Ajanta Manufacturing Limited Vs DCIT (Gujarat High Court)
Summary: Gujarat High Court held that an assessee cannot be denied interest on refund under Section 244A(2) of the Income Tax Act merely because the claim resulting in refund was raised during assessment proceedings and ultimately allowed in appeal. Ajanta Manufacturing Limited had initially offered subsidy received under the Kutch Area Incentive Scheme as a revenue receipt but, during assessment proceedings, claimed that it was a capital receipt not exigible to tax. The Assessing Officer rejected the claim because it had not been made through a revised return, but the Commissioner (Appeals) subsequently allowed it, resulting in refund with interest.
The Revenue later sought to withdraw Rs.2,15,73,710 of interest through rectification proceedings under Section 154, treating the period preceding appellate relief as delay attributable to the assessee. The High Court held that Section 244A(2) applies only where the proceedings resulting in refund were actually delayed for reasons attributable to the assessee. Revising a return or raising a claim during assessment cannot by itself constitute such delay, nor can filing an appeal that ultimately succeeds be treated as assessee-attributable delay.
The Court also held that the issue involved detailed consideration of facts and law and therefore could not be treated as an error apparent from the record capable of rectification under Section 154. While the Commissioner was competent to decide a reference under Section 244A(2), the substantive conditions for denying interest were not satisfied. Following the principle recognised by the Kerala High Court in CIT v. South Indian Bank Ltd., the Gujarat High Court quashed the Commissioner’s order, the consequential Assessing Officer’s order and the demand notice seeking recovery of the refund interest.
Cases Discussed
Commissioner of Income-Tax Vs South Indian Bank Ltd. (2012) 340 ITR (Kerala High Court) — Relied upon. The Kerala High Court held that interest under Section 244A cannot be denied merely because a claim resulting in refund was raised belatedly; there must be an identifiable delay in the proceedings attributable to the assessee.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.


