Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Goods and Services Tax

GST Refund Under Section 54: Two-Year Limitation and Refunds Outside the Act

Summary: Section 54 of the CGST Act, 2017 establishes the statutory framework for refund of tax, interest and other amounts, ordinarily requiring applications within two years from the relevant date. However, an important judicial distinction has emerged between tax lawfully leviable but wrongly paid and amounts collected without authority of law. While the Karnataka High Court has treated the statutory limitation as mandatory for refund officers, several High Courts have permitted claims beyond that period where GST was paid on exempt or non-taxable transactions or under an invalid levy. The Supreme Court’s decisions in Mafatlal Industries, BLA Infrastructure and Torrent Power provide important guidance on statutory remedies, appellate pre-deposits and unjust enrichment. This article examines the different relevant dates prescribed under Section 54, special refund procedures, judicial interpretations of limitation, the constitutional protection under Article 265 and the circumstances in which writ jurisdiction may provide relief. It also explains why establishing that the tax burden was not passed on remains crucial, even where a refund is sought outside the ordinary statutory mechanism.

Refund Under GST: What Section 54 Governs and What Lies Outside It

Advertisement

1. Introduction

The refund provision of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 is short in words and long in consequence. Section 54(1) allows a person to claim refund of “any tax and interest, if any, paid on such tax or any other amount paid by him” before the expiry of two years from the relevant date. Every refund officer reads the two years first. The question that keeps returning to the High Courts is whether every rupee that reaches the Government through the GST portal is “tax” for this purpose, or whether some of it is money the State had no right to receive at all, which Section 54 never set out to govern.

The question is no longer academic. In the first months of 2026, the Supreme Court decided two refund matters that bear on the reach of Section 54; the Karnataka High Court, sitting in a Division Bench, held the two years to be mandatory for the proper officer, and several other High Courts have held that the period does not touch an amount that was never leviable. This article sets out the statutory scheme, the refunds that the Act itself governs, the line of authority that places certain amounts outside it, and the principle on which the two can be reconciled.

2. The Words of Section 54(1)

Four expressions in the sub-section carry the weight of the controversy.

(a) “Tax”. The section is headed “Refund of tax”, and the claim it contemplates is a claim to refund of tax and of interest paid on such tax.

(b) “Any other amount paid by him”. The Revenue reads these words as bringing every deposit, of whatever character, within the section and therefore within its limitation.

(c) “May make an application”. Some High Courts have read “may” as making the time limit directory. Others read the word only as conferring the right to apply, the period itself being fixed.

(d) “Before the expiry of two years from the relevant date”. The period does not run from one fixed event. Explanation 2 fixes the relevant date differently for each kind of refund.

The rest of the section supplies the machinery. Sub-section (3) governs refund of unutilised input tax credit. Sub-section (5) directs that the amount found refundable shall be credited to the Consumer Welfare Fund under Section 57, and sub-section (8) lists the cases in which it is paid to the applicant instead, clause (e) being the case where the applicant has not passed on the incidence of the tax and interest to any other person. Sub-sections (10) and (11) permit withholding and adjustment. Section 56 provides interest on delayed refund at six per cent, and at a rate up to nine per cent where the claim arises from an order of an adjudicating authority, Appellate Authority, Appellate Tribunal or court which has attained finality and the amount is not refunded within sixty days of the application filed in consequence of that order.

3. Refunds That the Act Governs, and the Relevant Date for Each

Explanation 2 to Section 54 fixes the relevant date as under:

1. Clause (a), export of goods: where exported by sea or air, the date on which the ship or aircraft in which the goods are loaded leaves India; by land, the date on which the goods pass the frontier; by post, the date of despatch of the goods by the Post Office concerned to a place outside India.

2. Clause (b), supplies regarded as deemed exports: the date on which the return relating to such deemed exports is furnished.

3. Clause (ba), zero rated supply to a Special Economic Zone developer or unit, where refund is available on the supply itself or on the inputs or input services used in it: the due date for furnishing the return under Section 39 for such supplies.

4. Clause (c), export of services: the date of receipt of payment in convertible foreign exchange, or in Indian rupees wherever permitted by the Reserve Bank of India, where the supply was completed before receipt of payment; and the date of issue of the invoice where payment was received in advance.

5. Clause (d), tax refundable as a consequence of a judgment, decree, order or direction of the Appellate Authority, Appellate Tribunal or any court: the date of communication of that judgment, decree, order or direction.

6. Clause (e), unutilised input tax credit under clause (ii) of the first proviso to sub-section (3): the due date for furnishing the return under Section 39 for the period in which the claim arises.

7. Clause (f), tax paid provisionally: the date of adjustment of tax after final assessment.

8. Clause (g), a person other than the supplier: the date of receipt of the goods or services by that person.

9. Clause (h), any other case: the date of payment of tax.

Read with these dates, the claims that sit comfortably inside Section 54 are the following: refund of tax paid on exports and zero rated supplies; refund of accumulated credit on account of exports without payment of tax or an inverted duty structure; refund of the balance in the electronic cash ledger, which Section 49(6) itself sends to Section 54; refund to specialised agencies of the United Nations, embassies and other notified persons under Sections 54(2) and 55, within two years from the last day of the quarter in which the supply was received; refund of tax paid in excess over a liability that did exist, which falls under the residuary clause (h); and refund that becomes due when an appellate authority, the Tribunal or a court sets aside a demand, where clause (d) starts the clock only from the communication of that order, however old the original payment may be.

4. Periods and Remedies the Act Fixes Separately

Three situations, though connected with refund, are governed by their own rules.

(a) Tax Paid Under the Wrong Head

Where integrated tax was paid on a supply later held to be intra-State, or central and State tax was paid on a supply later held to be inter-State, Section 77 provides for refund of the tax wrongly paid. Rule 89(1A), inserted with effect from 24.09.2021, allows the application within two years from the date of payment of tax under the correct head, and where that payment was made before the rule came in, within two years from 24.09.2021.

(b) The Pandemic Period

Notification No. 13/2022-Central Tax dated 05.07.2022 excludes the period from 01.03.2020 to 28.02.2022 in computing the period for filing refund applications under Sections 54 and 55. The Allahabad High Court in Arvind Kumar Agarwal v. State of U.P., Writ Tax No. 4179 of 2025, decided on 25.02.2026, quashed deficiency memos rejecting refund applications for 2018-19 and 2019-20 solely for delay while ignoring the exclusion directed by the Supreme Court, and remitted the matter for a reasoned order after hearing.

(c) Pre-Deposit for Appeal

In State of Jharkhand v. BLA Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd., 2026 LLBiz SC 5, the Supreme Court held that refund of the mandatory pre-deposit flows from the appellate mechanism itself, under Section 107(6) read with Section 115, and not from the general refund provision. The Court upheld the direction to refund the deposit with interest, but set aside the reasoning of the Jharkhand High Court on Section 54 as unnecessary. The judgment matters for a wider reason: the Supreme Court has itself recognised that not every amount which goes back to a taxpayer is a refund under Section 54.

5. Is the Two-Year Period Mandatory?

The Madras High Court in Lenovo (India) Pvt. Ltd. v. Joint Commissioner of GST (Appeals-1), 2023 (79) GSTL 299, read the word “may” in Section 54(1) as making the period directory, so that a legitimate claim could be allowed in an appropriate case even after two years. The Jharkhand High Court followed the same reasoning in the pre-deposit case. When that case reached the Supreme Court, the refund was upheld on a different footing and the High Court’s reasoning on Section 54 was set aside. The “directory” reading therefore has no approval from the Supreme Court.

The Karnataka High Court, in Division Bench, has now taken the opposite view. In Assistant Commissioner of Central Taxes v. Merck Life Science Pvt. Ltd., Writ Appeal No. 110 of 2026, decided on 17.03.2026, the Court held that the two year limitation is mandatory and binding on the proper officer, and that the Act contains no provision empowering the tax authorities to condone delay. The Court added that a taxpayer may still seek relief under Article 226 on the facts of a particular case, and that any such condonation must be balanced by extending the time available to the Revenue under Sections 73 and 74. On the facts, where double taxation was not disputed and the delay was of about six months, the Court treated the claim as filed in time and directed it to be processed within sixty days.

The position that emerges is this. Before the proper officer and the appellate authority, the period is a bar they cannot lift. Before the High Court in writ jurisdiction, the period may yield in a fit case, but as a matter of discretion and not of right.

6. What Mafatlal Settled

Any discussion of refund of indirect tax begins with the nine Judge Bench in Mafatlal Industries Ltd. v. Union of India, (1997) 5 SCC 536. Three propositions from that judgment govern the present question.

(a) Where the statute provides a refund mechanism, a claim for refund of tax paid on a misinterpretation or misapplication of the statute, including a claim founded on a mistake of law discovered from a decision in another person’s case, must be made under the statute and within its limitation.

(b) Where the levy itself is struck down as unconstitutional, the claim falls outside the statute. It may be pursued by suit or by writ, and limitation runs from the date of discovery of the mistake, applying Section 17(1)(c) of the Limitation Act, 1963.

(c) In either case, the claimant must show that the burden of the tax has not been passed on. Article 265 forbids collection without authority of law, but it does not by itself entitle a person who has recovered the tax from others to receive it again.

Mafatlal has not been overruled. Being a decision of nine Judges, it can be reconsidered only by a larger Bench, and the Supreme Court continues to apply it.

7. Amounts That Were Never Tax

Two older decisions of the Supreme Court form the base of this line. In State of Madhya Pradesh v. Bhailal Bhai, AIR 1964 SC 1006, the Court held that a writ court may direct refund of tax paid under a mistake of law, judging delay with reference to the period of limitation for a suit. In Salonah Tea Co. Ltd. v. Superintendent of Taxes, (1988) 1 SCC 401, the Court held that tax collected without authority of law must ordinarily be refunded, subject to delay and laches.

Under GST, the High Courts have built on these decisions in the following cases.

1. Comsol Energy Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Gujarat, R/SCA No. 11905 of 2020, decided on 21.12.2020 by the Gujarat High Court: the limitation provisions for refund of lawful tax do not apply to an amount paid under a mistake; such an amount does not partake of the character of tax legally due.

2. The Delhi High Court in the case of Delhi Metro Rail Corporation, 2023 (9) TMI 1177: the Corporation had deposited GST on the preparation of a project report, believing the service to be taxable; it was not. The Court held that the limitation in Section 54 does not apply where GST is not chargeable and the amount has been deposited under a mistake of law.

3. Nspira Management Services Pvt. Ltd. v. Assistant/Deputy Commissioner of Central Tax, W.P. Nos. 18287 and 14905 of 2024, decided on 26.09.2025 by the Andhra Pradesh High Court: GST had been paid on rent of residential dwellings used as residence, a supply exempt under Notification No. 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate). The refund claims were rejected by deficiency memos as time barred. The Court held that the limitation in Section 54 does not apply where tax was collected without authority of law, set aside the memos also because they bypassed the show cause procedure under Rule 92(3), and directed the claims to be decided on merits without reference to limitation.

4. Louis Dreyfus Company Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India, decided on 14.08.2025 by the Andhra Pradesh High Court: once the levy on ocean freight was held invalid, the payment made in discharge of it was not an exaction of tax, and no period of limitation under the Act could be applied to its refund.

5. Rajendra Narayan Mohanty v. Joint Commissioner of State Tax, W.P.(C) No. 2271 of 2026, decided by the Orissa High Court: tax paid twice for the same liability cannot be retained by refusing refund on the ground of limitation under Section 54, as retention of the second payment offends Article 265.

6. Jupiter Comtex Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India, R/SCA No. 1280 of 2024, decided on 14.02.2024 by the Gujarat High Court, 2024:GUJHC:11877-DB: the officer had rejected a refund of IGST on ocean freight saying that a refund flowing from a levy held unconstitutional is not a category known to Section 54. The Court deprecated that stand, holding that the officer is bound to give effect to the law declared by the Supreme Court in Union of India v. Mohit Minerals Pvt. Ltd., (2022) 10 SCC 700, and directed refund with interest on the strength of a certificate of non-passing of the burden.

The reasoning common to these decisions is simple. Section 54 is a provision for refund of tax. An amount that the law did not authorise the State to collect on that transaction is not tax. Its return is governed by Article 265, by the general law of restitution in Section 72 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, and, where limitation is to be applied at all, by the general law of limitation and not by the two years in Section 54(1).

8. The Supreme Court in Torrent Power

In Union of India v. Torrent Power Ltd., SLP (C) No. 13084 of 2025, decided on 10.02.2026, reported as (2026) 39 Centax 265 (SC), a power company had paid IGST and service tax on ocean freight on CIF imports of natural gas. After Mohit Minerals, it sought refund. The Department proposed to credit the amount to the Consumer Welfare Fund because the burden had been passed on to consumers through tariffs. The Gujarat High Court directed the refund to be paid to the company for adjustment in favour of its consumers.

The Supreme Court set that judgment aside. It held that under Section 54(5) the refundable amount is to be credited to the Consumer Welfare Fund unless the case falls within Section 54(8); that the company, having admittedly passed on the burden, did not satisfy clause (e); and that the High Court could not devise a mode of refund not contemplated by Section 54 read with Section 57. The company was directed to transfer Rs. 19,28,86,868 for credit to the Fund within three months.

Three things follow from the judgment. First, even a refund of a levy declared unconstitutional was dealt with through Sections 54(5), 54(8) and 57, and the Court described Section 54 as a complete code. The Revenue will rely on this language to argue that every refund, whatever its source, carries the two year period. Second, the judgment turns on unjust enrichment and on the destination of the refund. The reach of the limitation in Section 54(1) to an amount that was never leviable was not the question before the Court. Third, the judgment is fully consistent with Mafatlal, which applied the test of unjust enrichment even to claims outside the statute. Read with BLA Infrastructure, where the same Bench held that refund of pre-deposit lies outside Section 54 altogether, Torrent Power is best understood as making Section 54 a complete code for refund of tax, and not as converting into tax what the law never levied.

9. Reconciling the Two Lines: The Test of a Lawful Levy

The decisions fall into place once a single question is asked: on the date of payment, was the amount leviable on that transaction under a valid charging provision and a notification then in force?

Where the Amount Was Lawfully Leviable

Where the answer is yes, the claim is one for refund of tax, and Section 54 with its two years governs. This covers the following claims:

1. Excess paid over a liability that did exist, through an arithmetical error or a higher figure in the return.

2. A dispute over rate or classification of a supply that is taxable, which Mafatlal treats as a misinterpretation of the statute.

3. Refunds on exports, zero rated supplies, deemed exports and inverted duty structure, and the balance in the electronic cash ledger.

4. Refund consequent on an appellate or court order, where the period runs from the communication of that order.

Where the Amount Was Never Tax

Where the answer is no, the amount was never tax, and the two years in Section 54(1) do not bar its return. This covers the following:

1. A levy struck down as unconstitutional or ultra vires, as with IGST on ocean freight.

2. The same tax paid twice for one liability.

3. GST paid on a supply that was exempt on the date of supply.

4. GST paid on a transaction that was not chargeable to tax at all.

5. An amount collected at a rate that was not in force for the period, as where an increase in rate operates only from a later date. For the period before that date, the higher rate had no authority of law, and the excess stands with the second class rather than with an ordinary dispute over rate.

Pre-deposit for appeal stands on its own footing under Sections 107(6), 112(8) and 115, as held in BLA Infrastructure.

The line between a rate dispute and a levy without law will not always be easy to draw. The distinction is nevertheless real. In the first, the transaction is taxable and the parties differ on how much. In the second, the law, on that date, did not authorise the amount at all.

10. Unjust Enrichment and Interest in Both Classes

Whichever class a claim falls in, the doctrine of unjust enrichment applies. Within Section 54, it operates through sub-sections (5) and (8) and Section 57, as Torrent Power now makes plain. Outside Section 54, it applies by force of Mafatlal. A refund paid to the applicant therefore always depends on showing that the incidence was not passed on, which is ordinarily done by the books of account and a certificate of a Chartered Accountant, as accepted in Jupiter Comtex.

Interest follows the same division. A refund under Section 54 carries interest under Section 56. Where the amount is returned outside the statute, the writ courts have directed interest on the footing of the statutory rate or on equitable principles, as the Gujarat High Court did in Jupiter Comtex by directing refund “along with the statutory rate of interest”.

11. Conclusion

Section 54 is a complete code for refund of tax. The Supreme Court has said so in Torrent Power, and the proper officer must apply its two years strictly, as the Karnataka High Court has held in Merck Life Science. But the code is a code for tax. It presupposes a levy that the law authorised on that transaction on that date. Where there was no such levy, the money in the Government account is not tax, and Article 265 does not permit it to be kept merely because the claim for its return was made after two years. That is the principle the High Courts have applied in Comsol Energy, Delhi Metro Rail Corporation, Nspira, Louis Dreyfus, Rajendra Narayan Mohanty and Jupiter Comtex. Until the Supreme Court decides that question directly, the line between tax wrongly paid and money never due remains the line on which every delayed refund claim will be won or lost.

Advertisement

Author Info

RAVINDRA KUMAR RASTOGI
Qualification: LL.B / Advocate
Company: R R ASSOCIATES
Location: Allahabad, Uttar Pradesh
Articles Published: 74

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *