Renu Anandani Vs National Faceless Appeal Centre (ITAT Jabalpur)
Assessment was reopened u/s 147 r.w.s. 143(3) on allegation that Assessee claimed bogus STCL in Ashutosh Paper Mills shares using fabricated back-dated contract notes. AO made addition of ₹22,16,080 including bogus loss of ₹21,72,628.
Later, PCIT invoked 263 holding that shares credited to demat on 26.03.2012 valued at ₹3,56,680 were not proved to be the same as earlier offline purchases of ₹25,32,920, implying total unexplained investment of ₹28,89,600. AO, following 263 directions, added ₹7,16,972 u/s 69B, recomputed STCG on immovable property, & also added ₹3,60,291 as bogus balance investment. Total income was computed at ₹57,05,869.
Before CIT(A), Assessee argued that additions resulted in double taxation, investment already stood recorded, & AO presumed fictitious online investment without proof. CIT(A) dismissed the appeal stating directions of PCIT were binding & no appeal was filed against the 263 order.
Tribunal held CIT(A) was completely misdirected—PCIT’s 263 only set aside assessment for fresh enquiry; AO was required to apply independent mind & CIT(A) was equally bound to examine additions on merits. CIT(A)’s refusal to adjudicate, merely because AO acted per 263, amounted to abdication of duty. Further, CIT(A) issued notice offering video-conference option till 25.07.2023 but passed the order immediately on 12.07.2023, violating natural justice.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




