K.Pandiarajan Vs ACIT (Madras High Court)
Madras HC: Compensation for Giving Up Right of First Purchase of Shares Is Capital Receipt -1 Million Received for Withdrawal of Legal Challenge Not Taxable as Revenue Income
In K. Pandiarajan & R. Hemalatha v. ACIT, the Madras High Court considered the taxability of Rs 1 million received by the founders/shareholders of Ma Foi Management Consultants Ltd. The assessees claimed the amount as a capital receipt, whereas the AO treated it as business income; the CIT(A) shifted the taxation to “Income from Other Sources” under section 56, which was upheld by the ITAT.
Under a 2004 shareholders’ agreement, Vedior held 76.33% of Ma Foi and the appellants jointly held 23.52%. Importantly, the agreement conferred upon the appellants a pre-emptive/right of first purchase if Vedior proposed to transfer its shares to a third party. When Vedior was proposed to be acquired by Randstad, the appellants asserted that their contractual rights were being breached and issued a legal notice threatening action.
To settle the dispute, Randstad agreed to a “success sharing bonus” of up to €3 million. The first €1 million was payable upon signing the agreement and withdrawal of the legal notice, while the subsequent €0.5 million instalments were linked to performance/business conditions. The appellants treated the first €1 million as capital receipt but offered the subsequent instalments to tax.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.



