Chamber of Tax Consultants Vs CIT (Exemptions) (Bombay High Court)
No Irrevocability Clause Required for Sec 12AB Registration – Bombay HC Quashes Rejection of Trust Registration
Bombay HC dealt with rejection of 12AB renewal applications of multiple charitable trusts on grounds that:
- Trust deed did not contain irrevocability clause / dissolution clause
- Assessee marked “Yes” in Form 10AB- treated as false information / specified violation
HC held:
1. No such condition in law:
- Sec 12AB requires satisfaction on objects, genuineness & compliance
- No requirement of irrevocability clause in statute
- Department cannot read new condition into law
2. Legal position on revocability clarified:
- As per Sec 63 – trust is revocable only if explicit power to re-transfer / reassume control exists
- Silence ≠ revocable ; rather implies irrevocable
3. MPT Act overrides concern:
- Even if trust revoked – assets cannot revert to settlor
- Must go to Charity Commissioner / similar objects (cy-pres)
- Hence, public trusts inherently irrevocable
4. Earlier registrations & consistency:
- Same deeds earlier accepted u/s 12A / 12AB
- No change in law – new interpretation impermissible
5. Form 10AB issue:
- System forces “Yes” – cannot penalise assessee
- Treating it as false info is arbitrary
6. Safeguards already exist:
- Sec 13, Sec 115TD & registration conditions prevent misuse
- Revocability concerns to be tested at exemption stage, not registration
Final Outcome:
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.

