Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Service Tax

Seconded Overseas Employees Taxable Under Service Tax RCM: CESTAT Bangalore

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 18922
Case Name
Bangalore International Airport Limited Vs Commissioner Office of the Commissioner of Service Tax (CESTAT Bangalore)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Bangalore International Airport Limited Vs Commissioner Office of the Commissioner of Service Tax (CESTAT Bangalore)

Summary: The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), Bangalore, examined six appeals filed by Bangalore International Airport Limited (BIAL) against service tax demands relating to manpower recruitment or supply services, management consultancy services, airport services and alleged inadmissible CENVAT credit. The disputes covered various periods between April 2004 and March 2016. The Department alleged that BIAL had received taxable services from overseas companies without discharging service tax under the reverse charge mechanism. In particular, BIAL had entered into an Expatriate Remuneration Reimbursement Agreement with Unique (Flughafen Zurich AG), Switzerland, under which expatriate personnel were assigned to work exclusively for BIAL while part of their remuneration was paid overseas and reimbursed by BIAL. The Department treated this arrangement as taxable manpower supply. BIAL contended that the personnel worked under its exclusive control and supervision and that the overseas company merely facilitated salary payments. The Tribunal examined the agreement and applied the principles laid down in CC, CE & ST, Bangalore (Adjudication) Vs Northern Operating Systems Pvt. Ltd., 2022 (61) G.S.T.L. 129 (SC). It held that the arrangement constituted taxable manpower supply services. However, demands relating to periods before 18 April 2006 were unsustainable, while subsequent demands were restricted to the normal limitation period.

Regarding management consultancy services, the Tribunal considered the confirmed demand of ₹41,26,163 relating to project development, design, engineering, legal consultancy and other expenditure incurred in connection with the airport project. BIAL argued that service tax could not be demanded on services received from overseas entities before 18 April 2006, relying on Indian National Shipowners Association Vs Union of India, 2009 (13) S.T.R. 235 (Bom.). It further contended that reimbursable expenses could not be included in the taxable value before 14 May 2015 in view of Union of India Vs Intercontinental Consultants and Technocrats Pvt. Ltd., 2018 (10) G.S.T.L. 401 (SC). The Tribunal held that the demand of ₹17,15,138 relating to the period before 18 April 2006 could not be sustained. Regarding the remaining demand, including ₹21,63,596 claimed as reimbursable expenses, it observed that the Commissioner had not recorded specific findings regarding the actual nature of those expenses. Consequently, the issue was remanded to the adjudicating authority for verification and reconsideration in accordance with the applicable judicial principles.

On airport services, the Tribunal examined the demand of ₹28,68,873 concerning amounts collected and retained from unsuccessful bidders participating in tenders for airport-related facilities. BIAL submitted that the collections were intended to discourage non-serious bidders and meet tender-related expenses and did not represent consideration for providing taxable airport services. The Tribunal accepted the principle that amounts collected from unsuccessful bidders could not be treated as consideration for airport services merely because they had participated in the tender process. However, the Commissioner had found that BIAL had not produced sufficient documentary evidence establishing that the disputed amounts actually related to unsuccessful bidders. Accordingly, the Tribunal remanded the matter for factual verification. Regarding CENVAT credit, the Tribunal considered input services such as photography, videography, asset hiring, landscaping, office rent and civil and interior work. Following JSW Steel Ltd. Vs CCE, 2021 (121) TMI 381 (CESTAT Bangalore), it held that these services satisfied the definition of input service under Rule 2(l) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004, and that the corresponding CENVAT credit was admissible.

On limitation, interest and penalties, the Tribunal observed that the disputes involved interpretation of statutory provisions and that no material facts had been concealed or suppressed from the Department. Consequently, invocation of the extended limitation period and imposition of penalties were held unsustainable. The Tribunal concluded that service tax demands relating to overseas services received before 18 April 2006 were liable to be set aside, whereas demands on manpower supply services received after that date were sustainable with applicable interest for the normal limitation period. It also held that eligible CENVAT credit could not be denied and that penalties imposed on BIAL were unsustainable. The management consultancy reimbursement issue and the airport tender-fee issue were remanded for verification. Accordingly, all six appeals were disposed of with directions to the adjudicating authority to recompute the service tax demands and interest in accordance with the Tribunal’s findings. The order was pronounced on 9 July 2024.

Cases Discussed
  • Dell International Services India Pvt. Ltd. Vs CCE & C, Bangalore — 2023 (5) Centax 111 (Tri.-Bang.)
  • CC, CE & ST, Bangalore (Adjudication) Vs Northern Operating Systems Pvt. Ltd. — 2022 (61) G.S.T.L. 129 (SC)
  • CCE & ST, Rohtak Vs Merino Panel Products Ltd. — 2022 (12) TMI 453 (SC)
  • JSW Steel Ltd. Vs CCE — 2021 (121) TMI 381 (CESTAT Bangalore)
  • Union of India Vs Intercontinental Consultants and Technocrats Pvt. Ltd. — 2018 (10) G.S.T.L. 401 (SC)
  • UFO Moviez India Ltd. Vs Commissioner — 2017 (9) TMI 507 (CESTAT Mumbai)
  • CST, Bangalore Vs Motor World — 2012 (27) S.T.R. 225 (Kar.)
  • Uniflex Cables Ltd. Vs CCE, Surat — 2011 (271) E.L.T. 161 (SC)
  • Indian National Shipowners Association Vs Union of India — 2009 (13) S.T.R. 235 (Bom.)

FULL TEXT OF THE CESTAT BANGALORE ORDER

These appeals are filed against the respective Orders-in- Original passed by the Commissioner of Central Tax, Bangalore North Commissionerate, Bangalore/ Order-in-Appeal passed by the Commissioner(Appeals-II), Bangalore. Since common issues are involved, all these appeals are taken up together for hearing and disposal.

2. Brief facts of the case are that the appellants are registered with the Department for rendering various taxable services viz. Airport Services, Business Auxiliary Services, Consulting Engineering Service, Manpower Recruitment Agency service etc. On the basis of intelligence, investigation was initiated which revealed that the Appellant though recipient of taxable services provided from outside India had not discharged appropriate service Tax e under Rule 2(1) (d)(iv) of Service Tax Rules,1994. It further revealed that the appellant had entered into a service agreement with M/s. Unique (Flughafen Zurich AG), Switzerland (M/s. Unique, for short) for providing personnel to work with the appellant and the salaries are agreed to be paid in convertible foreign currency for which the overseas company M/s. Unique raised debit notes on the appellant with details of remuneration disbursed on behalf of the appellant. It is alleged that the activity attracts service tax under the category of “Manpower Recruitment or Supply Agency Services” under Section 65(68) read with Section 65(105)(k) prior to 01.07.2012 and under the provisions of Section 65(B)(44) read with Section 65(B)(51) of the Finance Act, 1994, but did not discharge service tax on the same. Also, it reveled that the Appellant had received ‘Management Consultancy service’, ‘consulting Engineering service, etc. from the service providers outside India and also rendered Airport services in India, but failed to discharge service tax, besides they had availed inadmissible CENVAT credit on various input services, accordingly, show-cause notices have been issued to the appellant for recovery of Service Tax being recipient of the services as per Section 66(A) of the Finance Act, 1994 read with Rule 2(l) (d)(iv) of the Service Tax Rules, 1994, for rendering airport services and availing inadmissible CENVAT Credit during the relevant period with interest and penalty. The first show-cause notice was issued to them on 23.04.2010 proposing recovery of service tax on various services including ‘Manpower Supply Service’ received from the overseas company M/s. Unique and also the demanding service tax on Airport Services, inadmissible cenvat credit availed invoking extended period of limitation. Subsequent show-cause notices have been issued periodically demanding service tax on receiving ‘Manpower Supply Service’ from the overseas company. On adjudication, the demand Notices were confirmed by the Commissioner with interest and penalty, except in appeal ST/20568/2018, wherein the Commissioner (Appeals-II), passed the order upholding the Order-in-Original. The demands involved Appeal wise is tabulated as below:-

Appeal No. Period Total demand confirmed Rs. Break-up of demand confirmed Rs. Interest & Penalty
ST/2429/2011 April 2004 to March 2009 2,46,49,943 Management consultancy 41,26,163 u/s 75 u/s 76 u/s 77 u/s 78
Airport services 28,68,873
Ineligible cenvat credit 6,63,716
Manpower supply 1,69,91,194
ST/248/2012 April 2009 to March 2010 59,44,906 Ineligible cenvat credit 18,652 u/s 75 u/s 76 u/s 77
Manpower supply 59,26,254
ST/27281/2013 April 2010 to March 2011 28,95,209 Manpower supply u/s 75 u/s 76 u/s 77(2)
ST/22511/2014 April 2011 to March 2012 57,07,992 Ineligible cenvat credit 30,85,869 u/s 75 u/s 76 u/s 77(1)(a) u/s 77(2) u/s 78
Manpower supply 26,24,123
ST/21132/2016 April 2012 to March 2013 Manpower supply 29,44,814 u/s 75 u/s 76 u/s 77(1)(a) u/s 77(2)
ST/20568/2018 April 2013 to March 2016 Manpower supply 67,58,560 u/s 75 u/s 76 u/s 77(1)(a) u/s 77(2)

3. At the outset, the learned advocate for the appellant has submitted that the appellant Company was promoted by the following indigenous and overseas companies viz. (a) M/s. Siemens Project Ventures, Germany (‘SPV’), (b) M/s. Unique Zurich Airport Limited, Switzerland (UZA), (c) Larsen & Toubro Limited (L&T), (d) Airport Authority of India (AAI) and (e) Karnataka State Industrial Investment Development Corporation (KSIIDC). He has submitted that the entities at (a), (b), (c) are private promoters and (d) & € are state promoters; besides (c), (d) and (e) resident promoters and (a) & (b) are non-resident promoters.

3.1 Assailing confirmation of demand on ‘Manpower Recruitment or Supply Agency services’, he has submitted that by respective agreements with overseas company M/s. Unique, the appellant has recruited some of the employees of M/s. Unique on fulltime basis as assigned and exclusively for the service of the appellant during the assignment period. He has submitted that the terms and conditions of the Secondment Agreement in issue is quite different from the judgment delivered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in CC, CE&ST, Bangalore (Adjudication) Vs. Northern Operating Systems Pvt. Ltd. [2022(61) GSTL 129 (SC)]. Distinguishing the facts of the said case, he has submitted that the Supreme Court judgment was delivered in the context where Secondment Agreement was a warranty to the ‘Master Service Agreement’ between the assessee and the overseas group company; the assessee therein was provided with manpower only to aid the ultimate rendition of services to the overseas group company. The seconded employees were also chosen by the assessee. Thus, the Secondment Agreement was in furtherance of subsisting service provider and service recipient relationship between the assessee and the overseas group company. Thus, the employees remained entirely in the payroll of the overseas group company. In the present case, there was no separate contract of employment between expats and the assessee therein. The entire salary also was paid by the overseas company and no part of salary was paid by the assessee. In the present case, however, the appellant recruited employees from M/s. Unique for their own purpose on a principal-to-principal basis i.e. there is no underlying economic benefit in these agreements. Further the employees are also chosen by the appellant. The preamble to the ‘Expatriate Remuneration Reimbursement Agreement’ dated 01.07.2005 itself unequivocally lays down that parties to the agreement are not be considered to have rendered any services by way of assigning employees. Therefore, the facts of the present case are completely different from the facts underlying in the said decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, which is not applicable. Therefore, the service tax as confirmed by the adjudicating authority in all these appeals for supply of manpower to the appellant cannot be sustained. Alternatively, the learned advocate for the appellant has argued that in the event the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Northern Operative Systems Pvt. Ltd. (supra) is followed, then levy of interest and penalty be set aside and prayed that tax paid under reverse charge mechanism be declared as eligible to cenvat credit. In support, they have relied on the following judgments:- i. CCE&ST, Rohtak Vs. Merino Panel Products Ltd. [2022(12) TMI 453-Supreme Court] ii. Dell International Services India Pvt. Ltd. Vs. CCE&C, Bangalore [(2023 5 Centax 111 (Tri. Bang.)] iii. Uniflex Cables ltd. Vs. CCE, Surat [2011(271) ELT 161 (SC)] iv. CST, Bangalore Vs. Motor World [2012(27) STR 225 (Kar.)]

3.2 Further he has submitted that the demand of Rs.41,26,163/- confirmed by the ld. adjudicating authority under ‘Management Consultancy Services’ under Section 66A of the Finance Act, 1994 is unsustainable. Further he has submitted that the learned Commissioner analysing the scope of the definition of ‘Management Consultancy Service’ held that the appellant had paid the cost/expenses with regards to services viz. design, engineering and development of the project, air traffic study etc. 01.01.2005 to 31.03.2006; hence squarely fall within the Section 65(65) read with Section 65(105)(r) of the Finance Act, 1994. Further, he has submitted that the appellant accepting their liability under the scope of ‘Management Consultancy Services’, excluding the development cost, paid service tax of Rs.6,15,221/- for the period 2005-06. Out of this total amount of Rs.30,26,246/-(excluding development cost), Rs.6,15,221/- has been paid by them under the said service; Rs.99,144/- relates to legal consultancy received prior to 18.4.2006 and Rs.1,48,285/- for the period after 18.4.2006. It is his contention that legal service became taxable only from 01.9.2009, hence, not sustainable. It is his contention that Section 66A was inserted w.e.f. 18/04/2006, and therefore, demands prior to that date are unconstitutional as held by the Hon’ble Bombay High Court in the case of Indian National Shipowners Association [2009(13) STR 235 (Bom.)] and affirmed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in 2010(17) STR J57 (SC). Further, he has submitted that the amount of Rs.17,15,138/- confirmed under the above category of Management Consultancy (development cost), payment to promoters for setting up the Airport and make it operational, for the period prior to 18.4.2006 is prior to introduction of 66A and hence covered by the judgement in Indian National Shipowners Association’s case(supra).

3.3 He has also submitted that the amount of 21,63,596/- relates employee salary relating to costs and bonus paid to UZA as reimbursement. paid by them are reimbursable expenses at actuals; hence covered by the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of UOI Vs. Intercontinental Consultants and Technocrats Pvt. Ltd. [2018(10) GSTL 401 (SC)] for the period prior to 14.05.2015. Therefore, the demand on this count is also not sustainable.

3.4 On the issue of admissibility of CENVAT Credit in appeal No.ST/2429/2011 and ST/248/2012 and ST/22511/2014, the learned advocate has submitted that the services received is in the nature of input services viz. Business Auxiliary Service (Sodexo passes for employees), photography and videography services, Public relation agency service etc) are square covered by the judgement of the Tribunal in the case of JSW Steel Ltd. Vs. CCE [2021(121) TMI 381 – CESTAT Bangalore].

3.5 Further, he has submitted that the airport services rendered by the appellant during the relevant period are in the nature of services to development / running of airport. Out of the total demand of Rs.78,87,102/-, the appellant had already discharged service tax of Rs.50,18,229/- where the amount has been collected from the successful bidders who, after being successful in the bid, rendered services to the appellant after issue of the work order.

3.6. However, it is also submitted that on the refund of the amount collected from unsuccessful bidders, the learned Commissioner analysing the scope of services held that there was no evidence placed by the appellant to substantiate their claim that the amount received from the unsuccessful bidders were not connected with airport services; hence confirmed the demand of Rs.26,68,873/- against the category of airport services. The said observation of the Ld. Commissioner is erroneous as no service was rendered by the unsuccessful bidders and received by the Appellant.

3.7. He has also submitted that the credit of Rs.6,63,716/- availed on various services which do not fall under the scope of definition of input service under Rule 2(l) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004; therefore, rightly confirmed by the learned Commissioner.

3.8. Learned advocate, further assailing the confirmation of demand on Airport Services’ relating to tender fee collected and retained, has submitted that the tender fee is collected from the contractors who seek to bid/tender for specific work/projects that are awarded by the appellant. The purpose for collection of tender fees are: (a) to ensure genuineness of contractors and (ii) to meet tender expenses. Therefore, these collections are not towards provision of any service but collected qua ‘invitation for invitation for offer’ and not the offer itself. Therefore, there is no service tax liability on these collections.

3.9. Further, it is submitted that the appellant collected the said fees for providing tender documents to bidders which ultimately enables them to express interest and participate in the tender. The appellant had paid VAT against these costs and hence service tax is not payable on the said fees. In support, they have referred to the decision in the case of UFO Moviez India Ltd. Vs. Commissioner [2017 (9) TMI 507 – CESTAT Mumbai]; which was later upheld by the Hon’ble Supreme, wherein it has been held that once VAT is paid, question of demanding service tax on the same transaction does not arise. Further, they have submitted that the show-cause notice dated 23.04.2010 in appeal No.ST/2429/2011 has been issued invoking extended period, which cannot be sustained except for the normal period from October 2008 to March 2009, as there was no suppression of fact and the issues involved are pure questions of interpretation of law. Also, they have submitted that since the issue involved is interpretation of question of law, interest and penalty cannot be levied on the appellant.

4. The Learned Authorized Representative for the Revenue, reiterating the respective impugned orders, has submitted that the assigned employees have been deputed by M/s. Unique under ‘Expatriate Remuneration Reimbursement Agreement’ and it is evident from record that such employees do not cease to be employees of the overseas company during the period of assignment. These employees are rendering services on the request of the appellant and against such assignment; the appellant pays M/s. Unique which is in the nature of international assignee, costs and other remuneration to the assigned employees. Therefore, the activity is in the nature of ‘Manpower Recruitment and Supply service’ prior to 2012 and post-2012, ‘service’ as defined under Section 65B(44) of the Finance Act, 1994. He has submitted that the agreement / contract under which M/s. Unique has assigned its employees is more or less similar to the Secondment Agreement considered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of CC,CE&ST, Bangalore (Adjudication) Vs. Northern Operating Systems Pvt. Ltd. (supra) and the principle laid down in the said case is squarely applicable to the facts of the present case. Therefore, the demand is rightly confirmed by the adjudicating authority on this count. He has fairly accepted that in view of the judgement of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Northern Operating Systems Pvt. Ltd. (supra), the invocation of larger period of limitation cannot be sustained.

4.1. The Ld. Authorized Representative appearing for the Revenue has submitted that the Ld. Commissioner also confirmed the demand on ‘Management Consultancy Services’ and ‘Airport Services’ for the period from April 2004 to March 2009.

4.2. Supporting the finding of the Ld. Commissioner, he has submitted that during the period in question, the appellant had received services in relation to design, engineering and development of projects, air traffic studies, design studies, etc., which squarely fall within the scope of the definition of ‘Management Consultancy Service’ and also the definition of the taxable service as prescribed under Section 65(105)(r) of the Finance Act, 1994. Therefore, it is contended that the services with regard to development of airport, being provided as per the shareholder’s agreement and the appellant having discharged the payments in foreign currency for all the expenses incurred with regard to design, engineering and development of project, the same are to be considered as “consideration” paid by the appellant for the services rendered by the overseas company; therefore, the said services squarely fall under the concept of ‘gross value’ as defined under Section 67 of the Finance Act, 1994, which was in existence even prior to 18.04.2006. It is also submitted that inclusion of various charges / expenses like hotel charges, telephone charges, travelling expenses, etc., in the gross value made effective from 19.04.2006 read with Rule 5 of the Service Tax (Determination of Value) Rules, 2006, are in the nature of basic primary expenses incurred in the course of provision of services and hence the same are taxable even prior to 19.04.2006. He has submitted that these expenses are to be treated as “consideration” paid for receiving Management Consultancy Services and consequently, the Service Tax of Rs.17,15,138/- on the developmental cost received by the appellant during the period from 01.01.2005 to 31.03.2006 is correctly chargeable to Service Tax.

4.3. Further, he has submitted that out of the Service Tax demand of Rs.30,26,246/-, the appellant has already accepted Rs.6,15,221/-, payable under ‘Management Consultancy Service’ and the actual demand of Rs.24,11,025/- is also chargeable under Management Consultancy Service for the period 2005-06 to 2008-09 to Service Tax, being the amount paid on receipt of legal services which are in the nature of due diligence report prepared by the overseas legal consultants and squarely covered vide the Order No. 1/1/2001/ST dated 27.06.2001 issued by the Ministry under Section 37B.

4.4. Further, supporting the order of the Ld. Commissioner for confirmation of demand under Airport Services, he has submitted that the tender fee / pre-award costs collected is in the nature of advance for providing the said services and to be treated as the amount collected for providing Airport Services. Therefore, it is contended that with regard to the total amount of Rs.2,03,19,923/- received from various unsuccessful bidders that, in the absence of documentary evidence to prove that the said amount relates to unsuccessful bidders, the same is correctly held to be leviable to Service Tax of Rs.28,68,873/- under ‘Airport Services’.

5. Heard both sides and perused the records.

6. The issues involved in the present appeals for consideration are whether:

(i) the appellant is required to discharge service tax under reverse charge mechanism for services received under the category of ‘Management Consultancy Services”, ‘Manpower Supply Agency Service’ during the relevant period involved in each of the appeal in the light of the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of CC, CE&ST, Bangalore (Adjudication) Vs. Northern Operating Systems Pvt. Ltd.;

(ii) service tax is leviable under airport services (Appeal No.ST/2429/2011) on the deposit amount collected from unsuccessful bidders;

(iii) cenvat credit is admissible on various input services;

(iv) extended period of limitation is invokable in appeal No.ST/2429/2011; and interest and penalty are leviable on the appellant.

7. To analyse the first issue, that is, whether manpower service supplied by M/s. Unique to the appellant, is leviable to service tax under reverse charge basis, for the period in question, it is necessary to examine whether the ratio of the judgment in the case of CC,CE&ST, Bangalore (Adjudication) Vs. Northern Operating Systems Pvt. Ltd. (supra) is applicable to the facts and circumstances of the present case. It is the Revenue’s argument that the judgment is squarely applicable to the present case; whereas the advocate for the appellant has submitted that the circumstances of the secondment agreement considered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court is different from the present one; hence not applicable.

8. Reading the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, it is clear that in para 3, the nature and content of the agreement has been narrated which reads as follows:-

3. The nature and contents of the agreements, are discernible in their description, extracted from the impugned order – where the assessee has been referred to as “the appellant” by the CESTAT – which is as follows:

“The relevant terms of the agreement to understand the activity are as follows:

(a) When required Appellants requests the group companies for managerial and technical personnel to assist in its business and accordingly the employees are selected by the group company and they would be transferred to Appellants.

(b) The employees shall act in accordance with the instructions and directions of Appellants. The employees would devote their entire time and work to the employer seconded to.

(c) The seconded employees would continue to be on the payroll of the group company (foreign entity) for the purpose of continuation of social security/retirement benefits, but for all practical purposes, Appellants shall be the employer. During the term of transfer or secondment the personnel shall be the employee of Appellants. Appellants issue an employment letter to the seconded personnel stipulating all the terms of the employment.

(d) The employees so seconded would receive their salary, bonus, social benefits, out of pocket expenses and other expenses from the group company.

(e) The group company shall raise a debit note on Appellants to recover the expenses of salary, bonus etc. and the Appellants shall reimburse the group company for all these expenses and there shall be no mark-up on such reimbursement.”

As a matter of fact, the assessee issues the prescribed forms to the seconded employees, in terms of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (hereafter “IT Act”). Those individuals too file income-tax returns and contribute to the provident fund. Furthermore, NOS remits the above amounts in foreign exchange, which are reflected in its financial statements. The assessee is reimbursed (by the foreign entity, Northern Trust Company – hereafter described as such) for the amounts it pays as salaries, to these seconded employees. The assessee pays for certain services received from the group companies. The assessee used to discharge service tax on payments for such services in terms of Section 66A of the Act. The appropriate major expense heads were ‘Salaries & Allowances’, ‘Relocation expenses’, ‘Consultancy Charges’, ‘Communication Expenses’ and ‘Computer Maintenance and repairs.’

9. The terms and conditions relevant to the present case, extracted from the agreement dated 11.07.2005 to examine the rival claims, are as below:-

EXPATRIATE REMUNERATION REIMBURSEMENT AGREEMENT

THIS AGREEMENT is entered on July 11th, 2005 by and between Bangalore Internation Airport Ltd., a company organized and existing under the laws of India and located at Khanija Bhavan, Ground Floor, #49, Race Course Road, Bangalore 560 001 (hereinafter referred to as ‘BIAL’) and Unique (Flughafen Zurich AG), a corporation established under the laws of Switzerland and located CH-8058 Zurich-Flughafen (hereinafter referred to as “Unique”).

WHEREAS BIAL is engaged in the business of Developing the construction and operation of the airport at Devenahalli, Bangalore.

WHEREAS BIAL desires to recruit some of the employees of Unique whose particulars are as set out in Schedule 1 attached hereto and as amended from time to time, (each hereinafter referred to as the ‘Assignee’) on a full time basis as assignees to work exclusively for BIAL during the assignment period. WHEREAS Unique has accepted the specific request made by BIAL for assigning the Assignee to work exclusively for BIAL during the assignment period; WHEREAS the Assignee is agreeable to such arrangement whereby he will work exclusively for BIAL, during the assignment period;

WHEREAS it is expressly understood and agreed upon by and between the Parties to this Agreement that Unique shall not be considered to have rendered any services, whatsoever, to BIAL by the assignment of the Assignee to BIAL and that Unique shall not be held responsible for any acts or omissions of the Assignee during the Assignees assignment with BIAL;

WHEREAS BIAL expressly acknowledges and agrees that the Assignee would not have any authority whatsoever to act on behalf of or bind Unique in connection with his duties towards BIAL and further that the Assignee would have no express or implied authority whatsoever to act for or represent or bind Unique;

WHEREAS during the period of the Assignee’s term with BIAL, it is understood and agreed between the Parties to this Agreement that in addition to any local currency remuneration paid to the Assignee directly by BIAL, the Assignee would be entitled to remuneration in foreign currency delivered to him outside of India, by Unique (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Foreign Currency Remuneration’);

WHEREAS the Foreign Currency Remuneration shall be made out of the items listed in Schedule of this Agreement;

WHEREAS it is expressly understood and agreed upon by the parties to this Agreement that BIAL will bear the Foreign Currency Remuneration of the Assignee paid by Unique and also the amount of any taxes payable thereon to the Indian Income Tax Authorities; and

WHEREAS it is understood and agreed by the Parties that BIAL will promptly reimburse to Unique such Foreign Currency Remuneration being paid by Unique and from the Effective Date (as hereinafter defined) in accordance with the terms and conditions herein

1.0 … ….

2.0 … …

3.0 Reimbursement of the Foreign Currency Remuneration.

3.1. In consideration for the assignment services to be provided by the Assignee of Unique to BIAL during the period commencing as set out in Schedule 1, BIAL agrees to reimburse Unique for the Foreign Currency Remuneration made by Unique to the Assignee subject to any requisite approval of the Government of India / Reserve Bank of India.

3.2. The Foreign Currency Remuneration paid by Unique to the Assignee shall be reimbursed by BIAL on a cost to cost basis.

3.3. Unique shall quarterly send to BIAL Debit Notes for the reimbursement of the Foreign Currency Remuneration paid by it to the Assignee and BIAL agrees to pay the notes within 30 days of receipt.

3.4. The Foreign Currency Remuneration reimbursable by BIASL to Unique under this Agreement shall be net of any withholding or other applicable taxes which shall be the sole responsibility of and borne by BIAL.

3.5. It is hereby expressly agreed that all payments / reimbursements described in this clause to be made by BIAL to Unique are subject to full compliance of all applicable legislation in India more specifically but not limited to the obtaining of necessary approvals if any required from the Reserve Bank of India / The Indian Income Tax Authorities as per applicable regulations in this regard as may exist from time to time.

4.0 Instructions and supervision

It is the parties clear understanding that during the assignment of the Assignee to BIAL that the overall responsibility regarding instructions and supervision of the Assignee remains with BIAL ………………………………………………………………………………………

SCHEDULE 1

Particulars of Assignees and Term of Assignment

S.No. Person Estimated period of assignment in India Appropriate start and finish dates
1. Albert Brunner 6½ years April 1, 2002 till September 30,2008
2. Stephan Widrig, COO 3 ¼ years July 1, 2005 till September 2008

SCHEDULE 2 Foreign Currency Remuneration

S.No. Person Remuneration item Amount
1. Albert Brunner CEO Basic salary Social security including pension contribution Administration and Overhead and Tax Performance Bonus CHF 149’006.gross salary minus social security, pension and insurance contributions. Approx. 24.9% of gross salary and performance bonus 13% of Basic salary and Social security. Maximum 108’357 of gross salary
2. Stephan Widrig, CCO Basic salary Social security including pension contribution Administration and Overhead and Tax Performance Bonus CHF 92’400 gross salary minus social security, pension and insurance contributions. Approx. 24.9% of gross salary and performance bonus 13% of Basic salary and Social security. Maximum 67’200 of gross salary

10. In the ‘Expatriate Remuneration Reimbursement Agreement’ dated 11.7.2005 between the appellant and M/s. Unique reveals that the terms and conditions are more or less similar to the one referred to in para 3 of the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Northern Operating Systems Pvt. Ltd. (supra). In the present case also, the appellant was in need of personnel for facilitating the business operations in India and the overseas company, which has such personnel, who possesses the requisite qualification and skill desired to employ such persons on exclusive basis and the overseas company has duly consented to depute such personnel. The deputed personnel while under employment with the appellant was not in any way subjected to any kind of instruction or control or direction or supervision of the overseas company and they would report only to appellant’s management. They function solely under the control, direction and supervision of appellant and in accordance with the policy, rules, guidelines applicable to the employees of the appellant. The appellant shall have the sole right to take punitive steps against misconduct, negligence, fraud or unsatisfactory performance of work by the dispatched personnel during employment with the appellant company and also have the right to terminate the employment. The remuneration to be paid by the appellant to dispatched personnel as laid down at Schedule 2 comprising of Monthly salary in India; Monthly Salary in Switzerland; Bonus in Switzerland and any other allowance paid / cost incurred for the dispatched personnel during the employment period. Further it is agreed that in respect of monthly salary in India and monthly salary in Switzerland and bonus in Switzerland on the request of the dispatched personnel as his home country is Switzerland and for administrative convenience, appellant company to request overseas company to make such payments in Switzerland which shall be reimbursed by the appellant on actual cost basis. It is also stipulated that such arrangement in no manner be considered as employer-employee relationship between the overseas company and the dispatched personnel.

11. In the sample ‘Expatriate Remuneration Reimbursement Agreement’, the dispatched personnel agree with all the conditions settled between the appellant and the overseas company under the sample ‘Expatriate Remuneration Reimbursement Agreement’.

12. A careful reading of the sample ‘Expatriate Remuneration Reimbursement Agreement’ and also the contract of the employment, letter of employment etc., we do not find any substantial difference from the facts stated in the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in Northern Operating Systems Pvt. Ltd.’s case. After analysing the secondment agreement, their Lordships observed as follows:-

48. The task of this Court, therefore is to, upon an overall reading of the materials presented by the parties, discern the true nature of the relationship between the seconded employees and the assessee, and the nature of the service provided – in that context – by the overseas group company to the assessee.

49. A co-joint reading of the documents on record show that:

(i) Attachment 1 to the service agreement ensures that the overseas group company assigns, inter alia, certain tasks to the assessee, including back office operations of a certain kind, in relation to its activities, or that of other group companies or entities;

(ii) The assessee is paid a mark up of 15% of the overall expenditure it incurs, by the overseas company (clause 2, read with attachment 1 of the Service Agreement);

(iii) By the Secondment Agreement, the parties agree that the overseas employee is temporarily loaned to the assessee (Article I read with the Schedule);

(iv) During the period of secondment, the assessee has control over the employee, i.e. it can require the seconded employee to return, and likewise, the employee has the discretion to terminate the relationship (Article II);

(v) The overseas employer (group company) pays the seconded employee, which is reimbursed to the overseas company, by the assessee (Article III);

(vi) The assessee is responsible for the work of the seconded employee, i.e., the overseas employer, during the secondment period, is absolved of any liability for the job or work of its seconded employees (Article VII);

(vii) The secondment is for a specified duration, and the employment with the assessee ceases upon the expiration of that period (Article II of the secondment agreement and the “Duration” clause in the letter of understanding with the seconded employee);

(viii) The letter of understanding issued to the seconded employee specifies that the tenure with the assessee is an assignment (in one place, the term used is “At its conclusion, repatriation will be in accordance with the Global Mobility Repatriation Policy”);

(ix) The terms include the salary payable as well as other allowances, such as hardship allowance, vehicle allowance, servant allowance, paid leave, housing allowance, etc. The nature of salary and other perks underscore the fact that the seconded employees are of a certain skill and possess the expertise, which the assessee requires.

50. The above features show that the assessee had operational or functional control over the seconded employees; it was potentially liable for the performance of the tasks assigned to them. That it paid (through reimbursement) the amounts equivalent to the salaries of the seconded employees – because of the obligation of the overseas employer to maintain them on its payroll, has two consequences: one, that the seconded employees continued on the rolls of the overseas employer; two, since they were not performing jobs in relation to that employer’s business, but that of the assessee, the latter had to ultimately bear the burden. There is nothing unusual in this arrangement, given that the seconded employees were performing the tasks relating to the assessee’s activities and not in relation to the overseas employer. To put it differently, it would be unnatural to expect the overseas employer to not seek reimbursement of the employees’ salaries, since they were, for the duration of secondment, not performing tasks in relation to its activities or business.

51. As discussed previously, there is not one single determinative factor, which the courts give primacy to, while deciding whether an arrangement is a contract of service (as the assessee asserts the arrangement to be) or a contract for service. The general drift of cases which have been decided, are in the context of facts, where the employer usually argues that the person claiming to be the employee is an intermediary. This Court has consistently applied one test: substance over form, requiring a close look at the terms of the contract, or the agreements.

52. A vital fact which is to be considered in this case, is that the nature of the overseas group companies business appears to be to secure contracts, which can be performed by its highly trained and skilled personnel. This business is providing certain specialized services (back office, IT, bank related services, inventories, etc.). Taking advantage of the globalized economy, and having regard to locational advantages, the overseas group company enters into agreements with its affiliates or local companies, such as the assessee. The role of the assessee is to optimize the economic edge (be it manpower or other resources availability) to perform the specific tasks given it, by the overseas company. As part of this agreement, a secondment contract is entered into, whereby the overseas company’s employee or employees, possessing the specific required skill, are deployed for the duration the task is estimated to be completed in. This Court is not concerned with unravelling the nature of relationship between the overseas company and the assessee. However, what it has to decide, is whether the secondment, for the purpose of completion of the assessee’s job, amounts to manpower supply.

53. Facially, or to put it differently, for all appearances, the seconded employee, for the duration of her or his secondment, is under the control of the assessee, and works under its direction. Yet, the fact remains that they are on the pay rolls of their overseas employer. What is left unsaid – and perhaps crucial, is that this is a legal requirement, since they are entitled to social security benefits in the country of their origin. It is doubtful whether without the comfort of this assurance, they would agree to the secondment. Furthermore, the reality is that the secondment is a part of the global policy – of the overseas employer loaning their services, on temporary basis. On the cessation of the secondment period, they have to be repatriated in accordance with a global repatriation policy (of the overseas entity).

54. The letter of understanding between the assessee and the seconded employee nowhere states that the latter would be treated as the former’s employees after the seconded period (which is usually 12-18 months). On the contrary, they revert to their overseas employer and may in fact, be sent elsewhere on secondment. The salary package, with allowances, etc., are all expressed in foreign currency (e.g., US $ 330,000/- per annum in the letter produced before Court, extracted above). Furthermore, the allowances include a separate hardship allowance of 20% of the basic salary for working in India. The monthly housing allowance in the specific case was ` 3,66,700. In addition, an annual utility allowance of ` 3,97,500/- is also assured. These are substantial amounts, and could have been only by resorting to a standardized policy, of the overseas employer.

55. The overall effect of the four agreements entered into by the assessee, at various periods, with NTS or other group companies, clearly points to the fact that the overseas company has a pool of highly skilled employees, who are entitled to a certain salary structure – as well as social security benefits. These employees, having regard to their expertise and specialization, are seconded (a term synonymous with the commonly used term in India, deputation) to the concerned local municipal entity (in this case, the assessee) for the use of their skills. Upon the cessation of the term of secondment, they return to their overseas employer, or are deployed on some other secondment.

56. This Court, upon a review of the previous judgment in Sushilaben Indravadan (supra) held that there no one single determinative test, but that what is applicable is “a conglomerate of all applicable tests taken on the totality of the fact situation in a given case that would ultimately yield, particularly in a complex hybrid situation, whether the contract to be construed is a contract of service or a contract for service. Depending on the fact situation of each case, all the aforesaid factors would not necessarily be relevant, or, if relevant, be given the same weight.”

57. Taking a cue from the above observations, while the control (over performance of the seconded employees’ work) and the right to ask them to return, if their functioning is not as is desired, is with the assessee, the fact remains that their overseas employer in relation to its business, deploys them to the assessee, on secondment. Secondly, the overseas employer – for whatever reason, pays them their salaries. Their terms of employment – even during the secondment – are in accord with the policy of the overseas company, who is their employer. Upon the end of the period of secondment, they return to their original places, to await deployment or extension of secondment.

58. One of the arguments of the assessee was that arguendo, the arrangement was “manpower supply” (under the unamended Act) and a service [(not falling within exclusion (b) to Section 65(44)] yet it was not required to pay any consideration to the overseas group company. The mere payment in the form of remittances or amounts, by whatever manner, either for the duration of the secondment, or per employee seconded, is just one method of reckoning if there is consideration. The other way of looking at the arrangement is the economic benefit derived by the assessee, which also secures specific jobs or assignments, from the overseas group companies, which result in its revenues. The quid pro quo for the secondment agreement, where the assessee has the benefit of experts for limited periods, is implicit in the overall scheme of things.

59. As regards the question of revenue neutrality is concerned, the assessee’s principal contention was that assuming it is liable, on reverse charge basis, nevertheless, it would be entitled to refund; it is noticeable that the two orders relied on by it (in SRF and Coca Cola) by this Court, merely affirmed the rulings of the CESTAT, without any independent reasoning. Their precedential value is of a limited nature. This Court has been, in the present case, called upon to adjudicate about the nature of the transaction, and whether the incidence of service tax arises by virtue of provision of secondment services. That a particular rate of tax – or no tax, is payable, or that if and when liability arises, the assessee, can through a certain existing arrangement, claim the whole or part of the duty as refund, is an irrelevant detail. The incidence of taxation, is entirely removed from whether, when and to what extent, Parliament chooses to recover the amount.

60. This Court is also of the view, for similar reasons, that the orders of the CESTAT, affirmed by this Court, in Volkswagen and Computer Sciences Corporation, are unreasoned and of no precedential value.

61. In view of the above discussion, it is held that the assessee was, for the relevant period, service recipient of the overseas group company concerned, which can be said to have provided manpower supply service, or a taxable service, for the two different periods in question (in relation to which show cause notices were issued).

13. Applying the aforesaid principle to the present case we are of the opinion that service tax is applicable on the amount paid to M/s Unique for receiving Manpower service by the Appellant. However, the demand of service tax confirmed by the Ld. Commissioner cannot be sustained for the period prior to 18.4.2006 and also for the extended period as their Lordships on the issue of invocation of extended period of limitation, decided in favour of the assessee. Consequently, the demand be restricted to normal period of limitation in appeal No.ST/2429/2011.

14. Resisting the demand confirmed in the impugned Order under the taxable category of ‘Management Consultancy Services’ (ST/2429/2011), for the period April 2004 to March 2009 amounting to Rs.41,26,163/-, it is submitted that the demand pertaining to the period prior to 18/04/2006 cannot be sustained in any case in view of the judgment of the Hon’ble High Court of Bombay in the case of Indian National Shipowners Association (supra) and upheld subsequently by the Hon’ble Supreme Court. For the demands raised on account of said services post 18.04.2006, it is argued that these are in the nature of reimbursable expenses; hence cannot be sustained in view of the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of UOI Vs. Intercontinental Consultants and Technocrats Pvt. Ltd. (supra) prior to 14/05/2015.

15. We find that a total amount of Rs.41,26,163/- has been confirmed under this category ‘Management Consultancy Services’ (ST/2429/2011). Also, as submitted on behalf of the appellant an amount of Rs.17,15,138/- pertained to the period prior to 18.04.2006 and covered by the judgement of the Hon’ble High Court of Bombay in the case of Indian National Shipowners Association v. Union of India [2009 (13) S.T.R. 235 (Bom.)] which has been affirmed by the Hon’ble Apex Court, and therefore, the demand is bad in law and cannot be sustained. From the remaining confirmed amount of Rs.24,11,025/-, Rs.1,48,285/- relates to legal consultancy charges received after 18.04.2006 and Rs.21,63,596/- relates to reimbursable expenses. The Ld. Advocate for the appellant vehemently argued that reimbursable expenses under Rule 5 of the Service Tax (Determination of Value) Rules, 2006, could not be included in the gross tax value prior to 14.05.2015 in view of the decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Union of India v. M/s. Intercontinental Consultants and Technocrats Pvt. Ltd. [2018 (10) G.S.T.L. 401 (S.C.)]. The demand for the period prior to 18.4.2006 cannot be sustained. On the issue of reimbursable expenses, we find that the Ld. Commissioner has not recorded any specific finding about the true nature of the said expenses as claimed by the appellant and hence, the matter needs to be remanded to the Ld. Commissioner, to verify the said claim of the appellant and decide the issue in the light of the principle laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in Intercontinental Consultants and Technocrats Pvt. Ltd. case(supra).

16. On the confirmation of demand relating to Airport Services rendered by the appellant during the relevant period i.e., 2005-06 to 2008-09, an amount of Rs.28,68,873/- has been confirmed by the ld. adjudicating authority, which is in dispute before us. The Ld. Advocate for the appellant has vehemently argued that the said Service Tax amount relates to the amount collected from unsuccessful bidders who participated in the tender process floated by the appellant in connection with various services like cargo handling, aviation fuel facility, ground handling, flight catering, etc., in the course of providing Airport Services; the said deposit amount has been collected from the persons who participated in the tender and is for the purpose of discouraging non-serious participants. The amounts so collected and retained by the appellant are in no way connected to the rendering of Airport Services as there is no relationship of service receiver and service provider between the appellant and the unsuccessful bidders. Therefore, it is argued that the confirmation of demand by the ld. adjudicating authority is incorrect.

17. We find merit in principle in the contention of the Ld. Advocate for the appellant that the Revenue could not establish that the unsuccessful bidders have rendered any services to the appellant and thus, the amount collected as a pre-bid offer from unsuccessful bidders cannot be considered as a “consideration” for rendering Airport Services and accordingly not leviable to Service Tax. However, we find that the Ld. Commissioner has confirmed the demand on altogether a different ground. He has held that except submitting list of unsuccessful bidders, no documentary evidence has been placed on record to prove that the said amounts relate to unsuccessful bidders and consequently, he has confirmed the demand. Therefore, to ascertain this fact, we are of the view that this issue needs to be remanded to the adjudicating authority.

18. On the issue of availing CENVAT Credit on various input services namely, photography and videography services, asset hiring, landscaping services, office rent, civil and interior work, etc., the appellant has argued that these services are held to be ‘input services’ and duty paid is admissible to credit by this Tribunal in the case of JSW Steel Ltd. Vs. CCE [2021(121) TMI 381 – CESTAT Bangalore]. We find that all these services have been considered by the Tribunal in the aforesaid judgement and held that the same satisfy the definition of “input service” as prescribed under Rule 2(l) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004, hence, duty paid on these services is admissible to credit. Following the said precedent, we are of the opinion that CENVAT credit of the duty paid on these services is admissible.

19. We also find that the issues involved in the present appeals relate to interpretation of law and no fact has been concealed or suppressed from the knowledge of the Department. Therefore, levy of penalty on the appellants cannot be sustained.

20. Thus, our findings and directions are summarized as below: –

(1) The demands relating to the period prior to 18.04.2006, for all categories of services received from the overseas company cannot be sustained;

(2) The demands with interest confirmed on ‘Manpower Supply Services’ received from the overseas company for the period after 18.4.2006, under reverse charge mechanism are sustained for the normal period of limitation only;

(3) The applicability of Service Tax on the amount collected from unsuccessful bidders as pre-bid fees and retained is not liable to service tax under Airport Services. However, the adjudicating authority is directed to verify from the records whether the disputed amount relates to unsuccessful bidders only, as claimed by the Appellant.

(4) The CENVAT Credit availed on various input services are admissible and hence demands on this issue are set aside;

(5) The penalty imposed on the Appellant cannot be sustained.

21. Consequently, all these appeals are remanded to the adjudicating authority to recompute the demands with interest in the light of above observation. Appeals are disposed of accordingly.

(Order pronounced in the open court on 09.07.2024)

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Sandeep Kanoi
Qualification: Graduate, CA in Job / Business, DD
Company: Taxguru Consultancy
Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra
Articles Published: 24,582

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.