Happiest Minds Technologies Limited Vs DCIT ( ITAT Bangalore)
Summary: ITAT Bangalore allowed Happiest Minds Technologies Limited’s appeal for assessment year 2019-2020 against the rejection of its rectification application concerning a ₹23,39,58,848 disallowance for diminution in the value of investment in a wholly-owned subsidiary. The assessee had acquired OSS Cube LLC, a US-based digital transformation company, in 2017 to strengthen and expand its existing business. Following adverse circumstances, including technological obsolescence, the investment declined and the subsidiary was to be wound up. The assessee claimed the diminution as revenue expenditure. CPC disallowed the claim while processing the revised return under section 143(1), relying on the tax auditor’s classification of the amount as capital expenditure. The AO rejected rectification under section 154, and CIT(A) upheld that rejection on the ground that the issue required deeper scrutiny. The Tribunal relied on Ace Designers Limited, where the Karnataka High Court treated the write-off of a business-purpose investment in a wholly-owned foreign subsidiary as a business loss. That binding jurisdictional judgment had been pronounced on 9 September 2020, before CPC’s intimation dated 19 November 2020. The Tribunal held that CPC performs a quasi-judicial function and cannot disregard binding jurisdictional precedent merely because of a contrary tax audit report observation. Applying Saurashtra Kutch Stock Exchange Limited, it held that non-consideration of such precedent constitutes a mistake apparent from the record. The Revenue’s reliance on Volkart Brothers and Hero Cycles was rejected as misplaced; Mepco Industries was distinguished because rectification here relied on an earlier judgment. The Tribunal set aside the impugned order and allowed the assessee’s grounds.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.





