Trident Automobiles (P) Ltd Vs DCIT (ITAT Bangalore)
Sale Deed for ₹6 Crore, Seller Retains ₹3 Crore: Bengaluru ITAT Allows Deduction for Payment to Agreement Holder
Summary: When a property is sold for ₹6 crore, but the seller is bound under an earlier arrangement to pay ₹3 crore to an agreement holder, how should the capital gains be computed? Can the seller simply show ₹3 crore as the sale consideration, or must the full ₹6 crore be recognised and the payment examined as a deduction? The Bengaluru ITAT considered this issue in the case of Trident Automobiles (P) Ltd.
The Earlier Agreement and the Eventual Sale
The assessee company owned land measuring 2 acres and 5 guntas at Tumkur Amanikere Village. It had initially agreed to sell the property to Mr N. Radhakrishna for ₹3 crore, and had received an advance of ₹11 lakh. Mr Radhakrishna could not pay the balance consideration. The parties therefore entered into a further arrangement under which he would find another buyer. The assessee would receive the originally agreed sum of ₹3 crore, while any amount realised above that figure would go to him.
A buyer was subsequently found, and the property was sold under a registered deed dated 31 August 2016 for ₹6 crore. Of this amount, ₹3 crore was paid to Mr Radhakrishna. The assessee stated that the payment was made through banking channels. He had also joined as a consenting witness in the arrangements concerning the sale.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.


