Jai Enterprises Vs Dr Anupama Goyal (GSTAT Lucknow)
Summary: The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Lucknow, allowed the appeal filed by M/s Jai Enterprises against the appellate order dated 19 December 2019, which had upheld a tax and penalty demand of ₹6,62,077 imposed under Section 129(3) of the CGST/UPGST Act, 2017. The dispute arose from the detention of a vehicle carrying Pan Masala and Tobacco products from Kanpur towards Auraiya under tax invoices and e-way bills generated on 11 May 2018.
The department relied on photographs and vehicle movement records from Bara Toll Plaza, which recorded the vehicle travelling towards Etawah at approximately 12:22 P.M., returning towards Kanpur at approximately 2:56 P.M., and again proceeding towards Auraiya at approximately 7:19 P.M. Based on these movements, the authorities inferred that the same goods had already been transported and that the invoices and e-way bills were being reused to facilitate tax evasion. The first appellate authority rejected the appeal on limitation as well as on merits.
The appellant maintained that the earlier journey involved transportation of cotton cut pieces or cotton waste to Kalpi, whereas the subsequent journey involved Pan Masala and Tobacco products supported by valid documents. It argued that the goods were physically verified without any discrepancy in description, quantity, weight, value or ownership and that similarity in photographs did not establish that the same consignment had been transported twice.






