AGS Customer Services (India) Pvt. Ltd. Vs Commissioner of Service Tax-I, Pune (CESTAT Mumbai)
Summary: The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), Mumbai, considered an appeal filed by AGS Customer Services (India) Pvt. Ltd. challenging confirmation of a service tax demand of ₹1,78,92,239, along with interest and an equal penalty, under the category of Manpower Recruitment and Supply Agency Services. The dispute concerned employees seconded from an overseas associated company and the applicability of service tax under the reverse charge mechanism. The demand covered financial years 2009-10 to 2011-12 and arose from Order-in-Original dated 28 October 2016 passed by the Commissioner of Service Tax, Pune.
The appellant was registered for providing Business Support Services and was engaged in exporting such services. It was a wholly owned subsidiary within the Aviva Group, whose parent holding company, Aviva PLC, was situated in the United Kingdom. Under an agreement dated 1 September 2008 with Aviva Employment Services Ltd. (AESL), employees were recruited for the appellant, while remuneration was disbursed in their home country by AESL on behalf of AGS. Following intelligence concerning foreign remittances and departmental investigation, the authorities treated the arrangement as taxable manpower supply. A show-cause notice dated 14 October 2014 proposed recovery of service tax for the relevant period, alleging suppression of facts and non-payment of tax.
Before the Tribunal, both sides addressed the legal position arising from the Supreme Court’s decision in Commissioner of Customs, Central Excise & Service Tax, Bangalore (Adjudication) Vs Northern Operating Systems Pvt. Ltd. The Tribunal recorded that, applying that decision, secondment of employees by an overseas entity for carrying out the Indian assessee’s work constituted manpower supply and attracted service tax. However, the Tribunal also noted that the extended period of limitation could not be invoked merely because the assessee had not paid service tax while holding a bona fide belief, supported by the judicial position prevailing before the Supreme Court’s decision, that the arrangement was not taxable.
The Tribunal examined Section 73(1) read with Section 73(6) of the Finance Act, 1994. It observed that the normal limitation period for issuing the demand notice was 18 months from the relevant date, whereas an extended period of up to five years required the statutory conditions concerning fraud, collusion, wilful misstatement, suppression of facts or contravention with intent to evade service tax. The appellant had filed its service tax return for the relevant period on 24 April 2012. Accordingly, the normal limitation period expired on 23 October 2013. The show-cause notice was issued only on 14 October 2014, after expiry of that period.
CESTAT Mumbai concluded that the demand was entirely barred by limitation. It found no basis for invoking the extended limitation period and observed that no demand remained recoverable within the normal period. Consequently, the Tribunal allowed the appeal and set aside Order-in-Original No. PUN-SVTAX-000-COM-019-16-17 dated 28 October 2016, with consequential relief, if any. The decision therefore turned on limitation rather than a finding that overseas employee secondment was outside the scope of taxable manpower supply services.
Cases Discussed
- Commissioner of Customs, Central Excise & Service Tax, Bangalore (Adjudication) Vs Northern Operating Systems Pvt. Ltd. — 2022 (61) G.S.T.L. 129 (SC). The Supreme Court decision was applied to the taxability of overseas employee secondment and considered in relation to the extended limitation period.
FULL TEXT OF THE CESTAT MUMBAI ORDER
Confirmation of Service Tax demand of ₹1,78,92,239/- alongwith interest and equal penalty on secondment of employees by the Appellant to its associated/related Company at United Kingdom on reverse charge mechanism under the heading “Manpower Recruitment and Supply Agency Services” is assailed by the Appellant in this appeal.
2. Facts of the case, in a nutshell, is that Appellant is a holder of Service Tax registration No. AAHCA1940PST001. Intelligence was gathered by Directorate General of Audit (Customs, Central Excise & Service Tax), New Delhi that Appellant had remitted £13,06,045,95/- (GBP) during the financial year 2009-10 to 2011-12. Information was called for from the Appellant by the Preventive Unit, Pune-III of the Respondent-Department and from the information furnished by Appellant, it was found that Appellant had registered for ‘Business Support Service’ and its a 100% exporter of such service. It is a wholly own subsidiary of Aviva Group having parent holding company Aviva PLC located in United Kingdom. It had entered into anst agreement with M/s. Aviva Employment Services Ltd. (AESL) on 1 September, 2008 for recruiting some employees of AESL and accordingly employment letters were issued, salary etc. were disbursed to the employees in the home country by AESL on behalf of AGS. Holding the same to be “Manpower Recruitment and Supply Agency Services” on secondment and allegedly suppression of fact of non-payment of Service Tax, demand cum-show-cause notice dated 14.10.2014 for the financial year 2009-10 to 2011-12 was issued that was adjudicated upon and resulted in confirmation of the demand, interest and penalty, as referred above, which is assailed in this appeal.
3. We have heard submissions from both the sides and perused the case record. Argument is led by both sides with reference to provision of law and judicial decisions on the point but ultimately the consensus that emerged is that in view of Hon’ble Supreme Court judgment on the issue, as passed in the case of Commissioner of Customs, Central Excise & Service Tax, Bangalore (Adjudication) Vs. Northern Operating Systems Pvt. Ltd., secondment of employees by overseas entity for the purpose of completion of Assessee’s job amounts to manpower supply and Assessee was service recipient for the same and, therefore, demand was sustainable but invocation of extended period was impermissible as Assessee had bonafide believe that it was not liable to pay any Service Tax, apparently for the reason that judicial decision on the similar line till pronouncement of Northern Operating Systems Pvt. Ltd. judgement by the Hon’ble Supreme Court was holding the field. But in the present case it could be noticed that show-cause notice was issued on 14.10.2014 up to the end of financial year 2011-12 and in view of clear provision contained in Section 73(1) read with 73(6), the normal period for making demand through show-cause notice was 18 months from the relevant date unless any fraud, collusion, wilful misstatement, suppression of facts, contravention of any of the provisions of this Chapter or the Rules made thereunder with intent to evade payment of Service Tax is noticed, Central Excise Officer can serve notice for demand that could be extended up to 5 years. This being the statutory provision, the notice of demand being signed on 14.10.2014 and dispatched thereafter cannot be considered to have been sent within 18 months of the end of financial years up to which demand is made i.e. up to 31st March 2012, against which Service Tax Return was filed on 24.04.2012. We are, therefore, of the considered view that the show-cause notice is not issued in conformity to the law and, therefore, it was required to be quashed before initiation of adjudication proceeding.
4. In addition to our observation above, it would be worthwhile also to take on record the submission of learned Counsel for the Appellant that Appellant having filed its return for the said period on 24.04.2012, in view of clear provision contained in Section 73(6) (i)(a) wherein it has been mentioned that for the purpose of determination of “relevant date”, periodical return filed on the date showing particulars of Service Tax paid during the period to which return relates would be taken for the purpose of calculation of period of limitation of 18 months, which would end on 23.10.2013, during which period no irregularity was noticed to enable the Department to go beyond the normal period up to 5 years and therefore, the entire demand is barred by limitation.
5. We find force in the submissions of learned Counsel and we are in agreement with the contention of the Appellant that the demand, apart from being barred by the period of limitation, is also unsustainable for the extended period and since no demand is due for the normal period, the following order is passed.
THE ORDER
6. The appeal is allowed and the order passed by the Commissioner of Service Tax Commissionerate, Pune vide Order-in- Original No. PUN-SVTAX-000-COM-019-16-17 dated 28.10.2016 is hereby set aside with consequential relief, if any.
(Order pronounced in the open court on 25.06.2024)

