Late Ashok Sunderdas Agicha Vs Deputy Director (Appellate Tribunal under SAFEMA, New Delhi)
Property Acquired Before the Crime Can Be Attached Under PMLA When Actual Proceeds Are Unavailable
Background: Alleged Diversion of Bank Finance
The proceedings arose from a CBI FIR dated 17 February 2022 against M/s Associate Lumbers Pvt. Ltd., its directors and others. The complaint alleged fraudulent diversion of bank finance, causing wrongful loss of approximately ₹122.19 crore to Union Bank of India, formerly Corporation Bank.
The alleged offences included criminal conspiracy and cheating under the IPC, besides offences under the Prevention of Corruption Act. Based on the scheduled offences, the Enforcement Directorate initiated proceedings under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002.
According to the investigation, loan funds were diverted to sister concerns as unsecured loans and to other entities for property purchases and settlement of liabilities. The Directorate provisionally attached immovable properties valued at ₹42,92,53,624 by an order dated 28 March 2024. These included a land parcel held jointly in the appellant’s name.
Earlier Disposal Recalled and Appeal Heard Afresh
The appeal had initially been disposed of on 3 August 2026, after counsel did not press the challenge to attachment, subject to protection of possession through an order of status quo.
The appellant subsequently sought recall, asserting that counsel had not been instructed to adopt that course. The Tribunal allowed the recall application and heard the appeal afresh.
The present decision therefore adjudicated the challenge after restoring the appeal.
Appellant’s Sole Ground: The Property Predated the Crime
The appellant contended that the land had been acquired much before the alleged criminal activity. Consequently, it could not have been purchased from the alleged proceeds of crime and had no direct or indirect connection with those proceeds.
Reliance was placed on Seema Garg v. Deputy Director, Directorate of Enforcement, 2020 SCC OnLine P&H 738.
The Tribunal expressly recorded that, despite an opportunity to raise other factual or legal issues, counsel pressed only this ground. The allegations underlying the FIR and ECIR were not contested in the arguments before it.
Accordingly, the decision was confined to whether property acquired before the crime could nevertheless be attached as property representing the value of proceeds of crime.
ED’s Defence: Attachment Was for Equivalent Value
The Enforcement Directorate maintained that the actual proceeds of crime were no longer available, having been dissipated or laundered. The land was therefore attached as property of equivalent value, rather than as property purchased using criminal proceeds.
The Directorate relied on Dilbag Singh alias Dilbag Sandhu v. Union of India, decided by the Punjab and Haryana High Court on 13 November 2024, which considered the statutory definition in light of the Supreme Court’s decision in Vijay Madanlal Choudhary.
“Proceeds of Crime” Includes the Value of Such Property
The Tribunal accepted that the definition under section 2(1)(u) extends beyond property directly or indirectly derived from criminal activity relating to a scheduled offence. It also includes “the value of any such property.”
On the interpretation adopted, where the actual tainted property cannot be traced or is unavailable, other property may be attached to represent its equivalent value. Such substitute property may have been legitimately acquired before the alleged offence.
The Tribunal reasoned that excluding all pre-existing property would render the value-based component of the definition ineffective. A person could otherwise dissipate the criminal proceeds and claim immunity for the assets remaining in his hands.
Earlier Decisions and the Safeguards Recognised
The Tribunal relied on the reasoning in Vijay Madanlal Choudhary, Axis Bank, Prakash Industries and Dilbag Singh. It declined to apply the restrictive approach relied upon from Seema Garg, referring to the subsequent judicial interpretation of the definition.
The authorities discussed also recognised safeguards. Attachment of substitute property requires equivalence in value to the unlawful gain, and the reasoning preserves protections for bona fide third-party interests.
The distinction is therefore significant: a property’s acquisition before the crime may exclude it from being directly derived from that crime, but does not necessarily exclude it from attachment as equivalent-value property.
Decision: Attachment Confirmed
The Tribunal held that the Directorate was entitled to attach the property for the value of the proceeds of crime because the actual proceeds were not available with the appellant.
It therefore dismissed the appeal and confirmed the impugned order.
Author’s Comments
The decision demonstrates the limitations of defending a PMLA attachment solely by producing an old purchase deed. An earlier acquisition date answers the question of direct derivation; it may not answer an equivalent-value attachment.
However, the ruling does not confer an unrestricted power to attach every asset of an investigated person. The existence and value of proceeds of crime, their unavailability, the basis for selecting substitute property and protected third-party interests remain material.
The narrow scope of the appeal also matters. Since the appellant pressed only the acquisition-date objection, the decision should not be presented as a comprehensive adjudication of every allegation or attachment requirement. The practical lesson is to address the specific statutory basis of attachment, together with the relevant facts, rather than rely exclusively on when the property was purchased.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.






