Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Corporate Law

RPF Recruitment: Delhi HC Upholds Termination for Concealing Criminal Case in Attestation Form

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 18996
Case Name
Pawan Kumar Vs Union of India & Anr. (Delhi High Court)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Pawan Kumar Vs Union of India & Anr. (Delhi High Court)

Summary: The Delhi High Court considered the challenge brought by Pawan Kumar against the termination of his employment with the Railway Protection Force (RPF). He had applied pursuant to an employment notice dated 27 February 2011, appeared in the written examination on 23 June 2013 and passed the Physical Efficiency Test on 12 June 2014. He completed an attestation form on 27 May 2014, answering negatively to questions concerning his previous arrest, detention and prosecution. In April 2015, the RPF terminated his services after antecedent verification disclosed a criminal case and prosecution that had not been revealed in the attestation form. The petitioner argued that he had been acquitted by the criminal court on 12 August 2011, had not been named in the FIR and had not deliberately concealed any material fact. He also relied on his rural background to explain the omission.

The High Court examined the criminal court judgment and found that Pawan Kumar had been arrested with other accused persons on 21 April 2011 and subsequently released on bail. The underlying allegations involved a group of boys allegedly stopping a bus and assaulting its driver and conductor. The complainant turned hostile, and the accused were acquitted. The Court nevertheless distinguished the outcome of the criminal trial from the obligation to disclose the earlier proceedings. Relying on Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan v. Ram Ratan Yadav, A.P. Public Service Commission v. Koneti Venkateswarulu, R. Radhakrishnan v. Director General of Police and Devendra Kumar v. State of Uttaranchal, the High Court held that material suppression in recruitment documentation could justify cancellation of appointment irrespective of the criminal proceedings’ outcome. It found that the petitioner had provided false responses to multiple questions in column 12 of the attestation form and dismissed the writ petition and pending application.

This account records the Delhi High Court’s decision of 17 November 2015 only. The Supreme Court subsequently allowed the appeal arising from this order on 2 May 2022; the uploaded High Court order does not contain the Supreme Court’s reasoning.

Subsequent Supreme Court Decision: The judgment of the Delhi High Court was subsequently challenged before the Supreme Court, which allowed the appeal. Read: Supreme Court Allows RPF Recruit’s Appeal Against Termination Over Criminal Antecedents.

Cases Discussed:

  • Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan v. Ram Ratan Yadav — AIR 2003 SC 1709 (Supreme Court) — Cited regarding disclosure of criminal antecedents during recruitment.
  • A.P. Public Service Commission v. Koneti Venkateswarulu — AIR 2005 SC 4292 (Supreme Court) — Cited regarding disclosure of criminal antecedents during recruitment.
  • R. Radhakrishnan v. Director General of Police and Ors. — AIR 2008 SC 578 (Supreme Court) — Cited regarding disclosure of criminal antecedents during recruitment.
  • Devendra Kumar v. State of Uttaranchal — (2013) 9 SCC 363 (Supreme Court) — Cited regarding disclosure of criminal antecedents during recruitment.

FULL TEXT OF THE JUDGMENT/ORDER OF DELHI HIGH COURT

The petitioner had applied for recruitment and participated in the selection process for appointment to the Railway Protection Force (RPF). The employment notice was issued on 27.02.2011. The petitioner was permitted and appeared in the written examination on 23.06.2013 and subsequently successfully cleared the Physical Efficiency Test on 12.06.2014. In these circumstances, upon the respondents’ determination of his fitness, he was asked to furnish an Attestation Form which he did on 27.05.2014. Column 12 of that Attestation Form elicited various information with respect to prior conduct such as whether the candidate had been arrested; whether he was prosecuted; whether he had been kept under detention or bound down and whether he had ever been fined by a Court of law.

The petitioner answered in the negative. There were further questions regarding whether any criminal case was pending against the candidate in the Court of law at the time of filing of the Attestation Form. Consequently, having regard to the replies to the queries in the Attestation Form, he was appointed subject to verification of his antecedents.

In April 2015, the petitioner’s services were terminated by the impugned order. That order has been impugned. It inter alia states that the verification of the petitioner’s particulars reveal that he had furnished false information and had suppressed the fact that he was charged in a criminal case and had faced prosecution.

It was urged by the petitioner that the criminal case he was charged with was in respect of an alleged incident of 2011 and that the judgment of the competent criminal court was delivered on 12.08.2011 which had resulted in his acquittal. It was further urged that the petitioner had not been arrested and that in fact he had not been named in the First Information Report (FIR).

Learned counsel for the petitioner was at pains to point out that the charge under Section 356 IPC was in fact not drawn against the petitioner. It was submitted that the petitioner’s omission to mention his prior involvement in any criminal case was bona fide and was because he belonged to the rural background.

The record of this petition contains a copy of the judgment rendered by the competent criminal court on 12.08.2011. That clearly shows that the petitioner along with the other accused was arrested on 21.04.2011. They were also admitted to bail subsequently. The incident for which the petitioner was charged was one whereby 10-12 boys allegedly armed with iron rods stopped a bus and beat up the driver and the conductor of the bus. The incident also led to loss of about `29,000/-. That amount was, however, not recovered. A copy of the judgment also reveals that the complainant – PW-1 turned hostile and that in these circumstances, the Court acquitted the accused – including the petitioner. In several judgments of the Supreme Court, i.e. Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan v. Ram Ratan Yadav AIR 2003 SC 1709; A.P. Public Service Commission v. Koneti Venkateswarulu AIR 2005 SC 4292; R. Radhakrishnan v. Director General of Police and Ors. AIR 2008 SC 578 and Devendra Kumar v. State of Uttaranchal 2013 (9) SCC 363, it has been repeatedly held that a person who suppresses material information at the time of his selection and appointment cannot be considered suitable and that irrespective of the outcome of the criminal proceedings, the employer is entitled to treat this fact as vital suppression and cancel the appointment.

In the present case, column 12 of the Attestation Form contained five details which had to be filled in by the petitioner and other candidates. The petitioner was charged and had been prosecuted; likewise he was under detention and had been arrested as well. In respect of each of these queries, he supplied false information.

Having regard to the entire conspectus of the facts, the Court is satisfied that the direction sought for cannot be granted. The writ petition is accordingly dismissed along with the pending application.

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Sandeep Kanoi
Qualification: Graduate, CA in Job / Business, DD
Company: Taxguru Consultancy
Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra
Articles Published: 24,648

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.