United Air Express Vs Sanjay Kumar Agarwal & Ors. (Calcutta High Court)
Summary: Calcutta High Court dismissed the appeal filed by United Air Express and upheld the Single Judge’s direction requiring Steel Authority of India Limited (SAIL) to give an MSME bidder, Metal Traders Processing Company, an opportunity to match the L1 price. The tender expressly provided that purchase preference under the Public Procurement Policy for Micro and Small Enterprises would apply and, where the order could not be split, 100% of the order would be placed on an eligible MSE whose quoted price was within L1+15%, subject to the MSE matching the L1 price.
United Air Express emerged as L1, FSNL Private Limited as L2 and Metal Traders Processing Company, an MSE, as L3. The Court found that the MSE bidder’s price fell within the stipulated range and the tender conditions conferred upon it a right to be treated as an MSME and an opportunity to match the L1 price. Correspondence between SAIL and Government e-Marketplace (GeM) showed that the portal did not provide the required MSE price-matching facility for the bid. Significantly, GeM itself advised SAIL to conduct price matching offline.
Despite this clarification, no such opportunity was afforded to the MSME bidder and the contract was awarded to United Air Express. The Division Bench held that SAIL was bound by its own tender conditions and that failure to provide the stipulated price-matching opportunity amounted to a gross procedural infirmity. Referring to Silppi Constructions Contractors Vs Union of India And Anr. and Tata Cellular Vs Union of India, the Court reiterated that judicial review in tender matters is permissible where there is an infirmity in the decision-making process.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.



