Sri Uma Manpower Suppliers Vs Deputy Commissioner of Central Tax (Telangana High Court)
Summary: The Telangana High Court dismissed the writ petition filed by Sri Uma Manpower Suppliers challenging an interest demand of Rs.4,82,295/- and consequential bank recovery proceedings concerning its December 2018 GST liability. The petitioner had declared the liability in GSTR-1 and claimed that deposits of Rs.15,60,826/- and Rs.23,88,588/- made on 05.01.2019 ensured that Rs.35,82,368/- was available in its Electronic Cash Ledger within the relevant period. However, the liability was discharged only when the September 2019 GSTR-3B return was filed on 17.10.2019. The department demanded interest under Section 50(1) for 273 days at 18% per annum and issued a Form GST-DRC-13 notice to the bank under Section 79(1)(c). The petitioner attributed the delay to GST portal technical glitches and argued that money already deposited with the Government should not attract interest. Examining Sections 39, 49 and 50 and Rule 87, the Court distinguished a deposit in the Electronic Cash Ledger from its appropriation towards a specific tax liability. It followed RSB Transmissions (India) Limited v. Union of India, holding that tax liability is discharged through the corresponding debit upon filing GSTR-3B. The petitioner’s reliance on Tamilnadu State Transport Corporation (Villupuram) Limited v. Additional Commissioner of Central Tax and the contrary approach in Eicher Motors Limited did not persuade the Court. The material did not establish that technical difficulties prevented statutory payment. The Court also declined interference on natural justice grounds because the petitioner had an opportunity to submit objections. Although an appeal under Section 107 was not an absolute bar to writ jurisdiction, the Court considered the merits and dismissed the petition, closed pending miscellaneous petitions and made no order as to costs.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




