Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Fema / RBI

SAFEMA Tribunal Sustains PMLA Attachment Despite Lawful Property Acquisition

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 15140
Case Name
Mohamad Ibrahim Sait Vs Deputy Director (Appellate Tribunal under SAFEMA)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Courts
SAFEMA
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Mohamad Ibrahim Sait Vs Deputy Director (Appellate Tribunal under SAFEMA)

PMLA Attachment as Equivalent Value: Earlier Acquisition and Lawful Sources Do Not By Themselves Protect Property

Background

The proceedings arose from allegations of illegal granite quarrying in Madurai district. Two police cases concerned alleged encroachment, unauthorised extraction and related offences under the IPC, the Tamil Nadu property-damage legislation and the Explosive Substances Act.

The Enforcement Directorate registered an ECIR in December 2017, relying on offences included in the Schedule to the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002.

According to the ED, the alleged criminal activity generated proceeds of crime totalling ₹79.50 crore. It provisionally attached 45 immovable properties valued at ₹4,69,55,706 through an order dated 29 March 2019. The Adjudicating Authority confirmed the attachment on 11 November 2019.

The appellants challenged that confirmation, principally disputing the existence of scheduled offences, the connection between the properties and alleged proceeds, their valuation and the recorded reasons for attachment.

Scheduled Offences Existed Despite the Mining-law Objection

The appellants argued that violations of the mining enactments relied upon were not themselves scheduled offences under the PMLA.

The Tribunal rejected this objection because the prosecution was not confined to mining-law violations. The charge sheet also invoked provisions including sections 420, 467, 471 and 304 IPC, and sections 3 and 4 of the Explosive Substances Act, which appeared in the PMLA Schedule.

Accordingly, the contention that there was no underlying scheduled offence failed.

Claimed Legitimate Sources Were Not Established

The appellants asserted that the properties had been purchased from lawful quarrying income, agricultural income, real-estate transactions, interest and accumulated cash. They furnished property particulars and explanations concerning acquisition.

The Tribunal nevertheless found that the claimed sources remained insufficiently substantiated. It accepted the ED’s objections regarding the absence of adequate supporting evidence and the limited income reflected in the returns available.

It therefore held that the appellants had not discharged their evidentiary burden.

More significantly, the Tribunal gave an independent reason for sustaining the attachment: the properties were attached as equivalent value of proceeds of crime, rather than solely as properties directly purchased from those proceeds.

Equivalent-value Attachment: Lawful Acquisition Was Not Conclusive

The Tribunal held that, where property is attached as “value of such property” under section 2(1)(u), its own source of acquisition is not decisive.

On that interpretation, even property acquired from fully explained lawful sources could be attached as a substitute representing the value of proceeds derived from the scheduled offence.

The distinction was therefore between property alleged to originate from criminal proceeds and other property attached in lieu of those proceeds. Establishing a lawful source for the latter did not, by itself, defeat attachment.

Properties Acquired Before the Alleged Offence

The appellants also pointed out that several properties had been acquired between 1993 and 2010, before the alleged offending period referred to in their submissions.

The Tribunal rejected this argument on the same basis. Since the attachment was as equivalent value, it held that acquisition before or after the scheduled offence was immaterial to that particular objection.

It relied on its earlier decision in Sadanand Nayak v. Deputy Director, dated 14 October 2024, and the Punjab and Haryana High Court’s decision in Dilbag Singh @ Dilbag Sandhu v. Union of India, dated 13 November 2024.

The Tribunal treated Pavana Dibbur as distinguishable in the equivalent-value context, following the reasoning reproduced from Dilbag Singh.

Valuation Objection Accepted, but Attachment Sustained

The appellants challenged the use of current guideline and market values, contending that the aggregate purchase cost of the properties was only ₹26,25,425.

The Tribunal accepted that, under section 2(1)(zb), “value” refers to fair market value on the date of acquisition, or the date of possession where acquisition cannot be determined. It found the ED’s adoption of present values incorrect.

However, it held that this error did not invalidate the attachment. The alleged proceeds of crime had been quantified by reference to the granite allegedly extracted, independently of the attached properties’ valuation. A lower property value therefore did not undermine the attachment challenged.

Sold Properties and Reasons to Believe

For properties the principal appellant claimed to have already sold, the Tribunal held that he no longer retained an interest sufficient to challenge their attachment as an aggrieved person under section 26. It did not adjudicate the purchasers’ rights through that finding.

The Tribunal also upheld the recorded reasons to believe. It considered the allegations, supporting material and risk of further alienation sufficient at the attachment stage. The appellant’s own assertion that some properties had already been sold supported that apprehension.

The disputed translation of his statement did not alter the result, since the Tribunal considered the remaining material sufficient without relying on the contested admission.

Decision

The Tribunal declined to interfere with the confirmation order and dismissed the challenge, leaving the attachment in place. The decision concerned attachment proceedings, not a final determination of criminal guilt.

Author’s Comments

The central lesson is to identify the legal basis of attachment before answering it. Proof that a property was lawfully acquired before the alleged offence may address an allegation that it represents direct criminal proceeds, but does not necessarily answer an equivalent-value attachment.

This ruling should nonetheless be cited within its limits. It does not establish that every property of an accused becomes attachable merely upon registration of an FIR. The Tribunal upheld a particular attachment on the alleged proceeds, recorded reasons and material before it.

The valuation finding is also important: the ED’s method was found incorrect, yet the attachment survived because the alleged proceeds were independently quantified. A valuation objection must therefore explain its effect on the permissible extent of attachment.

Finally, the dismissal concerning sold properties rested on the seller’s standing. It should not be presented as a ruling rejecting the independent rights or defences of bona fide purchasers.

FULL TEXT OF THE JUDGMENT APPELLATE TRIBUNAL UNDER SAFEMA AT NEW DELHI

Want to Read the Complete Judgment?

You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.

Read on with Premium
Goes straight to payment. GST invoice included.

One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Vijayakumar Shetty
Qualification: CA in Practice
Company: Shetty & Co, Chartered Accountants, Mangalore
Location: Mangalore, Karnataka
Articles Published: 7,850

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.