ITO Vs Narayanaswamy (ITAT Chennai)
Fabricated Agreement Fails Revenue -Unregistered Sale Agreement -No Proof of Cash Receipt in Property Sale-271D Penalty Struck Down: ITAT Chennai
Chennai ITAT has upheld the order of CIT(A) deleting a massive penalty of ₹3.02 crore levied u/s 271D, on the allegation of cash receipt in a property transaction. Tribunal held that in the absence of any cogent evidence of actual cash payment, the penalty was unsustainable in law.
Assessee had sold immovable property along with others & received ₹17,52,250/- as his share of the consideration. According to AO, as per the information available with Dept, an unregistered sale agreement dated 29.04.2017 was executed between Assessee and purchaser for a sale consideration of immovable property for land of total area of 5 acres and 75 cents for ₹.3,47,87,500/-. AO concluded that the actual sale consideration was ₹3.47 crore as against the registered deed value of ₹45.04 lakh. According to AO, the difference of ₹3.02 crore was presumed to have been received by Assessee & other sellers in cash, allegedly in violation of Section 269SS & accordingly a penalty of ₹3,02,83,000/- was levied u/s 271D.
CIT(A) deleted the penalty, holding that there was no documentary evidence to prove that Assessee had received any cash over & above the registered sale consideration. It was observed that mere existence of an unregistered agreement was not sufficient to prove cash transactions.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




