Suvarn R. Bandekar Vs CA. Sachin Laxman Urmila Kadam (ICAI Disciplinary Committee)
Outstanding Debtors Alone Do Not Establish Audit Negligence: ICAI Clears Chartered Accountant
Summary: Long-outstanding trade receivables and subsequent business closure do not, by themselves, establish professional negligence by a statutory auditor. The ICAI Disciplinary Committee, Bench-II, examined these issues in Shri Suvarn R. Bandekar Vs CA. Sachin Laxman Urmila Kadam, arising from the statutory audit of Shirsa Labs Private Limited for financial year 2018-19.
The Committee held the respondent Chartered Accountant not guilty of professional misconduct under Clause (7) of Part I of the Second Schedule to the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949. The proceedings were closed through an order dated 29 October 2026, after consideration of the financial statements, submissions and material available on record.
Background of the Complaint
The complainant was a director of Vishwas Warehousing and Trading Private Limited, which held a 50% shareholding in Shirsa Labs Private Limited. The respondent Chartered Accountant audited Shirsa Labs’ financial statements for financial year 2018-19.
The complaint principally concerned the auditor’s treatment of trade receivables, their recoverability and the company’s ability to continue as a going concern.
According to the complainant, the auditor had failed to report appropriately on substantial outstanding debtors and had not exercised the diligence required under Standard on Auditing 570, dealing with going concern. The Director (Discipline) initially formed a prima facie opinion that the respondent was guilty of misconduct. However, that preliminary opinion remained subject to the Committee’s examination.
Allegations Concerning Outstanding Receivables
The financial statements reflected total trade receivables of ₹1,73,86,329 as at 31 March 2019. Of this amount, ₹97,53,579 was outstanding for more than 180 days.
The complainant questioned the absence of a provision against these balances and alleged inadequate verification of their recoverability. Concerns were also raised regarding supporting records, balance confirmations and the possibility of doubtful or fictitious debtors.
The respondent denied negligence. His defence included reliance on the company’s accounting policy concerning bad debts and the disclosure that balances were subject to confirmation and reconciliation.
The central question was whether the material established a failure to exercise due diligence, rather than merely showing that receivables remained outstanding.
Committee’s Findings on Debtor Reporting
The Committee examined the financial statements and noted that the receivables had been disclosed as unsecured and considered good. Their ageing had also been separately presented.
It further considered the stated accounting policy under which debts considered irrecoverable were written off, and other receivables were regarded as recoverable by management.
The Committee also took account of the note disclosing that balances relating to sundry debtors, creditors, loans and advances were subject to confirmation and reconciliation, with consequential adjustments to be made when determined.
On the material before it, the Committee did not find the allegations sufficient to establish professional misconduct concerning the outstanding receivables. This was an assessment of the particular record; it should not be understood as a general proposition that financial statement disclosures automatically substitute for necessary audit procedures. The importance of independent verification and sufficient audit evidence is also illustrated by the separate TaxGuru report, ICAI Removes Auditor for Six Months Over Unverified ₹567.77 Crore Overseas Loan.
Going Concern: Subsequent Closure Was Not Conclusive
The complainant also relied on circumstances concerning the company’s business operations and subsequent closure to question the appropriateness of the going concern assumption.
The Committee examined the company’s financial position during the relevant period. It noted that the company had reported a profit of ₹40,38,926, compared with ₹1,51,709 in the preceding year, and that its net worth was positive.
The Committee further observed that the company’s business had closed in March 2021, whereas the audit under examination related to financial year 2018-19. A subsequent closure did not, on the facts considered, establish that the auditor had failed in assessing going concern for the earlier financial statements.
The distinction is significant: later developments must be evaluated in their proper temporal context before drawing conclusions about an earlier audit. For a broader discussion of the applicable reporting framework, see NFRA Issues Going Concern Guidance on SA 570 for Auditors and Audit Committees.
Non-Appearance Did Not Determine the Merits
The respondent initially appeared before the Committee and pleaded not guilty, but subsequently failed to attend despite further opportunities.
The Committee proceeded ex parte, examined the available documents and considered the complainant’s submissions. Nevertheless, the respondent’s absence was not treated as sufficient proof of the substantive allegations.
Ultimately, the Committee recorded that the respondent was not guilty under Clause (7) and ordered closure of the proceedings under Rule 19(2) of the Chartered Accountants (Procedure of Investigations of Professional and Other Misconduct and Conduct of Cases) Rules, 2007.
Author’s Comments
The decision illustrates why commercial failure and professional misconduct require separate examination. An unpaid debtor does not automatically establish a defective audit, just as business closure in a subsequent year does not automatically invalidate an earlier going concern assessment.
Equally, the ruling should not encourage auditors to rely solely on management’s classification of debts or standard notes concerning confirmation and reconciliation. Appropriate audit evidence and documentation remain essential, particularly where receivables are substantial or recovery is uncertain.
The practical lesson is balanced. Allegations of negligence require examination against the actual audit period and supporting record. For auditors, the strongest protection remains a documented, reasoned assessment of recoverability and going concern, supported by appropriate procedures.
The outcome can also be compared with CA Not Guilty for Housing Society Reserve Fund Conveyance Expense: ICAI, where the Committee likewise examined the specific evidence before declining to sustain a professional misconduct charge. The comparison is editorial; that decision was not cited in the present disciplinary proceedings.


![7 Best Free Link to MP4 Downloaders Online [New]](https://taxguru.in/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/How-to-Download-Instagram-Videos-in-MP4-Format.jpg)



