JSW Minerals Trading Private Limited Vs Assessment Unit (Bombay High Court)
Bombay High Court quashed the assessment order and demand notice against JSW Minerals Trading Private Limited for AY 2020-21 after holding that an addition of ₹302.27 crore based on undisclosed CBEC import data violated principles of natural justice. The Assessing Officer noticed a difference between imports of ₹1,520.29 crore appearing in CBEC data and purchases of ₹1,218.03 crore disclosed by the assessee. Despite repeated requests, however, the Department did not furnish the detailed breakup or underlying CBEC data necessary to enable the assessee to reconcile the alleged difference.
The Court observed that it was impossible for the assessee to properly explain the discrepancy without particulars of the import bills and purchase values relied upon by the Assessing Officer. Significantly, the show-cause notice proposed an addition under Section 69A as unexplained money, whereas the final assessment made the addition under Section 69 as unexplained investment. The Court also noted that the assessee had partially reconciled ₹270.94 crore and that the same purchases had been scrutinised in transfer-pricing proceedings and accepted at arm’s length.
Holding that general aggregate information without particulars, supporting evidence or adequate opportunity for reconciliation could not constitute valid material for making the addition, the High Court set aside the assessment and demand. The matter was remanded for fresh assessment. The Assessing Officer was directed to furnish the complete CBEC information and detailed breakup, specify the provisions proposed to be invoked, grant at least 15 working days for reply and provide a personal hearing. If judicial decisions are relied upon, at least seven days’ notice must be given to the assessee to respond. The fresh assessment was directed to be completed by 31 March 2026.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.






