PCIT (Central) Vs Vaibhav Global Limited (Rajasthan High Court)
Summary: The Rajasthan High Court dismissed the Revenue’s appeal against the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal’s decision in the case of Vaibhav Global Limited. Two issues arose: the arm’s length price of corporate guarantees issued on behalf of associated enterprises and the deductibility of approximately ₹50.72 crore arising from permanent diminution in the value of equity investments in a United States subsidiary. The Court declined to interfere with the Tribunal on either issue. The Transfer Pricing Officer had applied a guarantee commission rate of 1.30%, while the Tribunal directed recomputation at 0.53%. Revenue counsel brought to the Court’s attention the earlier Division Bench decision dated 27 May 2019 in Income Tax Appeal No. 281/2018 involving the same assessee. That decision had rejected the Revenue’s challenge to a reduction in the corporate guarantee fee adjustment. Accordingly, the Court did not entertain the first question.
The second question concerned ₹50,72,57,000 written off following permanent diminution in the value of shares of Jewels Gems USA Inc. The Assessing Officer rejected the claim under Section 37 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 on the ground that the investment was capital rather than revenue expenditure. The Assessing Officer also rejected deduction as a bad debt under Section 36. The Tribunal reversed the disallowance, relying on its earlier decision in the assessee’s own case for assessment year 2012–13. It accepted that overseas subsidiaries had been set up for worldwide business expansion and that the investment had been made with a commercial objective. The Tribunal therefore treated the loss as revenue expenditure allowable under Section 37.
The High Court held that the assessee had invested in its subsidiary to expand business and earn higher profits. The investment was driven by business expediency. Finding no error in the Tribunal’s reasoning and no question of law, the Court dismissed the appeal. Related decisions on commercial expediency in subsidiary investments and business loss on subsidiary shares discuss comparable issues, although their facts are distinct.
Cases Discussed
Principal Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) v. Vaibhav Global Limited, Income Tax Appeal No. 281/2018, order dated 27 May 2019 (Rajasthan High Court) — Earlier decision involving the same assessee, relied upon for the corporate guarantee ALP issue. The supplied judgment does not identify other precedents by name.
FULL TEXT OF THE JUDGMENT/ORDER OF RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT
This appeal is filed by the revenue to challenge the judgment of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal. Though as many as four questions are framed by the revenue in the appeal, the issues are only two which can be gathered from the following questions framed by the department:-
“1. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the Hon’ble ITAT is justified in directing the AO to re-compute the adjustment by applying arm’s length price of guarantee at 0.53% against 1.30% applied by the TPO/AO on account of bank guarantees charges given by the assessee on behalf of its associated enterprises.
3. Whether in the facts and in circumstances of the case, the Hon’ble ITAT was justified in law and in allowing the write off of loss of Rs.50,72,57,000/- on account of permanent diminution in value of investment made in equity shares of one of its subsidiary M/s Jewels Gems USA Inc. without appreciating that the amount is not an expense, loan or advance of any kind that is required to be debited to the profit and loss account of the assessee, and the amount was an investment that was never debited to the P&L account of the company.”
So far as the first question is concerned, learned counsel for the revenue candidly brought to our notice an order dated 27/05/2019 passed by the division bench in Income Tax Appeal No. 281/2018 in the case of the present assessee. The appeal of the revenue was dismissed making the following observations:-
“This court notices that ALP determination which led to adjustments on both counts, were the subject matter of previous appeal decided in its favour by the ITAT. Further appeal to this court by the revenue was unsuccessful. Moreover the reduction of ALP determination on interest, in this court’s opinion, by applying LIBOR rates, is reasonable because the amounts were used by the AE Abroad and the yardstick, therefore, was naturally as per LIBOR rates. Likewise, as far as the ALP determination of the cooperate guarantee fee, mere reduction per se does not result in a question of law, as is urged in this appeal.”
Under the situation, the first question is not entertained.
The second question pertains to the objection of the revenue to the claim of the assessee of a business loss of Rs.50.72 crores (rounded off) on account of permanent diminution in the value of the investment made in the equity shares in one of the subsidiaries of the assessee in USA. According to the assessing officer this loss was not allowable under Section 37 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 since the expenditure could not have been considered as a revenue expenditure. He also held that this was not a case of bad debt which could be allowed under Section 36 of the Act. The assessee carried the matter in appeal. The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal by the impugned judgment reversed the decision of the assessing officer on this point relying upon the earlier decision of the Tribunal in case of the assessee for the assessment year 2012-13. In such order the tribunal relying on the decisions of the Supreme Court and High Courts noted that under similar circumstances the expenditure incurred by the company were allowed. This was on the basis that the assessee company in order to expand its business world wide had setup subsidiaries in other countries. The investment made in such companies was seen as revenue expenditure since the purpose behind making the investment was only for expansion of the business. Applying this logic to the assessee in the present case, the Tribunal was of the opinion that such investment being in the nature of revenue expenditure was to be allowed under Section 37 of the Act.
Having perused the order passed by the assessing officer and by the tribunal and having heard learned counsel for the revenue, we find no error in the view expressed by the tribunal. As noted, the assessee had made investment in its subsidiary company in order to expand its business with a view to earn higher profit. The investment was thus driven by business expediency. The tribunal therefore committed no error. No question of law arises.
The appeal is dismissed.




