigative justification for taking the appellant into custody, rather than treating the seriousness of the allegations or the delay in registration as automatically determinative.
Explaining the governing approach, the Supreme Court acknowledged that custodial interrogation is an effective investigative method. It also clarified that the absence of a requirement for custodial interrogation does not, by itself, justify granting anticipatory bail where the alleged offences are serious. Nevertheless, the Court held that the State cannot defeat a request for pre-arrest protection merely by asserting that custodial interrogation is necessary. The prosecution must show or indicate, beyond a prima facie assertion, why custody is required for the investigation. The distinction between a general investigative requirement and a demonstrated need for custody is central to the decision. Comparable discussions of the necessity for custodial interrogation appear in Further Investigation Alone Does Not Justify Custodial Interrogation: Telangana HC, although that later decision was not cited in the present proceedings.
The appellant assured the Supreme Court that he would continue to appear before the Investigating Officer whenever required and cooperate with the investigation. Taking account of his participation in the investigation, the recording of his statements and the collection of forensic specimens, the Court exercised its discretion in his favour. The Supreme Court set aside the High Court’s order and directed that, in the event of arrest in connection with the FIR, the appellant should be released on bail subject to such terms and conditions as the Investigating Officer considered appropriate. The criminal appeal and pending applications were disposed of. The Court did not quash the FIR or determine the appellant’s criminal liability.
The combined decisions illustrate the different considerations that may operate at successive stages of anticipatory bail proceedings. The High Court had refused relief because of the seriousness of the allegations and the prosecution’s forensic assertions. The Supreme Court, after interim protection had enabled further investigation, gave weight to the appellant’s cooperation and required a more specific justification for custodial interrogation. The ruling does not establish an automatic entitlement to bail whenever an accused joins an investigation. Rather, it emphasises the need to assess the gravity of the allegations, investigative requirements and the accused’s conduct together. The broader principles governing the duration and operation of anticipatory bail are also discussed in Anticipatory Bail is not fixed for a particular period & can continue till end of trial: SC, which is included as related reading and not as an authority cited in these orders.
Related TaxGuru Reading: For additional discussions on the legal framework governing pre-arrest protection, see Anticipatory Bail Need Not End on Filing of Chargesheet: Supreme Court, Anticipatory bail in fraudulent GST Input Tax Credit allowed as custodial interrogation not warranted, Custody in One Case Does Not Bar Anticipatory Bail in Another: Orissa HC, and Condition of pre-deposit for anticipatory bail in absence of final assessment not sustainable. These are related publications, not decisions cited in the present Supreme Court order.
Related High Court Ruling: In a case involving allegations of forgery of service reports, the Punjab and Haryana High Court rejected the anticipatory bail application of a Head Constable, highlighting the relevance of individual facts and circumstances in deciding anticipatory bail applications. Read: Anticipatory Bail Denied to Head Constable Accused of Forging Service Reports: P&H HC.
FULL TEXT OF THE SUPREME COURT JUDGMENT/ORDER
1. Leave granted.
2. We have heard Mr. D.K. Sharma, the learned counsel appearing for the appellant (original accused) and Mr. Kanu Agarwal, the learned counsel appearing for the respondent-Union Territory of Chandigarh.
3. A First Information Report bearing No. 05/2023 dated 15.06.2023 came to be registered with the Vigilance Police Station, Chandigarh against the appellant and other co-accused for the offences punishable under Sections 419, 465, 468 and 471 read with Section 120-B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 and Section 7-C of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.
4. The appellant apprehending arrest at the hands of the police first prayed for anticipatory bail before the Sessions Court Chandigarh. The Sessions Court declined to grant anticipatory bail. The appellant thereafter, went before the High Court and prayed for anticipatory bail. The High Court also declined to grant anticipatory bail.
5. In such circumstances referred to above, the appellant is here before this Court with the present appeal.
6. By our Order dated 25.08.2023, notice was issued and an interim order was passed that the appellant shall not be arrested.
7. We are informed that after our Order dated 25.08.2023, referred to above the appellant appeared before the Investigating Officer for the purpose of interrogation and his statements have been recorded. We are also informed that the specimen signatures/ hand-writings of the appellant has also been collected and sent to the Forensic Science Laboratory.
8. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant submitted that in such circumstances, the appellant may be ordered to be released on anticipatory bail. On the other hand, Mr. Kanu Agarwal, the learned counsel appearing for the respondent-Union Territory of Chandigarh has vehemently opposed the plea for anticipatory bail. He submitted that the appellant is the main accused and his custodial interrogation is required.
9. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and having gone through the materials on record, the only question that falls for our consideration is whether we should exercise our discretion in favour of the appellant and order his release on anticipatory bail in the event of his arrest by the police?
10. The First Information Report originates from a departmental inquiry initiated sometime in 2017. It took almost 6 years for the police to register the FIR for the alleged offences. We do not say for a moment that this by itself is sufficient to order the release of the appellant on anticipatory bail.
11. One good ground which has persuaded us to exercise our discretion in favour of the appellant is that the appellant has already joined the investigation. He has cooperated in the investigation so far.
12. There is no gainsaying that custodial interrogation is one of the effective modes of investigating into the alleged crime. It is equally true that just because custodial interrogation is not required that by itself may also not be a ground to release an accused on anticipatory bail if the offences are of a serious nature. However, a mere assertion on the part of the State while opposing the plea for anticipatory bail that custodial interrogation is required would not be sufficient. The State would have to show or indicate more than prima facie why the custodial interrogation of the accused is required for the purpose of investigation.
13. The appellant has assured this Court that as and when required to appear in future before the Investigating Officer, he would do so and cooperate in the investigation.
14. Without observing anything further, we set aside the impugned order passed by the High Court. We order that in the event of arrest of the appellant by the police in connection with the F.I.R. referred above, he shall be released on bail subject to terms and conditions that the Investigating Officer may deem fit to impose.
15. The appeal stands disposed of, as above.
16. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
1. The appeal stands disposed of in terms of the Signed Order placed on the file.
2. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.






