Sacchanand Hiralal Lalwani Vs ACIT (ITAT Nagpur)
Section 68 Addition Deleted Because AO Failed to Disprove Documented Share Transactions; LTCG Exemption Allowed Because Investigation Report Alone Could Not Prove Bogus Transactions; No Section 68 Addition Because Assessee Produced Complete Documentary Evidence; Capital Gains Exemption Restored Because No Evidence Linked Assessee to Price Manipulation; Section 10(38) Relief Granted Because Natural Justice Was Not Followed; Section 68 Addition Set Aside Because Sale Through Recognised Broker Was Properly Documented; LTCG Claim Upheld Because AO Failed to Rebut Demat, Bank and Contract Note Evidence.
The appeal concerned the validity of an addition of ₹3,27,70,750 under Section 68 and the denial of exemption under Section 10(38) in respect of long-term capital gains arising from the sale of shares of Greencrest Financial Services Limited. The assessee also challenged the findings that the share transactions were bogus and alleged violation of the principles of natural justice.
Background of the Case
The assessee filed the return of income for Assessment Year 2015–16 declaring income of approximately ₹1.24 crore and claimed exempt long-term capital gains of about ₹3.57 crore under Section 10(38). The gains arose from the sale of shares of Greencrest Financial Services Limited. The assessee explained that he had acquired 2,00,000 shares of Marigold Glass Industries Ltd. through preferential allotment for ₹24,00,000. Following a share split from a face value of ₹10 to ₹1, the holding increased to 20,00,000 shares, and the company was subsequently renamed Greencrest Financial Services Limited. During the relevant year, the assessee sold 5,87,000 shares through Edelweiss Securities Ltd. on the Bombay Stock Exchange, paid Securities Transaction Tax (STT), and claimed exemption under Section 10(38). Supporting documents, including share application forms, allotment details, bank statements, contract notes, and Demat statements, were furnished.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




