Sana Md. Saqib Puthawala Vs ITO (ITAT Ahmedabad)
ITAT Ahmedabad deletes addition on alleged bogus LTCG in Kushal Tradelink shares – No live link, no evidence, mere suspicion cannot justify tax
Assessee had declared LTCG of ₹23,02,040 on sale of shares of Kushal Tradelink Ltd and claimed exemption u/s 10(38). Assessment was reopened u/s 147 based only on Insight Portal information alleging accommodation entries in Kushal Group. AO denied exemption, treated entire gain of ₹23,59,580 as unexplained income & added 6% commission ₹1,41,575 u/s 69C. CIT(A) upheld the additions.
Assessee’s contention:
- Reopening based on “borrowed satisfaction” without independent application of mind.
- All documents such as demat, contract notes, bank statements, STT-paid transactions, were filed.
- No material/statements were given to assessee, no cross-examination.
- Relied on Gujarat HC in Ashishbhai Jashwantbhai Desai HUF (07.01.2025).
Tribunal’s Findings:
Reopening invalid in substance
- AO relied only on Insight Portal info without showing live link or independent satisfaction.
- Gujarat HC in Ashishbhai Desai HUF held such reopening is borrowed satisfaction.
No evidence of assessee’s involvement in price rigging or accommodation entry
- Merely because there was price rigging in Kushal Tradelink does not mean every investor is a beneficiary.
- No broker link or statement produced.
- No cash trail, no off-market deals.
Genuine transactions established by assessee
- Shares purchased through SEBI registered broker.
- Payments through bank, reflected in demat.
- Regular investor, not one-off transaction.
- AO did not point out any defect in documents.
Revenue failed to rebut evidence
- Once assessee discharged onus, burden shifted to Revenue.
- Revenue brought no contrary material.
Addition based on suspicion & general allegation
- AO made addition on presumption, conjecture & general investigation report.
- Such addition cannot stand without concrete evidence.
Conclusion of Tribunal:
- LTCG addition of ₹23,59,580 deleted.
- Commission addition of ₹1,41,575 u/s 69C also deleted.
- Entire assessment addition unsustainable in law & facts.
FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ITAT AHMEDABAD
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.


