Shiv Hari Singla Vs ITO (ITAT Delhi)
Sundry Creditors Not Bogus When Purchases & Sales Accepted – ITAT Delhi Deletes Addition of ₹3.36 Cr
Assessee, an individual contractor engaged in installation, erection & maintenance of air-conditioning systems for MES & private parties, declared income of ₹13.37 lakh with turnover of ₹6.44 crore. AO during scrutiny noted huge sundry creditors of ₹9.06 crore & treated balances of four parties (₹3.36 crore) as bogus since notices issued u/s 131 were unserved & Inspector reported shops as closed. AO added this sum as income from undisclosed sources, assessing total income at ₹3.62 crore.
CIT(A) partly allowed Assessee’s appeal but confirmed addition of ₹3.36 crore holding purchases from the four creditors as not proved.
Assessee’s Arguments before Tribunal
- Books were produced & accepted, no defects pointed out.
- Trading results & sales were accepted; hence corresponding purchases cannot be disallowed.
- Detailed evidences filed including ledgers, invoices, VAT returns, challans evidencing movement of goods, confirmations & affidavits of creditors.
- During remand proceedings creditors themselves replied u/s 133(6), confirming supplies & outstanding balances; VAT Department also verified their returns.
- Part-payments were made later through banking channel; in one case, creditor even sued for recovery of dues.
Revenue’s Stand
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




